4 ms·
This Congress? If they do anything, it will be to enact legislation to make what's going on appear more legal, in a chorus of harumphs.
by a3n 13y ago
This Congress?
If they do anything, it will be to enact legislation to make what's going on appear more legal, in a chorus of harumphs.
- gavinlynch 13y agoExactly. The last time there was an open debate (en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Information_Awareness_Office) about mass surveillance, Congress realized it was a bad issue with the public. So what did they do? Government simply moved these programs into black budgets or granted retro-active immunity, or modified the FISA rules to make sure everything fit into a legal framework that is Congress Approved. They wrote the laws and fund the programs. They want these programs. Why would they care to have a public debate about them?
- rfnslyr 13y agoIs it possible for my belief in congress to reach negative numbers?
- wavefunction 13y agoAnd self-congratulations, don't forget those! "Congress has shown once again a remarkable willingness to reach across party lines to ensure that no problem is ever reported again. Time for a raise!" I believe that government can work well for us, it's just the individuals in there now in both major parties are by-and-large the worst sorts we could hope for real oversight.
- dllthomas 13y agoOversight of secret programs by elected officials flat doesn't work, in a system where money plays such a big role. The only ones who can speak on the issue (with dollars) are those who know about it, and the only ones who know about it are those asking for the power or the contract.
- wavefunction 13y agoI've seen it work in real life, so I'm afraid I'm going to have to disagree.
- dllthomas 13y agoYou've "seen" oversight by elected officials reliably protect against abuses in a secret program? What was your role?
- wavefunction 13y agoCitizen only. I would cite Sens. Wyden and Udall as reliably working within the system to expose the abuses in a strategic manner, knowing how powerful the forces arrayed against them are. Now certainly you can disagree with me and say that they should have exposed everything they knew about the programs to the public, but I think their work over the years has been more productive that that. Had they gone public, they probably would have been replaced by other individuals all too interested in quid pro quo.
- dllthomas 13y agoMy point is slightly different - Wyden and Udall have been great in public, on this issue. My point is we have no way of telling whether their walk matches their talk behind closed doors. Hopefully it does, but I am not confident we can count on it. You've not observed it, you've observed what you think and hope is it - it may be, but it's not evidence until we know.