2 ms·
> A city excluding illicit competitors from using its roads "requires the use of force" no more than vindicating the right of a property owner to exclude others
by baddox 13y ago
> A city excluding illicit competitors from using its roads "requires the use of force" no more than vindicating the right of a property owner to exclude others requires the use of force as a general matter.
They key difference is not so much the use of force itself, but rather who we consider to be legitimate purveyors of force. When it comes to property rights, obviously there are many varying philosophies and codes that people adhere to, but most people who believe in any form of personal property rights believe that the owners themselves can legitimately use force to defend that property. In other words, there is no monopoly on the legitimate use of force for enforcing property rights.
Government, on the other hand, enjoys a monopoly on the legitimate use of force for many things. If a random group of people went around to every house in a region forcefully taking money in order to fund roads, hospitals, charities, etc., the vast majority of society would not see this as legitimate. Likewise, if 9 of the 10 families on your block agreed to forcefully take and use your family's house and property as they saw fit, the vast majority of society would not see this as legitimate. The fact that the majority of people in a region agreed on the use of force would not legitimize it. So government is unique in this regard: it can and does do both of those things and more, and society sees them as the only group of people who can legitimately do that. This is the quality of government I don't care for, and what I believe leads to economic inefficiency.
- rayiner 13y agoMunicipalities can ban Uber even within your framework. In that situation, the justification for the use of force derives not from the government's monopoly on the use of force, but from a property owner's right to use force to exclude anyone from their property (i.e. the public roads).
- dragonwriter 13y ago> My point is that even within that framework, municipalities do not need to resort to the government's monopoly on the use of force to exclude Uber from the public roads. Sure they do. > The public built the roads that Uber runs its service on, and the public, acting through municipal governments, is entitled to exclude Uber from those roads. Perhaps, but, in any case, that doesn't relieve them of the need to rely on the so-called "monopoly on force" to exclude Uber, it just, at best, is the justification for that particular use of it.
- rayiner 13y agoThere is a difference between using a power to achieve an end, and necessarily needing to use that power to achieve that end. Cities might use their monopoly on force, as governments, to enforce a ban on Uber, but even if they did not have that power, they could use their rights as the entities that build and maintain the roads Uber runs on.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Cities might use their monopoly on force, as governments, to enforce a ban on Uber, but even if they did not have that power, they could use their rights as the entities that build and maintain the roads Uber runs on. No, they couldn't. Rights are a theoretical justification for excluding someone, the government's compulsory power is a mechanism for excluding someone. The former cannot substitute for the latter (and vice versa.)
- rayiner 13y agoI'm presupposing a point of baddox's hypothetical, which posits a mechanism for enforcing the right to exclude others from property independent of the government's monopoly on force.
- baddox 13y agoI suppose that's true if you consider "public property" to be equivalent to "private property" that just happens to have the government as its owner. But by that logic, governments could have arbitrary control over all public property, meaning they could do things like ban political dissidents from using roads. In reality though, the mini-framework I presented is too simplistic to extend to public property. The key difference is that public property, unlike traditional personal private property, is funded by taxation, which is why we reflexively reject the idea of the government exercising certain control over public property.
- rayiner 13y agoYou don't have to consider the government as the outright owner of public property. You can think of the government as holding public property in trust. Trustees are empowered to exercise the rights of property ownership as long as they do so consistently with their fiduciary duties. So a municipality could still exclude Uber from the public roads based on its right to exclude others from property it holds in trust.