5 ms·
I think most companies in the Valley would acknowledge this. The thing is - most companies are not looking for the best talent, they're looking to build the be
by nostrademons 13y ago
I think most companies in the Valley would acknowledge this.
The thing is - most companies are not looking for the best talent, they're looking to build the best teams. And one of the things that helps a team to gel is having all the members co-located together. It would be wonderful if the physical presence barrier was broken and you could setup virtual presences that were as efficient as physical ones, but something intangible seems to be lost when you only interact over e-mail.
It works for GitHub because it makes the company a very incentivized user of their own product - they're developing for precisely the sort of organization that is their market, and so they understand their market better than if they acted like a normal start-up. But if they were playing in a fast-moving consumer market or trying to capitalize on a recent platform or innovation, they'd get eaten alive.
- ryanSrich 13y agoI know you pointed out github but I'd have to disagree about the physical part for consumer facing markets. I'll point to Fictive Kin[1] and 37signals[2] as just two very successful examples. 1.) http://fictivekin.com/ http://fictivekin.com/ 2.) https://37signals.com/ https://37signals.com/
- nostrademons 13y ago37signals is B2B2C: their primary market is small businesses. I'd never heard of Fictive Kin before, and a quick Google doesn't turn up anything other than their website, where it looks like they're more of a consultancy than a product.
- ryanSrich 13y agoFictive Kin invented Gimmebar[1] among other products. 1.) https://gimmebar.com/ https://gimmebar.com/
- rdl 13y agoAutomattic (Wordpress) is probably the canonical b2c distributed team example (although I think they make more from b2b sales of WP:Enterprise)
- jusben1369 13y agoI think you make really good points. I'd turn it around though a little. GitHub can break the mold (scale a startup/grow a team) where others have failed partly because it's in the DNA in their product. But once they show how it's done it'll be modifiable/repeatalbe and usable by folks focused on other markets.
- nostrademons 13y agoIt could be; I'd very much like them to succeed, because I love working with a lot of smart people in tech but hate paying Silicon Valley rents. Maybe that's why Andreesen Horowitz invested. But it's very much an open market thesis; I don't really see any evidence this is repeatable across markets yet.
- mahyarm 13y agoYou'll be surprised what google hangouts on a wired connection on both ends can do, especially when on-ramping people. Why wired? Packet loss from wifi seriously degrades the conversation. Wired on both ends and packet loss is practically non-existant. There are downsides to not being distributed too. Being distributed for example lets engineers control their interruptions and environment far more. If companies really really cared about building the best teams, they wouldn't do the nearly industry standard open office layouts. Open office layouts make for easy management and harder development.
- nostrademons 13y agoI use Hangouts extensively; I work for Google, we eat our own dogfood as far as videoconference software goes. That's one of the main reasons I'm pessimistic about distributed teams. Despite having probably the fastest fiber backbone in the world, and despite having an inside track to the VC software we use, it still turns out that being physically present with the people you work with is pretty important. Enough that I'm moving offices this week, 3 cubes down, so that I can be 30 ft. closer to the rest of my teammates. There seems to be something intangible that is lost when you move out of shouting distance, and even though we have the technology to shout over 3000 miles, it doesn't seem to be the same.
- lifeisstillgood 13y agoIf distributed working was a no-brained with no downsides we would all be doing it. However I do believe the upsides are several factors greater than the down, so the cost benefit does win out - if the effort is put in. I have got most out of distributed working within weeks of physical meetups for sprints, so my view is meetup every quarter for a weeks sprint (somewhere nice of course!) The benefits of easier to control working environments, focus on deliverables, honesty, greater team choice and flexibility, easier professionalism, all make winning easier
- vidarh 13y agoOne thing (of many) that simply must be handled better for video conferencing to even getting close to be a viable replacement is the "eye contact" problem. People need to be able to look in someones eyes on screen, and see them looking back at them. For the occasional call for e.g. an interview, I make it a point to look into the camera, rather than on screen, and it makes a big difference in how I get perceived, but that turns the video aspect into a one-way thing - like looking into a TV camera. While looking at the screen means you loose a lot of the signals you'd get face to face just from having a harder time reading facial expressions, and from the way peoples interaction change when they don't get eye contact with you. There's lots of other bits and pieces that impact its usefulness too, but to me solutions to the eye contact issue needs to be there before there's much point. E.g. in my experience with teams seated close together, eye contact is often the primary indicator that you've gotten someones attention and can start asking a question and know you're not interrupting something important. Without that, you're either back to the keyboard, or "polluting" the environment with distracting speech - often I see team members using IM even to someone at the next desk over when failing to get eye contact, exactly to avoid disturbing everyone else by speaking, so that's a non-starter. It's an incredibly important part of communication that most current video conferencing seriously hampers.
- rwallace 13y agoThat depends entirely on the people involved. Some people find they need to be physically co-located with their teammates, but some of us find it's easier to work with other people when relieved of the distracting noise of physical presence and granted the clarity and time for thought of text communication. If you fall into the former category, fair enough, by all means you should organize your situation accordingly, but don't assume what's true for you is true for everyone.