5 ms·
Ah, this decision is from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit. Totally expected, and we need to get rid of that court. For those unfamiliar with
by btilly 13y ago
Ah, this decision is from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit. Totally expected, and we need to get rid of that court.
For those unfamiliar with the history, that is the court that all patent cases go to. They've been co-opted by patent lawyers, and decide very much in favor of patent holders. Every so often the Supreme Court takes the time to review one of their decisions, and inevitably overrules them. So in their next ruling they find a way to pay lip service to the Supreme Court while ignoring what that court said.
So the rhythm goes like this. You go to your local court, and win or lose based on the jury. Then if the patent holder does not like the decision, you go to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit. And pretty much inevitably will win. If the challenger is very, very lucky, the Supreme Court will have time to hear the case. And you'll get a balanced decision for the challenger. (I mean that literally. The Supreme Court does not have time to hear many of these, so they just pick the most egregious, and issue a balanced decision. But since they picked egregious cases, the patent holder always loses.)
If we could just replace the one court in the middle with one that actually listened to the Supreme Court, then patent trolling would be dealt a fatal blow. I shudder to think of how much its existence costs legitimate business in this country every single year.
- bobwaycott 13y agoThe CoA for Federal Circuit operates very much like the FISC for patents.
- rayiner 13y agoExcept that's not remotely the case, at all. The Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit issues precedent binding on all the lower federal courts in the country, to the exclusion of any of the other Courts of Appeal. The FISC issues precedent binding on... no one (other than itself).
- bobwaycott 13y agoApologies for not being excessively explicit--I was referring only to the fact that given their caseload and decisions, the CAFC often appears as a rubber stamp court for patent litigation. I was not speaking about establishing binding precedent. However, even on that note, your argument rings hollow--the FISC has established precedent that has very much become the prevailing understanding of "legal" where its cases are concerned. That's why we've arrived at the mess we're in. Whether the precedent is binding or not is debatable, as nobody I've yet heard of is quoting FISC decisions in other law enforcement actions/cases. But when we have every official from the President onward declaring that everything is "legal" because it has been reviewed and decided upon repeatedly over the last few decades by "the courts", I think trying to make a technical argument on the binding nature of the precedents established is misguided.
- rayiner 13y agoFISC precedent is not binding on any federal court but FISC itself. I have never seen a FISC opinion cited to support some point of law (and only one FISA Review Court opinion so cited: 310 F.3d 717), so I think it's ridiculous to say that "the FISC has established binding precedent that has very much become the prevailing understanding of 'legal' where its cases are concerned." FISC precedent is important in the sense that it guides FISC itself, and it guides grants of foreign intelligence warrants, but at the end of the day, if the government wants to use information collected pursuant to a FISC warrant to prosecute you, it has to do so in a regular U.S. District Court, and that court is not bound in any way by the FISC's interpretations of the law. In contrast, in a patent litigation, all the U.S. District Courts are absolutely bound by the Federal Circuit's precedent.
- bobwaycott 13y agoAre we talking past each other here, or are you just imagining a disagreement here and continuing to press a completely unrelated point? You've said nothing materially different from me on the point that I made. You are pinpointing and continuing to dispute an off-hand comment about rubber-stamping with drawing upon the establishment of precedent and its binding nature on other courts, and again, I wasn't saying anything about that issue at all. If I was to hazard a guess, I'd say you misunderstood the intent of my jab and are carrying forward an inconsistent comparison, cherry picking one minor detail to dispute the jab, and creating a bit of a straw man here that is completely pointless. Here, I will say it again: I was referring only to the fact that given their caseload and decisions, the CAFC often appears as a rubber stamp court for patent litigation. I was not speaking about establishing binding precedent [on any other courts]. Sheesh, friend. You're barking up the wrong tree here.
- rayiner 13y agoFirst, you did say something about the precedent issue, because you claimed in your second paragraph that the FISC was creating binding precedent that shaped the law in its area. That's true for the Fed. Cir., but not for FISC. Second, and this is more pointing out an implication of your point rather than a disagreement, FISC being a rubber stamp is much less of a problem than Fed. Cir. being a rubber stamp. FISC being a rubber stamp only affects warrant requests that come in front of FISC itself. Fed. Cir. being a rubber stamp has ripple effects throughout the entire court system because it creates precedent binding on every district court and appellate court in the country.
- WildUtah 13y agoThat isn't really what gp was talking about, but your point ignores the ways decisions propagate other than hierarchical appeals. Since the Supreme Court has created large good faith effort holes in the exclusionary rule for law enforcement, any source of reliable warrants creates an unlimited opportunity for mischief. Other courts will have to admit evidence first suspected because of information obtained through any apparently valid FISA warrant. And since FISC is a no-work sinecure for ultra-right judges to draw a salary and benefits for occasionally showing up to rubber stamp secret warrants, it blows a hole in any restrictions on search and seizure for anyone in any court with access to FISC.
- ajb 13y agoThat isn't what the article says, though: 'As patent scholar Mark Lemley put it on Twitter, “we’ve got two Federal Circuits on this issue, and it seems to depend on the luck of the draw"'. Mark Lemley is a high profile (sceptical) patent scholar. If he is correct, then there are some voices of sanity on the Federal Circuit. The question is, is the influence of the voice of sanity increasing or decreasing?
- btilly 13y agoI am sure he knows better than I. However from my point of view, those two positions are likely to be "extreme" and "very extreme". (My point of view is that we would be better off without software patents. It would be hard to find a US patent lawyer or court who would agree.) Also a random note in case anyone gets confused. There is only one such court, but cases are often heard by a subset of the justices. So what result you get can depend on which justices hear the case. Mark Lemley's claim is that there is a sharp divide between the justices.
- rayiner 13y ago> There is only one such court, but cases are often heard by a subset of the justices. To be specific, like all U.S. Courts of Appeal, the Federal Circuit hears cases in panels of three judges, drawn from the overall pool. In certain circumstances (notably, anything that requires a prior panel opinion to be overruled), a majority of the judges on the court may vote to rehear a matter en banc, in which case all the judges on the court vote on the outcome. If I recall correctly, the panels are assigned randomly as the cases come in, so if there is a marked division in opinions within the court, the outcome can depend heavily on the luck of the draw.
- WildUtah 13y ago(My point of view is that we would be better off without software patents. It would be hard to find a US patent lawyer or court who would agree.) Justice Stevens wrangled four votes on the Supreme Court for that proposition as recently as 2010. If we could replace some of the pro-software patent majority (Roberts, Scalia, Kennedy, Thomas, Alito) in the Bilsky decision, maybe Breyer could wrangle five votes someday. Of course, the CAFC might just overrule the Supreme Court if that ever happens. (You say the CAFC can't overrule the Supreme Court? Wrong-o! [0] Don't read the link unless you're in a profanity-safe environment; not because it contains profanity, but because you're likely to shout some.) [0] http://www.ipwatchdog.com/2012/03/20/supreme-court-mayo-v-prometheus/id=22920/ http://www.ipwatchdog.com/2012/03/20/supreme-court-mayo-v-pr...
- masklinn 13y ago> They've been co-opted by patent lawyers, and decide very much in favor of patent holders. Co-opted? It's been run by patent lawyers pretty much from the start. See http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2012/09/how-a-rogue-appeals-court-wrecked-the-patent-system/ http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2012/09/how-a-rogue-appea... for a history of the place.