5 ms·
Just because it pisses the public off, that is no excuse for anyone to leak information at will, let alone be pardoned for it. I call bullshit. The government
by mindcrime 13y ago
Just because it pisses the public off, that is no excuse for anyone to leak information at will, let alone be pardoned for it.
I call bullshit. The government exists to serve the people, not the other way around. What is "legal" or "illegal" is bigger than just what Congress, the President or the Supreme Court think. As they say, "An unjust law is no law at all".[1]
Certainly an arguable point, but it's one I adhere to, and I think a lot of other HN'ers do as well. As well as a lot of Americans, and, for that matter, a lot of people period.
[1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lex_iniusta_non_est_lex http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lex_iniusta_non_est_lex
- pfraze 13y agoTrue, but I'm not sure I'd say the laws against leaking government secrets are unjust. I'd say the various monitoring systems are potentially dangerous and unconstitutional, but those issues are separate from Snowden's charge. Also, I'm not a lawyer, but I'm pretty sure that the nature of the leak will factor into his trial, which is where it should be evaluated (right?).
- drcube 13y agoBecause secret treason courts are where justice is best served? In the very country being accused of civil rights violations by the defendant? And besides troop movements, names and locations of undercover operatives, and other specific information that could get people hurt or killed, why should the government keep secrets from its citizens for any reason? Or what does "consent of the governed" mean?
- jasonlotito 13y ago> and other specific information that could get people hurt or killed, You've described the loop hole for a slippery slope. And I promise you, the first suggestions would seem so reasonable. After all, you didn't mention the descriptions of the operatives. Or the supplies needed to support the troop movements. Both of which are not specifically described by you, but could easily be used against the troops and agents. Both of which are reasonable to keep secret... But it's still a slope. We think we are here overnight, but we are not. PRISM didn't just happens. It's been in the making for decades before you were born. That's the part we need to realize. Obama didn't do this. Bush didn't do this. Hell, your parents didn't do this. We've all done this, one way or the other. We've all been apart of this.
- rayiner 13y ago> Because secret treason courts are where justice is best served? What secret treason courts? Snowden is not charged with treason, and even if he were, he'd be tried in U.S. District Court.
- mindcrime 13y agoTrue, but I'm not sure I'd say the laws against leaking government secrets are unjust. I think you have to consider context. To flip it around, the law may or may not be inherently unjust, but breaking it may well be justified in some circumstances. Nominally, this is part of the reason we have juries, and why juries are able to make their determination on any basis they see fit... so they can allow for this kind of "fuzziness" to the law. There's also a reason that prosecutors have discretion in choosing what charges to pursue, what sentence to seek, etc. Now, you can argue that, given our system and all its checks and balances and protections, that Snowden should come home and face a trail in front of a jury of his peers. But you can also argue that, given all the publicity around the case, he's correct in saying that he won't get a fair trail. You could also argue that even a "fair trail" is unfair from the perspective of the individual being judged, if they don't consider themselves guilty of a crime. At the end of the day, this whole idea of "justice" is not black and white, sadly.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- diminoten 13y agoYou don't get to end-run the justice system by being popular in the eyes of the people.
- eksith 13y agoWhile popularity may be irrelevant, being "right" in the eyes of the people is what justice is all about. After all, the civil rights movement was fairly unpopular for a large part of the U.S. population. Regardless, the legal precedents set during that time were "right" and just.
- mpyne 13y agoYou contradicted yourself from one sentence to the next. The population overwhelmingly supported oppressing the black minority. But the legal system disregarded what the large majority thought and did the right thing anyways.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 13y agoThey also say, "we are a government of laws, not of men." The government should enforce, and follow, the laws as they are written, not go by what one man or another considers to be "just" or "unjust." And as a practical matter, the majority of Americans think Snowden should be prosecuted.
- gasull 13y agoThat's not what this Gallup poll found: http://www.gallup.com/poll/163043/americans-disapprove-government-surveillance-programs.aspx http://www.gallup.com/poll/163043/americans-disapprove-gover... 44% say Snowden did the right thing, 42% say it was wrong. 53% disapprove Government surveillance. 59% say it was right for the newspapers to publish the info. Also: 31% say he's a patriot, 23% say he's a traitor: http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/06/12/us-usa-security-poll-idUSBRE95B1AF20130612 http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/06/12/us-usa-security-po...
- rayiner 13y agoA Pew Research poll found that Americans believe Snowden should be prosecuted, by a substantial margin (54-38): http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2013/06/17/americans-say-snowden-should-be-prosecuted-for-nsa-leaks-in-usa-today-poll/2430583 http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2013/06/17/ameri....
- gasull 13y agoI would like to know the exact question they were asked. It's easy to induce people into answering what you want if you use the right wording.
- danielweber 13y agoIt can both be a good thing as well as something he should have to answer about in court.
- anigbrowl 13y ago