4 ms·
"...in order to reduce shoplifting and employee theft..." Shoplifting, maybe. Employee theft, no. The Hasidim already have the world's best deterrent to empl
by edw519 18y ago
"...in order to reduce shoplifting and employee theft..."
Shoplifting, maybe. Employee theft, no. The Hasidim already have the world's best deterrent to employee theft: you are banned for life from the community. Period. No warnings. No discussion.
Imagine if wall street had that rule.
- boundlessdreamz 18y agoHow do they know who has done the theft ?
- edw519 18y agoDoesn't matter, that's the point. Would you be willing to risk everything important to you, not just your job, but your family, friends, home, and community, on the chance that someone may have seen you take a $5 item?
- sethg 18y agoI wouldn't, but I can't speak for everyone else. Sex outside of marriage is much more frowned-upon in the Hasidic community than petty theft, and yet there are Hasidim who have been caught soliciting prostitutes.
- yan 18y agoThat statement says absolutely nothing about the Hasidic community. As with any community, there will be those that commit acts considered indecent or tailor to their own urges above culture. That statement holds true if you insert absolutely any group of people in place of "the Hasidic community," no matter how traditional or strict.
- sethg 18y agoAgreed. My point is that a store owner cannot assume that a Hasidic employee, even one who is constantly in the presence of other Hasidim, can automatically be trusted not to steal.
- agrinshtein 18y agoAgreed. People are still human even though that they may try to follow a principled life. Think about yourself. You have certain principles which in moments of weakness are violated. I, in principle, go to sleep early. Here I am posting at 10:17PM (South African time) on Hacker News. Principle violated. People are only human.
- marcusbooster 18y agoPeople get the wrong idea because they see the beards and hats and think "oh they must be really religious". You have a cultural group with individuals acting in different ways across a wide spectrum, often conflicting at different points in time -- just like everyone else.
- htrbtrb 18y agoIt does help if you not only know most of your workers personally - but your father knows their father and so on for 200 generations! There are a few software companies like that in Utah - everybody in the dept goes to the same church on sunday, not my cup of tea but they seem happy.
- param 18y agoI am sure that its just the owners who are Jews. Employees would be regular folks, and theft just means getting fired - no different from other stores.
- cjbos 18y agoI think all employees are Jewish as well, or at least I haven't seen a non Hasidic Jewish guy behind the counter any of the half dozen times I've been in the store.
- joshwa 18y agoWhile the majority of the salespeople and staff are jews, there are also plenty who are not. All walks of life-- anyone you'd normally see on Ninth Avenue is represented on the B&H staff. (including that snotty bastard in the studio lighting department-- B&H salespeople can be a little brusque) I've probably spent upwards of $10k there over the years-- just bought $200 in grip on Sunday.
- shard 18y agoIt might have been true back when I was still living in NY (around '92) when it was just a small store, but I don't think it's true anymore.
- allertonm 18y agoI don't think this is true - I was in there three years ago and one of the guys who helped me out was an african-american. It's possible that he was jewish, but I am pretty sure he wasn't Hasidic.
- wheels 18y agoPresumably that's not policy or at least not a formal one since they'd be in violation of the Equal Opportunity Act. While I knew nothing of the place before this, I'd suspect they have at least a token non-Hasidic employee or three just to keep them from getting sued.
- jonknee 18y agoI am sure you haven't been to B&H before.
- Confusion 18y agoI seriously doubt there are only Hasidim working there... Edit: hmmm wait, this tab was obviously already open for quite some time... a dozen comments have materialized, including some I'm now duping. Sorry.
- crux_ 18y agoRandom anecdote: I interned, back in the day, at a consulting firm working w/ their website; at the time -- and perhaps still? -- they worked in gender-segregated areas when on site. More randomness for the hell of it: I read the Yiddish Policemen's Union the other week and cannot recommend it highly enough. (It's a noir detective alt-history set in a Jewish analogue of Hong Kong in Alaska, where the local organized crime are Hasidic, the slang name for them is "black hats.") (It also manages to be a page-turner without any of that guilty feeling of "I just read 300 pages without thinking a single original thought" that so many page-turners leave you with.)
- joshwa 18y agoIncidentally, I don't think the conveyor system is to reduce theft-- it's due to the lack of space. 35k ft^2 is only enough to keep display models of most items out on the sales floor (I'm guessing their total product line is >300k SKUs) Most of their store inventory is in the basement warehouse (and plenty of other inventory must be off-site entirely). There's simply no other way of fulfilling that much volume in a real-time retail environment.