3 ms·
Wow, the article managed to explain the comment that I had been holding out as the most ridiculous comment ever. And I understand why it was said. The comment
by btilly 13y ago
Wow, the article managed to explain the comment that I had been holding out as the most ridiculous comment ever. And I understand why it was said.
The comment was that it would violate the privacy of Americans to try to figure out how many Americans were under surveillance.
The key to understanding this is that the NSA believes that it can avoid having to follow the 4th as long as it never intentionally "searches Americans" by doing any analysis on data collected about identified Americans, and immediately throwing away analysis already done once the identification was made.
Figuring out how many Americans had been caught up in the dragnet would require doing analysis on identified Americans. That triggers the protection of the 4th, and can only be done under their legal theories with a real warrant. Which they don't have. Therefore attempting to answer that question really does cross the line that they have set for what is and is not legal.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- enraged_camel 13y agoAt this point everyone knows that the NSA cares very, very little about what is legal or not. They are confident that Obama will cover their asses in any way he can, and any judge that tries to rule against them - including the Supreme Court judges - will be branded an activist terrorist-lover.
- pjmlp 13y agoMaybe that is my European view, but how can anyone seriously expected secret services to respect any laws?
- mtgx 13y agoThat doesn't mean they shouldn't be punished when found to be abusing their powers, though. Otherwise we might as well agree to having a shadow government in our democracies, and be fine with it.
- Qantourisc 13y agoNope it's not European view, it's yours. Unless you men "secret" with no oversight and such, so there is no judge on if they are following the law.
- pjmlp 13y agoLike a few European countries in the last century, I got to enjoy what a dictatorship means, secret services don't follow the law, they make the law.
- btilly 13y agoAt this point everyone knows that the NSA cares very, very little about what is legal or not. Actually I don't know that. My inclination would be to assume that. But the Snowden leaks are showing an organization which has come up with an interpretation of what is legal, and is following their interpretation exactly to the letter. The first fear is that in any such arrangement their interpretation of what is legal and what anyone else will think is is legal will differ. The second is that over time they will find ways to come up with ever more extreme interpretations. And the final one, of course, is that eventually the safeguards get disregarded. But for the moment they have gone to lengths to stay within their interpretation of the law. While recognizing and criticizing them on the rest, it is worth acknowledging that current (and somewhat surprising) reality.