2 ms·
I don't believe the "wipe after 10 failed attempts" is enforced in hardware, but the actual encryption is. Everything got much better with the 4S/iPad 2 and la
by rdl 13y ago
I don't believe the "wipe after 10 failed attempts" is enforced in hardware, but the actual encryption is. Everything got much better with the 4S/iPad 2 and later. So, if you can get the phone to boot from your replacement image, you should be able to run arbitrary attacks against the encrypted image. This would be complex. Much much easier for Apple, and still doesn't really count as a "backdoor" in the hardware key storage itself. If you could bypass the 10 tries lockout again, you can do ~12 tries/second, so 20 minutes to defeat a simple 4-digit passcode.
I suspect someone could decap the chip itself and extract the key, at the cost of the phone (and burning a bunch of whatever chip they're using in advance to prep for the attack). That probably would be worthwhile for a conference presentation. I'm confident any decent intelligence service which doesn't have Apple's cooperation can do this now, since extracting keys from hardware is a pretty key capability for anyone doing black bag stuff. A friend of mine just started a consultancy in this space, so maybe will look at this for a presentation in 2014 if there's time.
- sneak 13y agoApple can just sign a ramdisk to boot on that phone and dump the whole flash (decrypted by the phone) over usb. Bruteforcing 10e3 numerics doesn't take long when your forensic ramdisk doesn't have any rate limiting or auto-wiping.
- rdl 13y agoThe rate limiting is the security element's speed (separate from the "too many tries" timeout and the "wipe after 10 tries" thing). Unless the security element itself has a backdoor, even Apple can't go faster than 12 tries per second. It is still about 20 minutes. But a longer pass phrase (admittedly a ux problem) helps. Plus, rumors of biometrics, which may or may not be implemented in a smart way. A biometric which allows a 4 digit pin, or if it fails, a 16 char alphanumeric, would be proper.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]