2 ms·
Because the first amendment does not apply to private property? It's completely irrelevant. Here, the judge is rightfully trying to avoid having someone try to
by DannyBee 13y ago
Because the first amendment does not apply to private property?
It's completely irrelevant.
Here, the judge is rightfully trying to avoid having someone try to confuse a lay jury about the law. Otherwise, he'd have to spend a lot of time trying to cut off the lawyer, or write up very complex jury instructions explaining first amendment law, when it's simply not relevant at all to private property, or this case.
There are certainly cases of vandalism of private property where it may even be an issue (if the property involved was owned by people acting as agents of the state/federal government, etc), but this isn't one of them.
Honestly, the fact that this question is being asked repeatedly proves the judge's point: People don't understand where and when the first amendment applies, and where it clearly doesn't, the only possible outcome is to confuse the jury.