4 ms·
I suspect that a trial that would result in Snowden being found not guilty is nearly impossible--given anything like competence in the prosecution team. But is
by cafard 13y ago
I suspect that a trial that would result in Snowden being found not guilty is nearly impossible--given anything like competence in the prosecution team. But is a fair trial supposed to be like a fair coin, with an even chance either way?
Note that I am not saying anything with regard to rights and wrongs, merely about laws.
[Edit: changed "found guilty" to "found not guilty". Thanks.]
- mtgx 13y agoGuilty on what? He has 3 charges against him. Pretty sure he won't be found guilty of Espionage (at least not at the Supreme Court if he gets there). If it's in a normal Texas Court, then he may be, and his fears might prove real that he won't get a fair trial. As for being found guilty of "leaking classified documents", I supposed that could happen, but again I'd like to see the issue at the Supreme Court, because there you might see it being discussed if a whistleblower can or can't be charged for "leaking".
- rthomas6 13y agoWhy do you think that a fair trial would result in Snowden almost certainly not being found guilty?
- danudey 13y agoThe debate isn't whether a fair trial would convict him, the debate is whether it would be a fair trial. Regardless of whether he's guilty of a crime, an unfair trial is a sign of an unjust society. Though, the same could be said for mass warrantless wiretapping.
- ipsin 13y agoI suspect you meant "being found not guilty is nearly impossible". And federal prosecution is absolutely nothing like a fair coin toss -- the federal conviction rate is 90+%. I think this has something to do with the tactics used in federal cases -- throwing an array of charges and seizing assets, for example. Also, the idea of jury nullification (the idea that jurors can find someone 'not guilty' of an unjust law) cannot be broached by the defense.
- cafard 13y agoYes, "not guilty". Would you consider a system just that brought persons to trial without a strong probability that they were guilty as charged? If so, why have grand juries?
- rayiner 13y ago> I think this has something to do with the tactics used in federal cases Yes, and that tactic is not wasting resources bringing a case unless it's a slam-dunk. Say what you want about the Schwartz prosecution, but it was a slam-dunk case. The debate was political: whether his actions merited such harsh punishment, not legal: it was clear and undisputed that he entered the closet, downloaded the articles, changed his MAC address to evade the ban, etc, and those actions were almost certainly crimes within the letter of the law. A system where a trials didn't result in a high conviction rate would be supremely broken. It would mean that prosecutors were bringing cases without enough evidence to make them a likely win.
- Someone 13y ago"And federal prosecution is absolutely nothing like a fair coin toss -- the federal conviction rate is 90+%." It better be. Yes, a high conviction rate can be a symptom of injustice, but it need not be. A low conviction rate, on the other hand, is a sure symptom of injustice. It would be truly harassment if the feds prosecuted many where they should know they don't stand a chance of getting a conviction.