11 ms·
Ecuador offers U.S. rights aid, waives trade benefits
- pvnick 13y agoNice! That's a classy move right there. Edit: further context: >Sen. Robert Menendez, D-N.J., head of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, promised Wednesday that he would block renewal of the pact should Snowden be granted asylum. >"Our government will not reward countries for bad behavior," he said in a statement, following other lawmakers who have spent years saying that the pact should be allowed to lapse, partly down to the country's links with Iran. [1] If my tentative understanding of events is correct, this economic act of aggression (which would have hurt innocent civilians - does the US even care about that anymore?) was the main form of likely retaliation the US would have pulled in response to Snowden being granted asylum. Preempting this move by giving up the preferential treatment is, IMO, a very astute move by the Ecuadorian government, and puts America in a position of not having that leg to stand on. [1] http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/06/26/us-usa-security-snowden-congress-idUSBRE95P1DR20130626 http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/06/26/us-usa-security-sn...
- mpyne 13y agoWell it's always better to go "You can't fire me! I QUIT!" as you get booted from the door. > (which would have hurt innocent civilians - does the US even care about that anymore?) There are two sides to that particular story bub, and only one side has taken actual action so far to hurt those civilians... and it was the government charged with protecting those same civilians. So what you're basically saying is that Ecuador has decided to harm their own innocent civilians in order to head toward granting asylum to a U.S. citizen to poke their thumb in Uncle Sam's face (again).
- lucian1900 13y agoThey are standing up against the bully that is the US. That is a service to their own citizens and those of various other countries around the world.
- twoodfin 13y agoIn what sense? If a member of the Ecuadorian opposition party infiltrated their government and stole classified information, then fled to the United States, wouldn't they demand to get him back?
- antoko 13y agoThe US didn't demand him back (and he isn't even there yet). They are threatening to remove some economic benefit that is completely unrelated to the issue at hand to coerce the Ecuadorean government to fall in line. That's pretty obviously bullying, and the Ecuadorean government has simply called uncle sam's bluff.
- mpyne 13y ago"Economic benefits" are generally not free. Why should the U.S. reward a country that has shown a willingness to embarrass them on the world stage (twice, now) when there are a hundred other countries that would be just as deserving (not to mention the millions of Americans here at home who could benefit from a bit of largesse)?
- eliasmacpherson 13y agoyour best friends are the ones that are allowed to tell you what you are like. the people who don't do that, they are not your best friends.
- mpyne 13y agoIf I believed for a second that Ecuador's government had genuine friendship-based concern for the U.S. and its actions I think I'd agree with you. But that's not what this is.
- PavlovsCat 13y agoThat doesn't change the fact that the more any entity relies on threats, the less it can have have real friends. This is like the physics of relationships and just how it is. Wether or not it applies here doesn't even matter for it being generally true, and the US seems to threaten friend and foe alike, if in doubt. Why, it even treats its own citizens like subjects quite often.
- corresation 13y agoWell it's always better to go "You can't fire me! I QUIT!" as you get booted from the door. Ecuador hasn't yet taken in Snowden. So no, your analogy doesn't fit: They are rejecting bullying outright.
- atwebb 13y agoAlso, it's often not better to say that.
- TallGuyShort 13y agoAgreed - but a better parallel to this situation is if you suspect you will be fired soon, to leave with dignity of your own accord beforehand.
- dllthomas 13y agoIt feels satisfying to go "You can't fire me! I QUIT!" but it's usually a bad idea. Removing a point of leverage before its attempted use is a slightly different scenario, though.
- jeremyflores 13y ago> only one side has taken actual action so far to hurt those civilians... and it was the government charged with protecting those same civilians. A meaningless technicality. You can't seriously be arguing that the US' continued hegemonic paternalism toward Ecuador isn't a major source of their population's problems.
- dspillett 13y ago> * which would have hurt innocent civilians - does the US even care about that anymore?* There own innocent civilians? Generally yes, though they consider them all to be potentially not at all innocent. Other country's innocent civilians? Not unless it is politically or industrially/commercially expedient to seem to care. This has always been the case, and is the same for any other power.
- CWuestefeld 13y agoI'm ashamed to say that Menendez is my ass of a senator. For the American people, this is also adding insult to injury. This punishment doesn't only hit the Ecuadorian people, it also hits Americans. Not only are we being spied on, but in the government's fight for its authority to spy, it's also now forbidding Americans from purchasing products that they want (or forcing us to pay higher prices). Menendez either (a) doesn't understand economics well enough to understand that in trade both sides profit; or (b) really does view this as a war [of the US government] against the American people. Personally, I think it's likely that both are true. I'll be writing him another letter, this time saying not only that isn't PRISM and other domestic spying unacceptable, but that the necessary remedy is, at a minimum, the repeal of USA PATRIOT and of the AUMF. EDIT: clarify third paragraph
- blueprint 13y agoWhat result do you expect from writing such a letter if he is participating in a war against you?
- johneth 13y ago> or (b) really does view this as a war against the American people I think CWuestefeld meant that the senator thinks that Ecuador's snub to the US regarding Edward Snowden is the 'war' - not that he and the US government is waging war against the American people.
- samstave 13y agoWell, I am of the opinion that the USG is at war wit the American people.
- CWuestefeld 13y agoNo, I really do view this as the American government at war against the American people.
- johneth 13y ago
- melling 13y agoHow should the US punish Ecuador? Assume you are in the government and your job is to try and get Ecuador to hand over someone? Clearly going to war is off the table. By the way, Ecuador is a cool country. It's quite poor and they use the US dollar. I spent several weeks in Quito and everyone was quite friendly.
- nitrogen 13y agoWhy should the US punish Ecuador? When did the US become the worldwide punishment police?
- melling 13y agoSaying "I wouldn't do anything" isn't an answer. You are running a country and you want a "crimminal" returned to the US for prosecution. This isn't the first time in history that this has happened. And the US isn't the only country that does stuff like this. If this happened in China, the UK, Russia, France, etc., I think they'd want their guy back too. From the WSJ: Mr. Obama said he hasn't called Russian President Vladimir Putin or Chinese President Xi Jinping concerning Mr. Snowden, who has been charged by U.S. authorities with stealing and passing on government secrets. President Barack Obama dismissed the idea of using the U.S. military to pursue NSA leaker Edward Snowden. "I shouldn't have to," Mr. Obama said, addressing a question raised during a news conference with Senegalese President Macky Sall. "This is something that is routine."
- resu_nimda 13y agoWell, you asked what they should do. They should make their case diplomatically and non-threateningly, and hope that they can persuade Ecuador to agree. If they can't, they should respect that this "criminal" is outside of their jurisdiction and there's nothing they can do. They should not attempt to leverage their size and muscle to force compliance, like a bully or tyrant. Of course, as you noted, it never works like that, here or anywhere else.
- 13y ago
- Roboprog 13y agoIt's too bad Snowden didn't go to China. The parallel would be funny: China - we don't care about our favored trade/tariff status! (as if); US Govt - up yours, import taxes then! (as if).
- diminoten 13y agoWhen does it become a not classy move? What if he kicks out all currently present US nationals from his country? What if he shuts down the US embassy in Quito? What if he takes military action against the US? When do I stop getting excited when someone hurts my country?
- malandrew 13y agoI think a better question to ask is what is reasonable and fair to expect my country to do on my behalf. I'm all for the USG to try to improve the position economically and politically in the world so long as they respect certain bounds of decency while doing so. Spying the the politicians and citizens of other countries in order to gain advantage is not decent or fair, the same way you wouldn't want your boss or your co-workers to spy on you to keep you from a raise or promotion. The US, China, Russia and the UK are among the biggest sociopaths insofar as countries interacting with other countries go. I'm not proud of that, and I would hope we could meet with other countries and their leaders on a fair playing field and discuss things as adults instead or resorting to bullying.
- diminoten 13y agoRegardless of what the US does, it's not, in my opinion, something to cheer or be excited about when another country acts aggressively towards the US (to a citizen, anyway; feel however you want about it if you're not a citizen). What it crosses to me is the boundary between loyalty to one's leaders and loyalty to one's country. Obama is going after Snowden, and I can either support or not support that action, that's my right as a citizen. But when another country takes action against my country, that suddenly becomes an act of agression directed at me, and every other citizen of the US. That's not "nice", or "classy" at all.
- malandrew 13y agoAnd what is your opinion of the act of aggression of the NSA towards you and every other US citizen by surveilling you without a warrant? Ecuador is providing protection to a whistleblower that is trying to help you question an unconstitutional program and reign in abuses. In a way that makes Ecuador a greater defender of the US Constitution than the USG. I don't know about you, but my loyalty is to the system of governance and rights laid out by the Constitution before some amorphous geographic shape determined by natural boundaries and history. I see Ecuador as helping the person that is helping protect the Constitution. I don't necessarily know their motivations or agree with the reason they may be acting the way they are, but I do know that the World needs more people like Snowden, and people willing to go to bat for Snowden, if we are going to be able to defend the Bill of Rights and other documents/policies outlining basic human rights. P.S. Threatening economic sanctions isn't "nice" or "classy" either. The US is as guilty as Ecuador for making this into an adversarial tete-a-tete.
- brown9-2 13y agoSo when the US severs these ties, it's an "economic act of aggression" and it "hurt[s] innocent civilians". But when Ecuador does this preemptively, it's an astute move?
- tankenmate 13y agoIt's a wise man that gives up what he cannot hope to keep for something he can't lose.
- consonants 13y ago> (which would have hurt innocent civilians - does the US even care about that anymore?) No. This is a standard tactic the US has used to economically intimidate Latin/South America for political, but usually economic reasons. After the disaster in Haiti, the government decided to raise taxes on gas/oil exports(forget really) to help recovery, but that would affect our profit margins so we threatened them economically into submission. I believe something similar happened with raising the minimum wage by a few cents for textile workers in Haiti, but there was no way in hell we'd have that.* Menendez represents me. Not that I'm surprised that he'd protect his monied interests over the welfare of innocents or anything. *edit: found the source http://www.theatlanticwire.com/politics/2011/06/us-haiti-wikileaks-minimum-wage-petrocaribe/38579/ http://www.theatlanticwire.com/politics/2011/06/us-haiti-wik...
- fspeech 13y agoEcuador's fight against Chevron is likely the largest obstacle to the renewal of the trade preference, not Snowden. Ecuador likely opted to retain the claim for potential billions instead of the trade privilege allegedly worth $23 millions. [edit] Wikipedia reference: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lago_Agrio_oil_field http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lago_Agrio_oil_field
- joonix 13y agoRight, screw over thousands of merchants and workers in your country so a few at the top can make names for themselves as "rebels" ... does that sound like leftism or being "for the people?" What exactly does giving up all this to house Snowden do for the average Ecuadorian? It increases the profile of the leadership, but that's about it.
- pessimizer 13y agoWhy have values when preferential treatment is at risk, right?
- dllthomas 13y agoThere are markets other than the US.
- scaredbythensa 13y agoSince all our freedom is for sale, right?
- antoko 13y agoYou seem to be assuming that if the US doesn't buy those flowers then no one will and they'll just rot. That seems unlikely. Given that they've also offered $23m for Human Right's training It seems likely they can afford to lose the $23m since they're effectively doubling that 'loss'. Is it grandstanding? sure, but if you agree with human rights it is exactly the right kind of grandstanding. Also, I have no problem with people considering themselves humans before they consider themselves members of a nation-state, even government officials of a nation-state.
- gwern 13y ago> You seem to be assuming that if the US doesn't buy those flowers then no one will and they'll just rot. That seems unlikely. At the margin, it seems incredibly likely. You don't cut yourself off from the largest wealthiest market in the hemisphere and continue to sell exactly as many flowers as before at exactly as high a price...
- mynegation 13y agoEcuador will have no problem finding buyers for oil, its main export. But flower and fruit merchants will suffer consequences.
- toomuchtodo 13y agoCorrect. More sales to Canada.
- schiffern 13y agoI don't know about you, but I'm calling flower merchants and buying Fair-Trade Ecuadorian flowers. Facebook needs some "Made in Ecuador" stickers methinks.
- znowi 13y agoIf western countries had enough balls to stand up against the US demands, maybe it would not turn into such a bully. It's our indifference that led us to wars, drones, surveillance, etc. Not a single country would be allowed to act this way.
- criley2 13y agoOh pah-leeze. The "Five Eyes" western electronic surveillance alliance leaked by Snowden is: UK, USA, Canada, NZ, Australia. The Western countries aren't poor victims, most of the big players are complicit allies! And to boot: We've learned that our "Five Eyes" partners, like the UK, are engaging in worse surveillance than the US! The UK organization boasts broader data collection, deeper records and less judicial oversight than their American counterparts. This isn't a "America running roughshod over the West" story like you're pretending, it's a "the western governments are colluding against their citizens" story. Oh -- wait, sorry, this thread is clearly an anti-America circlejerk. Keep pretending everyone is innocent except the USA! Carry on!
- Mordor 13y agoOh, they won't bother when it's clear they need China more than the US.
- cpursley 13y ago" Not a single country would be allowed to act this way." Going point.
- gscott 13y agoApparently we are sharing data with Australia and Britain so likely many others too. They don't need to spy on their populations when we will do it for them and give them the data.
- ewbuoi 13y agoApparently this has been common since at least the cold war.
- andrewcooke 13y agogreat. now the us is going to find a way to fuck up another south american country.
- drawkbox 13y agoWould have it just been easier to pardon Snowden, bring him back home, never allow him to work with a security clearance again or do we just have to be that hardline that we just caused lots of anguish? Has the non-pardoning/hardline caused more damage here? If he truly has more damning information, as the state department, wouldn't you want to contain that by bringing him back without fear of being detained? Unless in some parallel Snowden is still in the CIA and we wanted to check HK, Russia and now Ecuador regime with a spy that would be excused due to the leaks (might also learn more about WikiLeaks). In the end, our enemies knowing we track everything hasn't really hurt them, it just let them know the long arm is longer than they expected or they knew it already. The only people it hurt were innocent Americans that now have assurance everything is being tracked, US cloud business trust and now poor farmers in Ecuador. Seems it could have been handled better.
- roc 13y agoThe US Government's concern is that if Snowden gets off light other whistleblowers will step forward. That's the root logic behind the 'war on whistleblowers'. Which strongly suggests "we ain't seen nothin yet." That's a big part of why Manning was treated so horribly and without any sense of proportion to what he did. It simply wasn't (all) about him. It was about the people who might be thinking of following in his footsteps.
- Joeri 13y agoAstute point you're making that if they're this concerned about additional whistleblowers, then there must be a lot out there that is worse than what we've heard so far. This isn't just about wiretapping, because that aspect couldn't be worse than we've heard so far.
- roc 13y agoWell, Snowden alleges warrantless wiretapping, but didn't have evidence of that. [1] A subsequent whistle-blower bringing proof that it wasn't just possible, but that it was done (routinely), would be worse. Particularly if they had proof of warrantless wiretaps done for bureaucratic/political reasons. [2] Similarly, if there was proof that no real effort is being expended to identify citizen data vs non-citizen data, it would be 'worse'. At least in the eyes of those who are following the traditional media account and are still giving the government the benefit of the doubt and buying their defenses. [3] [1] At least he hadn't presented any, thus far. Just a document outlining the technical capability of bulk copy and 'intercept' existed and his assertion that he could initiate those intercepts without any oversight, let alone legal basis. [2] Which is something alleged by another whistle-blower, but again, without iron-clad proof. Which is apparently what you absolutely have to have, for the mainstream media to pay any attention to the story. (And even then, they'll probably just talk about you, personally.) [3] Despite those defenses having to be walked back time and again for containing falsehoods and no corrected defenses being offered.
- A__MJ 13y agoThe best part: "In a cheeky jab at the U.S. spying program that Snowden unveiled through leaks to the media, the South American nation offered $23 million per year to finance human rights training."
- quantumpotato_ 13y agoWhere is this offer for human rights training? Googling only shows me references to the Reuters link. Has anyone seen an Ecuadorian press release?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- lhnz 13y agoThis plus this [0] point towards the US having given up trying to get Snowden. Maybe Wikileaks has won this one. [0] http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2013/jun/27/obama-edward-snowden-wheeling-dealing http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2013/jun/27/obama-edward-sno...
- tootie 13y agoJust browsing wikipedia, it seems that the man riding in on his white horse has sent journalists to prison for writing unflattering editorials about him.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- dnautics 13y agothat's why he said "mercantile interests" and not "political interests". It is such an odd choice for the president, while the US does engage in blatant and unethical mercantile coercion around the world, the snowden case is one where the US' sins are almost purely political, and its actions are coming at a cost to its economic position.
- jackmaney 13y ago<Grumpy Cat Meme> Good! </Grumpy Cat Meme>
- muyuu 13y agoBold and classy of them not to cave in to American terror.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- blueprint 13y agoAs a citizen and long-time resident of US, I hereby accept Ecuador's offer for human rights aid.
- saosebastiao 13y agoForget the Ecuadorean response, WTF with the US response to the Ecuadorean response? Trade is mutually beneficial, idiots.
- grecy 13y agoGreat! Many countries have bowed to US demands in the last years due to threat of losing trade benefits. After the Australian Prime Minister agreed to (illegally) send troops into Iraq with Dubya, 16 US Trade Negotiators came to Australia within a week and negotiated previously unseen trade deals to benefit Australia. When questioned directly about this, the Australian Prime Minister shrugged and said "What was I going to do?" After living in South America for a year, I'm very excited to see those countries develop more and more, and reject US rule and meddling more and more.
- mark_l_watson 13y agoI just tried going to Amazon.com and searching for "Ecuador crafts". I have several birthday presents to buy over the next few months, and I am thinking that craft items from Ecuador might be things people will enjoy. I consider myself a patriotic USA citizen, but our government's cracking down on whistle blowers in the last 4 or 5 years has really gone too far. Our laws + punishments for whistle blowers is way out of whack with the rest of the world (I think the crimes Snowden is accused of carry a maximum sentence of 2 years in the UK, and less in most other European countries).
- ender89 13y agoI kind of love Ecuador for that move.