3 ms·
1) It's a needlessly dramatic hypothetical, but it was chosen by the author of the paper not read into it (or, so far as I've found, prompted) by others. 2) Th
by dllthomas 13y ago
1) It's a needlessly dramatic hypothetical, but it was chosen by the author of the paper not read into it (or, so far as I've found, prompted) by others.
2) There's a distinction between what the President can do when Congress and the courts have not spoken on a topic, and what the President can do when they have. Is it obvious that Congress could not, in principle, forbid the use of nuclear weapons? The government needs to be able to place checks on itself and especially on any individual within it. I would argue for similar reasons that constitutional protections continue to apply in wartime - the last clause in the Third Amendment is pretty toothless otherwise.
- rayiner 13y agoThere is a distinction between how Congress and the courts can check the President's power domestically, and how it can do so internationally. John Woo's point is that the courts cannot tell the President how to treat foreigners on foreign soil during war time. The Constitution continues to apply in war time, of course, but the Constitution is silent on the subject of interrogation methods for foreign soldiers. Moreover, while torture may be in contravention of a treaty, it is not necessarily the case that the courts may supervise every executive or Congressional action for conformance with treaty obligations. People like John Woo argue that the courts were not designed to be the preeminent branch. That is to say, they were not designed so they could second-guess every single action of the Congress or the Executive, even in domains like foreign policy where the Constitution conspicuously gives the President and Congress certain powers but none to the judiciary. John Woo thinks it's legal for the President to torture children (non-Americans on non-U.S. soil mind you) not because he thinks torturing children is morally justified in some way, but because he thinks that the voting public is the body that is empowered to impose consequences for such actions, not the un-elected judiciary.
- euroclydon 13y agoImpeachment could be a swift and direct remedy also.
- dllthomas 13y agoI don't know that I object to the notion that impeachment is required as well (absent it, a president could just pardon themselves anyway) but I don't think punishment should be restricted to impeachment in the face of serious abuses.
- dllthomas 13y agoRight, and I wholeheartedly reject that notion. A person who orders the crushing of the testicles of a child - on any soil - should be facing criminal charges, and criminal charges cannot happen without the courts. If our reading of our founding documents (and interpretations since then) don't permit that, our reading needs to change or the documents do. To hold that this is the case, and not be loudly advocating for amendment, is fundamentally an attack on basic human dignity and anything resembling rights of those abroad.
- dllthomas 13y agoOn a lighter aside: People like John Woo argue that audiences like movies with slow-motion doves flying in front of explosions. People like John Yoo are the people we were talking about.
- twoodfin 13y agoCongress can prevent the use of nuclear weapons by refusing to fund their production. They might very well be able to prevent torture by making it a military crime. There's obviously a spectrum here, as Congress almost certainly couldn't make it a crime to take a particular village as an end run around the President's authority as Commander in Chief. This is not a logic puzzle, it's checks and balances.