6 ms·
>In other words, considering how US has promised to treat him You mean the promises to arrest him for releasing confidential information? I'm honestly confuse
by mikeyouse 13y ago
>In other words, considering how US has promised to treat him
You mean the promises to arrest him for releasing confidential information? I'm honestly confused why people don't think he should be arrested. If he had released weapons designs instead of NSA documents, would you support his galavanting across HK and Russia?
The question, "Is the NSA program unconstitutional?" is a far different one than "Should those who release confidential documents be arrested?" Unless you think that there should be no state secrets, it makes absolute sense to arrest and prosecute Snowden. I'm grateful that he shed some light on a very troubling program, but that doesn't just grant him immunity from prosecution. It would be far more honorable to accept responsibility rather than to continue this mess.
- throwaway10001 13y agoYou mean the promises to arrest him for releasing confidential information? Arrest, a fair trial and humane treatment is different from what Bradley Manning suffered. http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2011/mar/11/stripped-naked-bradley-manning-prison http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2011/mar/11/stripped-naked-b... Also, need I remind you all the statements made against him by politicians?
- skynorth 13y agoDidn't you just answer your own question? Because many people consider him to be a whistle-blower. If he truly believes that he is exposing a large and direct illegal activity, he should be protected under law.
- tymekpavel 13y ago> If he had released weapons designs instead of NSA documents, would you support his galavanting across HK and Russia? I think you're missing the point. The fact is he didn't release weapons designs; he released information pointing to surveillance programs that violate the 4th amendment. > The question, "Is the NSA program unconstitutional?" is a far different one than "Should those who release confidential documents be arrested?" The two questions you ask are not mutually exclusive, because whistleblowers need protection when surfacing evidence of illegal behavior. You seem to be taking arguments to their absolute extremes rather than considering the fact that there are instances where there is a reasonable expectation that individuals should be protected. That doesn't mean there should be no state secrets, it means there should be protections for individuals who reveal state secrets that demonstrate the government is not acting in accordance with the law. Furthermore, I would argue that state secrets that hide evidence of wrongdoing from the public should most certainly be leaked.
- mikeyouse 13y agoWhistleblowers do indeed need protection. Unfortunately for Snowden, current whistleblower laws only protect him if he leaked to his agencies IG; Disclosure of information that is required by law or Executive Order to be kept secret in the interest of national defense or the conduct of foreign affairs is unprotected, unless made to the agency’s Inspector General, to “another employee designated by the head of the agency to receive such disclosures” or to the Office of the Special Counsel. Obviously these laws need to be improved, but selective enforcement leaves a ton of room for politics to infiltrate the whistleblowing. It was only a few years ago that Bush's special council at the OSC was arrested for doing precisely that: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Office_of_Special_Counsel#Scott_J._Bloch http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Office_of_Special_Counsel#Scott...
- vinceguidry 13y ago> I'm grateful that he shed some light on a very troubling program, but that doesn't just grant him immunity from prosecution. This doesn't seem like a rational position. Either Snowden performed a service or he committed a crime. He can't have done both. The fact that it's really a subjective call speaks to its political nature. As such, there is no dishonor in absconding to a country with more favorable politics.
- icebraining 13y agoEither Snowden performed a service or he committed a crime. Isn't that what a trial - after arrest and prosecution - is supposed to determine? The problem is not prosecution, it's that a fair trial is hardly guaranteed.
- vinceguidry 13y agoWhy submit yourself to prosecution if you've no hope of a fair trial?
- codex 13y ago38% of Americans think that Snowden shouldn't be prosecuted. While not 50%, it's reasonably high. That, combined with jury selection and sequestration, ought to do the trick--but if OJ Simpson can get away with murder, anything's possible in the U.S.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Either Snowden performed a service or he committed a crime. He can't have done both. He actually can have done both. That something has value to the public does not mean it is not within the scope of prohibition of a criminal statute. (Further, even if there was a blanket "public service" exception to the applicable criminal laws, its quite possible that some of the information he absconded with and released could be "service" and the rest could still be "crime".)
- vinceguidry 13y agoI'm aware that the law can prohibit actions that are ultimately good for society. That doesn't make it rational.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> You mean the promises to arrest him for releasing confidential information? I'm honestly confused why people don't think he should be arrested. If the government believes that he still has valuable intelligence potentially damaging to national security that may not have already been released, and if the government's primary concern with his actions is addressing the national security impact (which all public statements point to), the primary goal of the government should be preventing foreign powers, potentially hostile ones, from getting access to the secrets he possesses. Publicly threatening to arrest and try him for serious and potentially capital offenses like espionage while he is in territory not subject to the US or any close ally that would be likely inclined to cooperate given the circumstances is, from that perspective, quite foolish.
- mikeyouse 13y agoThis train of logic doesn't make any sense. the primary goal of the government should be preventing foreign powers, potentially hostile ones, from getting access to the secrets he possesses. Publicly threatening to arrest and try him for serious and potentially capital offenses like espionage while he is in territory not subject to the US or any close ally that would be likely inclined to cooperate given the circumstances is, from that perspective, quite foolish. If the government were to take that tack, it would only encourage leakers and 'spies' to grab the most valuable documents possible, in essence blackmailing their way out of prosecution. If you're the US government, your default assumption must be that Putin has a hard drive with everything that Snowden took. If that's the case, it makes absolute sense to publicly threaten to arrest him and charge him with the most severe of consequences. Look at it from a game theory perspective; the US government 'lost' the first game to Snowden. The only reason they are still engaging with him is that the US is playing a repeating game. They need to make the penalty for leaking high enough to persuade other potential leakers to stay quiet.
- dragonwriter 13y agoI think you are confusing two different issues: publicly threatening to arrest and prosecute him for capital offenses while he is outside of the practical reach of the US government and seeking to arrest and prosecute him. You can do the second without doing the first; indeed, the first can be actively counterproductive to the second, since he cannot be arrested and prosecuted without first being brought within the practical reach of the US government, which the public threats to him (and the public threats to other sovereign states) have made less, not more, likely. > Look at it from a game theory perspective; the US government 'lost' the first game to Snowden. The only reason they are still engaging with him is that the US is playing a repeating game. They need to make the penalty for leaking high enough to persuade other potential leakers to stay quiet. Making public threats that make acheiving the stated goals of those threats less likely, thus demonstrating impotence, is not a particularly effective method of doing that.
- columbo 13y ago> You mean the promises to arrest him for releasing confidential information? Being arrested and facing a fair trial isn't anyone's fear. Being arrested, placed in solitary confinment for months on end, subjected to technically-not-torture-torture, threats against your family all the while having your entire character destroyed thread by thread until the day you stand in front of a show room to argue why you should only receive 50 years of prison time instead of 500 is another story. If we truly lived in a fair and free society I would be championing his arrest, if anything simply for the truth to come out. As it stands it is hard to believe a truly fair trial is something that even exists anymore.
- mikeyouse 13y agoHe's accused of three things[1]; 1. Theft of Government Property 2. Unauthorized Communication of National Defense Information 3. Willful Communication of Classified Communications Intelligence Information to an Unauthorized Person Is there some chance that he's innocent of any of those charges, and will be wrongly convicted? They all seem pretty obvious and there are Federal laws in place to guide penalties and fines. Why is everyone convinced he won't have a fair trial? Is a result where he ends up in jail an unfair result? [1] http://apps.washingtonpost.com/g/documents/world/us-vs-edward-j-snowden-criminal-complaint/496/ http://apps.washingtonpost.com/g/documents/world/us-vs-edwar...
- columbo 13y ago> Why is everyone convinced he won't have a fair trial? http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2012/03/manning-treatment-inhuman/ http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2012/03/manning-treatment-i... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guantanamo_Bay_detention_camp#Criticism_and_condemnation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guantanamo_Bay_detention_camp#C... > Is a result where he ends up in jail an unfair result? NO. If we had set a high bar for wanting a free and fair trial (which we haven't) then the case would be decided in an open manner which could very well end in jail time, community service or some equivalent. I fully support that process.
- mikeyouse 13y ago