3 ms·
At the moment, the attack is not yet practical because it requires access to millions and possibly billions of copies of the same data encrypted using different
by jrochkind1 13y ago
At the moment, the attack is not yet practical because it requires access to millions and possibly billions of copies of the same data encrypted using different keys. A browser would have to make that many connections to a server to give the attacker enough data. A possible exploitation path is to somehow instrument the browser to make a large number of connections, while a man in the middle is observing and recording the traffic.
Does it need to be a single browser? If you have recorded a substantial portion of internet traffic (as the NSA has), and thus you have connections from a bunch of different browsers to a popular SSL/https web page, and the server (during a given time period) returns the exact same response (it's static web page) to all of them (or a portion of them and you can figure out which portion)....
?
I can think of a bunch of different reasons this would NOT work, but (or 'and') I'm also not neccesarily an expert and don't entirely understand this stuff, so I'm not sure either way, just wondering.
- CaveTech 13y agoWouldn't depend on the browser. Any top level network would have access to everything they need.
- tptacek 13y agoExplain how that would work, in as much detail as you can.
- Skalman 13y agoBut... aren't headers also encrypted? Won't the "Date: Thu, 27 Jun 2013 14:20:43 GMT" header make it unlikely that there will be more than x000 copies of the exact same data encrypted?
- sdevlin 13y agoRC4 is a stream cipher. This means you have a stream of key bytes and a stream of plaintext bytes. You pair these up and XOR each pair together to get a stream of ciphertext bytes. The key stream is generated independently of the plaintext, so the attacker really only cares that the bytes he's interested in (i.e. session cookies) stay at the same offset in the stream.
- sdevlin 13y agoTypically the secret data you're interested in is specific to a particular user. Session cookies, for example. (Not saying this is universally true, this is just the scenario I think is on most people's minds.) If the traffic is common to everyone, the NSA could just browse to the site.
- tptacek 13y agoYes, it needs to be from a single browser.