4 ms·
Please explain to me how a "constitutional amendment creating an explicit right to privacy" would do fuck all if the only body that assesses constitutionality w
by dllthomas 13y ago
Please explain to me how a "constitutional amendment creating an explicit right to privacy" would do fuck all if the only body that assesses constitutionality won't allow us to complain when that right is breached.
- anigbrowl 13y agoYou're allowed to complain, but they may not agree that your complaint has any merit. You don't seem like the sort of person who's into changing their mind though, so I don't really know what to tell you. You could try checking out some books on Constitutional law from the library to get a better understanding of how this works.
- dllthomas 13y agoYou did not address my point. "It won't happen because the court does not believe you have any rights that have been violated" is something that can be fixed by a constitutional amendment granting an explicit right to privacy, but seems to me a different claim than "it's just politics," and the court has supported a right to privacy in the past (though it's complicated). Obviously, the court may or may not consider us to have a right to privacy, may not consider the right to extend that far, &c, &c. Those still seem qualitatively different than what you'd lead with. What am I actually missing? I fucking love changing my mind, but it takes actually convincing me, not simply argument from authority without even any credentials given. "Go read a bunch of books" is bad form (doubly so with no particular recommendations) - I have plenty on my reading list as it stands.