3 ms·
I would argue that all granted monopolies are flawed models. Either they require the use of force to prevent illicit competitors (who are making consensual busi
by baddox 13y ago
I would argue that all granted monopolies are flawed models. Either they require the use of force to prevent illicit competitors (who are making consensual business transactions with customers), or they serve the demands of the market well enough that there are no illicit competitors (in which case the granted monopoly is by definition unnecessary).
- dragonwriter 13y ago> I would argue that all granted monopolies are flawed models. Sure, granted monopolies are (at best) a blunt instrument for internalizing externalities; the questions aren't whether they are imperfect (they are), the question is whether more finely-tuned mechanisms of internalizing the externalities have their own costs which outweigh the benefits. (Also, of course, whether the externalities are accurately assessed.) > Either they require the use of force to prevent illicit competitors (who are making consensual business transactions with customers) You seem to suggest that consensual business transactions are always desirable, which (even making the usual assumptions that make this true when considering only the effects on the direct participants) only is sensible if you completely discount the possibility of externalities.
- baddox 13y ago> You seem to suggest that consensual business transactions are always desirable, which (even making the usual assumptions that make this true when considering only the effects on the direct participants) only is sensible if you completely discount the possibility of externalities. Not at all. I recognize the existence and inevitability of market failures. I just think that regulations will lead to more market failures ("government failures") and will (on average) decrease economic efficiency.
- rayiner 13y ago> (who are making consensual business transactions with customers) ...using public property (public roads, public rights of way for water lines or telephone lines, etc). A city excluding illicit competitors from using its roads "requires the use of force" no more than vindicating the right of a property owner to exclude others requires the use of force as a general matter.
- baddox 13y ago> A city excluding illicit competitors from using its roads "requires the use of force" no more than vindicating the right of a property owner to exclude others requires the use of force as a general matter. They key difference is not so much the use of force itself, but rather who we consider to be legitimate purveyors of force. When it comes to property rights, obviously there are many varying philosophies and codes that people adhere to, but most people who believe in any form of personal property rights believe that the owners themselves can legitimately use force to defend that property. In other words, there is no monopoly on the legitimate use of force for enforcing property rights. Government, on the other hand, enjoys a monopoly on the legitimate use of force for many things. If a random group of people went around to every house in a region forcefully taking money in order to fund roads, hospitals, charities, etc., the vast majority of society would not see this as legitimate. Likewise, if 9 of the 10 families on your block agreed to forcefully take and use your family's house and property as they saw fit, the vast majority of society would not see this as legitimate. The fact that the majority of people in a region agreed on the use of force would not legitimize it. So government is unique in this regard: it can and does do both of those things and more, and society sees them as the only group of people who can legitimately do that. This is the quality of government I don't care for, and what I believe leads to economic inefficiency.
- rayiner 13y agoMunicipalities can ban Uber even within your framework. In that situation, the justification for the use of force derives not from the government's monopoly on the use of force, but from a property owner's right to use force to exclude anyone from their property (i.e. the public roads).
- dragonwriter 13y ago> My point is that even within that framework, municipalities do not need to resort to the government's monopoly on the use of force to exclude Uber from the public roads. Sure they do. > The public built the roads that Uber runs its service on, and the public, acting through municipal governments, is entitled to exclude Uber from those roads. Perhaps, but, in any case, that doesn't relieve them of the need to rely on the so-called "monopoly on force" to exclude Uber, it just, at best, is the justification for that particular use of it.