4 ms·
1. I'm still not seeing backup for your claim that I was asking anyone to sacrifice themselves for the good of others. 2. You should read Objectivist Epistemol
by javajosh 13y ago
1. I'm still not seeing backup for your claim that I was asking anyone to sacrifice themselves for the good of others.
2. You should read Objectivist Epistemology, where she connects her ethical system to her metaphysics. It's fairly execrable as philosophy goes, but it does underscore my point that she's fundamentally driven by her idealism, particularly about the nature of truth. (BTW that's why it's called Objectivism and not Selfishism).
Anyway, you really do sound like a young Randroid (again). In a few years you'll see that, well, she was wrong. Emotions are not vestigial. Reason is one tool in the box among others. And when self-interest, rather than self-restraint, becomes widely accepted as the criteria for merit, we end up with a system like we have today, where a docile public unable to even articulate a criticism of abuse of power, since there is no such thing as "abuse of power" in a framework that rewards only self-interest.
Adieu.
- javert 13y agoI've tried to engage productively with you, even to the point of chiding you for being rude without retaliating myself, but now you're just being an asshole. I've been studying philosophy as a hobby/passion for many years. I've read the work you're referring to, and a whole hell of a lot more. You have a very, very naive understanding of Objectivism. > Anyway, you really do sound like a young Randroid (again). In a few years you'll see that, well, she was wrong. Likewise, you really do sound like a young <X>, and in a few years, you'll realize how wrong you are about everything. That is, literally, the sum of your argument. That is really pitiful. And for all you know, I could be a 55 year old philosophy professor (though I'm not).
- jtheory 13y agoI only skimmed this exchange, and I have no dog in this fight, but you should be aware -- you seem to be the only one using obscenities, and you started this exchange with "Sorry, but this is a load of disgusting hogwash". None of these comments are very friendly-feeling to me (on either side... you're both obviously feeling defensive), but if you start the exchange with that kind of comment, you're the first to deploy obscenities, you're more actively insulting, etc., you can't really claim the higher ground at the end. I hope this is useful... it's hard to discuss these kinds of things, but if you can manage it (without getting tangled up in attack/counterattack) it can be rewarding.
- javert 13y agoIt's been a personal goal of mine to get to the point where I never say something online that I wouldn't say in person, and so far I've made a lot of progress, but it looks like the next step is to never use obscenities. So, you're right, thank you, and that is helpful. I strongly disagree that I was more actively insulting. I think a detailed reading of the conversation speaks for itself on this.