4 ms·
This is the kind of stuff I wish Wikileaks had stuck to -- mostly or completely legal, beneficial to national security, etc. They are still challenging powerfu
by rdl 13y ago
This is the kind of stuff I wish Wikileaks had stuck to -- mostly or completely legal, beneficial to national security, etc. They are still challenging powerful entities and supporting change, but without becoming the story themselves.
- camus 13y agowho made the "press" shift its attention on wikileaks rather than on the docs they leaked ? your favorite DC spin doctors. So please , dont blame the messenger , or you are as stupid as the government think you are. And they do think you are stupid , trust me.
- rdl 13y agoReleasing 250k classified documents is a news story itself, so it was inevitable that the story would shift to wikileaks. (shifting to Julian Assange was some DC spin, though, but he sure didn't help things.)
- dantheman 13y agoBut they didn't release the cables at first, they released an encrypted file. Then a journalist who didn't like wikileaks that had access to the file published the password in a book. Since the files were then available to those with resources to know about they password, they felt it was reasonable to release them completely so people could see if they were mentioned in the documents which were at that point for all intents and purposes public.
- mpyne 13y agoLikewise. I really liked WikiLeaks at the beginning but it became clear after some time that there was a definite agenda behind their actions. The impression I've had for years is that they will oppose the U.S. for no better reason than that it's the U.S. Which is, if you think about it, just like opposing any maligned group for what they are instead of what they do. In other words if we start from the assumption that the U.S. should be a "bastion of the free world" then it would make sense to tirelessly note instances where the U.S., corporations, states, etc. fall from that ideal. But diplomatic cables describing what kind of women Berlusconi likes, while interesting, are hardly indicators of the collapse of a free society. Those types of things were released because they were embarrassing, nothing more. And while I'm certainly glad that Assange is able to stroke his ego by thumbing his nose in Uncle Sam's face, I don't actually hate my country; I want it to be better.
- Amadou 13y agoI have to strongly disagree. Wikileaks has released minutiae about other countries as well. It isn't only about showing up hypocrisy from the US, it is about lifting the veil of secrecy that all governments misuse whether it is hiding big stories or trivial ones. Saying that wikileaks has an agenda to oppose the US is basically confirmation bias. Leaks about the US get news coverage in the US. Just for starters, look at the 2 million emails from Syria - clearly most of those are about trivial matters too, but most people in the US haven't even heard about the release at all.
- mpyne 13y ago> I have to strongly disagree. Wikileaks has released minutiae about other countries as well. Doing bad things to other countries (again, because of what they are instead of what they've done) doesn't make me feel better about when it's done to mine. Here's some other countries I don't hate: Russia, China, the U.K., France, South Africa and in fact the list could go on as long as I have time. > Just for starters, look at the 2 million emails from Syria - clearly most of those are about trivial matters too, but most people in the US haven't even heard about the release at all. There's no polite way for me to say this so I'll just spit it out; no one cares about Syrian government emails. That's why no one in the U.S has heard about the release. Gossip is as destructive for international politics as it is for small towns. If there's big news to release then by all means go and do so, but governments should be able to maintain diaries too.
- Amadou 13y agoI'm having a hard time understanding your point of view, it seems to have no unifying principle. But if I take your last sentence as what you really believe then the obvious response is that once governments can be relied on to not abuse their ability to keep secrets then they will have earned the privilege to maintain their diaries in secret.
- mpyne 13y agoAnd anarcho-libertarian types will claim that a government can never be relied on to do that, which is just as well as saying again that the government could not be allowed to keep secrets.