3 ms·
"For you civilians webcasting rates are “compulsory” rates. They are set by the government (crazy, right?). Further since they are compulsory royalties, artists
by greenyoda 13y ago
"For you civilians webcasting rates are “compulsory” rates. They are set by the government (crazy, right?). Further since they are compulsory royalties, artists can not “opt out” of a service like Pandora even if they think Pandora doesn’t pay them enough. The majority of songwriters have their rates set by the government, too, in the form of the ASCAP and BMI rate courts–a single judge gets to decide the fate of songwriters (technically not a “compulsory” but may as well be)."
This bothers me. Why should the government regulate payments for music? Why shouldn't a musician have the option of licensing his music to radio stations but not to Pandora? We in the U.S. claim to have a system based on free enterprise, but this is very far away from that.
- warfangle 13y agoBecause it's not just the performing artists that would need to give copyright permission, it would also be all of the collaborating artists (lyricist, etc), and the label, and potentially the mastering house. It would be a licensing nightmare to get your song on the air - and would probably be harkened to the bad old days of payola. Read up on the history of copyright law, especially as it pertains to music.
- greenyoda 13y agoBut all of these entities would seem to have the common interest of maximizing their revenues from royalties. So why shouldn't they have the right to authorize one party (perhaps the label) to negotiate on their behalf? Also, it's becoming increasingly easy for musicians to digitally produce their own MP3s, so if there's no label or studio involved and the musicians wrote their own lyrics, it would seem to be even easier for them to negotiate on their own behalf.
- macspoofing 13y agoBecause copyright doesn't quite fit in your free enterprise world. Copyright isn't like traditional property. It needs government to define it, set limits on it and enforce it.
- greenyoda 13y agoThere's copyright in many other industries - book publishing, software, etc. - but in those industries the government doesn't control how much the parties get paid. Yes, the government grants the copyright and its courts enforce it, but that's all. For example, if I write an e-book, I can determine the price I sell it for and I'm not forced to allow Amazon to sell it.
- macspoofing 13y ago>Yes, the government grants the copyright and its courts enforce it, but that's all. You're skirting a very deep issue. Copyright is a legal construct, whose every aspect is completely arbitrary, and comes about from a balance of competing goals. You find it perplexing that for certain copyrighted material distributed over a certain medium in a certain way, government sets a fixed price? I find it perplexing that you find it perplexing. Shouldn't you should also be asking why the copyright term is over a century long now, why there are satire and 'fair use' exceptions, why certain kinds of remixing is allowed, and others not. There are countless more strange and weird aspects to copyright, because everything about copyright is completely arbitrary. > For example, if I write an e-book, I can determine the price I sell it for and I'm not forced to allow Amazon to sell it. You may or may be allowed to restrict resale of your book. Your work is allowed to be reproduced (without compensation to you and without permission from you) in braille, for the blind. You will not be able to restrict state libraries from lending (for free) copies of your book.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Copyright is a legal construct, whose every aspect is completely arbitrary, and comes about from a balance of competing goals. As side note, this is true of all property rights; real and tangible personal property are no different than copyrights or other IP rights in this respect. This often gets forgotten, apparently just because legal protection of real and tangible personal property rights in some form is far older than copyright.