2 ms·
Anybody else notice the contradiction here? The idea was to try to lure some of the talented software engineers who had been laid off on Wall Street It turns
by gruseom 18y ago
Anybody else notice the contradiction here?
The idea was to try to lure some of the talented software engineers who had been laid off on Wall Street
It turns out that the learning curve was too steep for many financial engineers
How talented can they be?
- TriinT 18y agoWell... since when are financial engineers supposed to be good software developers? Even if you're mega-smart, it's virtually impossible to be an expert in pricing derivatives and, simultaneously, an expert in writing code. Some quants were good at coding before they became quants, but as soon as you has some minions hacking for you, your coding skills deteriorate amazingly fast.
- pierrealexandre 18y agoMost of the quants have to code themselves. Some of them have PhD/MS from the best CS departments. Very few of them have an army of "minions hacking for [them]". That doesn't automatically mean they develop superior sofftware development skills, but I think your comment misrepresents the reality.
- TriinT 18y agoYou are right. I know some quants who have a couple of younger coders to help them with the implementation, but most of them have to code stuff on their own. Sometimes it's "quantish" code like numerical PDEs and SDEs (which is what quants should be doing), other times one has to create GUI's and such stuff which an enthusiastic teenager is more qualified to do than a PhD...
- gruseom 18y agosince when are financial engineers supposed to be good software developers The context makes it clear that he's talking about the same people.
- menloparkbum 18y agoHis initial premise, that laid-off wall streeters would flock to startups, was flawed in many ways. - the tech stack on wall street is totally different than most startups. On Wall Street it's Windows, Solaris, C++ and EXCEL. At most startups, its uh... not those things. - most startups don't actually need statistical heavyweights. the whole "analytics" thing he is talking about is a small part of MOST startups. that kind of thing is bigger at google and paypal and after the startup is already successful and has millions of users per hour. - the actually programmers on wall street are the last ones to get fired - the financial risk situation is wildly different. on wall street it's $150K base + bonus. at a startup it's $60-$80K + worthless equity. To most wall streeters it's worth waiting around an extra 9 months to see if they can get another $150K job. - the startups in NYC largely suck, anyway. it's not like actual startup programmers are flocking to them, either.
- gruseom 18y agoThat's a much more sensible explanation than the article gives. My point was more superficial: the statements I quoted are contradictory, or at least oxymoronic, because software talent is largely the ability to go through learning curves.
- menloparkbum 18y agoThey are indeed contradictory statements. In this case, I think he's simply wrong. I've met many startup founders in silicon valley who had worked at places like morgan stanley and goldman sachs. Fred Wilson's just upset that they aren't working at HIS startups. And why would they? The pay is bad (compared to wall street, or even working at google), the startups are dumb and there's not even much theoretical upside.