4 ms·
It is constantly surprising to me how nearly-deterministic these votes are: each respective quartet of the court votes along what's seen as party lines, with Ke
by danso 13y ago
It is constantly surprising to me how nearly-deterministic these votes are: each respective quartet of the court votes along what's seen as party lines, with Kennedy being the swing vote. Is it because the court really is that partisan, or because the technicalities and details in each case fall sharply along judicial philosophical lines? With life terms, it's not as if the justices need to vote a certain way to keep office.
- jansanchez 13y agoKennedy isn't always the swing vote. Sometimes Roberts is the swing vote.
- ceejayoz 13y agoRoberts has generally been considered the swing vote in cases where he needs to sort of fall-on-his-sword to preserve the non-partisan appearance of the court. The Obamacare ruling was one such case.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Roberts has generally been considered the swing vote in cases where he needs to sort of fall-on-his-sword to preserve the non-partisan appearance of the court. I think this is a fairly strained interpretation to try to defend the idea that the court is iron-locked into the "liberal 4" + "conservative 4" + Kennedy divide (casting a different divide as Roberts trying to create an illusion about the court), and it falls down when you have high profile cases like the today's Hollingsworth v. Perry [1] where the majority is made up of Roberts, Scalia, Ginsberg, Breyer, and Kagan. [1] http://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/12pdf/12-144_8ok0.pdf http://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/12pdf/12-144_8ok0.pdf
- darkarmani 13y ago> Roberts has generally been considered the swing vote in cases where he needs to sort of fall-on-his-sword to preserve the non-partisan appearance of the court. Why? So he doesn't have a problem getting "re-elected?" I'm not sure why you think he is worried about the appearance of the court in that way.
- ceejayoz 13y agoThe Court's power lies in its perceived integrity and being above the fray of election-driven politics. If it appears partisan, it risks being marginalized. Remember, the Court gave itself the powers it has in Marbury vs. Madison, and has at times had folks like Jackson go "let them enforce it". If public opinion turns against the Court, politicians can as well.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 13y ago> It is constantly surprising to me how nearly-deterministic these votes are, each respective quartet of the court votes along what's seen as party lines, with Kennedy being the swing vote I think there is probably a bit of confirmation bias and media distortion here; plenty of Supreme Court decisions, even on high profile topics, aren't 5-4 or are 5-4 but don't break "conservative 4" + "liberal 4" + Kennedy (e.g., the decision uphold the Affordable Care Act [1] was 5-4, with Roberts plus the four liberals in the majority, and the four remaining conservatives, including Kennedy, in the minority.) But for the months the case was before the Supreme Court, the media was harping on how it was bound to be 5-4 with Kennedy as the swing vote, so what do you think sticks more in people's minds -- the actual result that was highlighted on the day of the decision and then dropped, or the "everyone knows" that was a focus of attention for months? And, on the decision letting stand the District Court decision [2] striking down Prop. 8 in California based on the Prop. 8 supporters lack of standing to appeal the decision, also announced today, the 5-4 decision had Roberts, Scalia, Ginsberg, Breyer, and Kagan in the majority with Kennedy, Thomas, Alito, and Sotomayor in the minority. [1] NFIB v. Sebelius, http://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/11pdf/11-393c3a2.pdf http://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/11pdf/11-393c3a2.pdf [2] Hollingworth v. Perry, http://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/12pdf/12-144_8ok0.pdf http://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/12pdf/12-144_8ok0.pdf
- aaronbrethorst 13y agoThere's a lot of speculation that Roberts' vote swung the way it did because he was concerned about public perception of SCOTUS in general, and the Roberts Court legacy in particular. It's apparently a 'well-known fact' at this point that Roberts switched his vote at the last minute on the ACA ruling.
- tptacek 13y agoThe Prop 8 standing decision was Roberts, Scalia, Breyer, Ginsburg, and Kagan.
- rickhanlonii 13y agoRight, and the Prop 8 decision was procedural rather than ideological. They essentially ruled (for the first and only time) that a private party (here, the Prop 8 proponents) is not allowed to defend the constitutionality of a law--the State is required to make that argument. Since the state declined to defend the law at lower courts, SCOTUS sent it back to that court with directions to dismiss it. From Amy Howe at the SCOTUS Blog: "Here's a Plain English take on Hollingsworth v. Perry, the challenge to the constitutionality of California's Proposition 8, which bans same-sex marriage: After the two same-sex couples filed their challenge to Proposition 8 in federal court in California, the California government officials who would normally have defended the law in court, declined to do so. So the proponents of Proposition 8 stepped in to defend the law, and the California Supreme Court (in response to a request by the lower court) ruled that they could do so under state law. But today the Supreme Court held that the proponents do not have the legal right to defend the law in court. As a result, it held, the decision by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, the intermediate appellate court, has no legal force, and it sent the case back to that court with instructions for it to dismiss the case." And since it was just posted, here is the same type of explanation for the DOMA ruling: "Here's a Plain English take on United States v. Windsor, the DOMA case: The federal Defense of Marriage Act defines "marriage," for purposes of over a thousand federal laws and programs, as a union between a man and a woman only. Today the Court ruled, by a vote of five to four, in an opinion by Justice Kennedy, that the law is unconstitutional. The Court explained that the states have long had the responsibility of regulating and defining marriage, and some states have opted to allow same-sex couples to marry to give them the protection and dignity associated with marriage. By denying recognition to same-sex couples who are legally married, federal law discriminates against them to express disapproval of state-sanctioned same-sex marriage. This decision means that same-sex couples who are legally married must now be treated the same under federal law as married opposite-sex couples."
- dragonwriter 13y ago
- rayiner 13y agoScalia had a good comment on the Supreme Court's alleged partisanship. He said: justices are selected for their distinct judicial philosophies. Is it a surprise when they vote accordingly? Also, some cases are more political than others. Most cases are not 5:4 votes. This is one of those political cases: where you come out depends on whether you view homosexuality as a protected characteristic where people's rights should trump the law as passed by the elected branches, or whether you don't view it as a protected characteristic in which case the default of deference to Congress wins out. What's interesting are the political cases where the votes don't follow the politics. Look at the vote on Hamdi v Rumsfeld. That was a very political issue at the time, but the votes came out not along party lines at all. It's also interesting to look at what happens when the parties change their positions relative to the justices they appointed. E.g. Stevens was appointed by a Republican and came out liberal. Thomas was appointed by a very moderate Republican but has come out very conservative. Roberts and Alito were both appointed by GWB, but the former has come out very moderate and the latter quite conservative.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Scalia had a good comment on the Supreme Court's alleged partisanship. He said: justices are selected for their distinct judicial philosophies. Is it a surprise when they vote accordingly? IIRC, if you assess the salience of particular political issues at the time a Justice is appointed, and then look at how they vote on those issues throughout their career, they tend to be pretty consistent with the appointing administrations views on issues that were of high salience when the justice was appointed to the Court, and less consistent the lower the salience of hte issue was at the time the justices are appointed. This tends to support the idea that justices are much more appointed for the views on high-profile issues than any kind of broad "judicial philosophy".
- rayiner 13y agoI agree with your characterization but I don't think that qualifies for the label "partisanship." Partisans would go with the political flow of their party.
- vilhelm_s 13y agoThe cases that are most reported on in media are the highly political/partisan ones, and there the votes tend to fall along partisan lines. But most of the cases decided by the court are more technical, and don't show such partisan voting. http://www.scotusblog.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/vote_split_June22.pdf http://www.scotusblog.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/06/vote_sp...