3 ms·
It is almost certain that Fermat did not have a proof. He did have (effectively) a proof for the case n=4, but it seems he worked for some time without success
by ColinWright 13y ago
It is almost certain that Fermat did not have a proof. He did have (effectively) a proof for the case n=4, but it seems he worked for some time without success on a proof for n=3. It seems unlikely he would do so if he really did have a general proof.
I'm told that if all rings of the form a+b.sqrt(-p) are unique factorization domains then there is a fairly simple proof[0], and it's plausible that Fermat momentarily forgot that this was not in fact the case. If he found the "proof" that uses this "fact" he may have got carried away and written his marginal note, then moments later done a face-palm, and not bothered to erase or correct that note.
[0] I do not speak from personal knowledge, and this may have been distorted. I believe the essence to be correct.
- andrewingram 13y agoWere Mathematicians generally convinced that a proof did exist and it was just a matter of time? Or was there a not-insignificant belief that it could be false?
- ColinWright 13y agoThe mathematicians I know and who had expressed an opinion generally believed it was almost certain to be true, but that the techniques and machinery were not yet available to tackle the problem. There was genuine astonishment when Wiles produced his proof, but no real disbelief, as might be expected had people felt it not to be true. It should be noted that it had been proven true for a very wide collection of possible exponents. You can read about the piece-wise progress here: http://www-history.mcs.st-and.ac.uk/HistTopics/Fermat%27s_last_theorem.html http://www-history.mcs.st-and.ac.uk/HistTopics/Fermat%27s_la... As a piece of trivia, in the Horizon program[0] mentioned elsewhere there's a point where J.H.Conway[1] (inventor of the game of "Life[2]" (don't ever ask him about it!)) is being interviewed, and he uses the word "prime." The editors dubbed the word "number" over the top, feeling that the audience might be put off, and knowing that "number" was accurate enough for the purpose. I don't know if Conway was ever told - I'll try to remember to ask him next time I see him. [0] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7FnXgprKgSE http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7FnXgprKgSE (roughly the 8 minute mark) [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Horton_Conway http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Horton_Conway [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conway%27s_Game_of_Life http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conway%27s_Game_of_Life
- mhartl 13y agoN.B. If you click on "Share" at YouTube, it includes a box and a field with the time in the current video. If you check the box, it gives you a direct link to that time. (The format is just http://youtu.be/7FnXgprKgSE?t=9m13s http://youtu.be/7FnXgprKgSE?t=9m13s, so you can also do it directly.) I'd link to the time in question myself in the present case, except that I listened from 7:00 to 9:00 and didn't find the thing you mentioned.
- ColinWright 13y agoIt's between 8m03s or 8m04s, and it's very hard to tell - it's very well done. If Simon Singh hadn't told me I would never have known. Here's the section: http://youtu.be/7FnXgprKgSE#t=7m55s http://youtu.be/7FnXgprKgSE#t=7m55s I didn't put the time marker on it because I wasn't able to check for sure, but I've confirmed it now.
- wging 13y ago>I'm told that if all rings of the form a+b.sqrt(-p) are unique factorization domains then there is a fairly simple proof I just can't resist showing why this is false. It's actually pretty simple. Take p=5. Then our 'integers' in this ring are of the form a + b\*sqrt(-5) for integers a, b. Taking b = 0 we see that all the normal integers are part of this ring. So consider how 6 factorizes. On the one hand we have 6 = 2 × 3... uncontroversial. But... due to the existence of new numbers in this expanded ring, we also get 6 = (1 + sqrt(-5)) × (1 - sqrt(-5)) . These are evidently two different factorizations... it suffices to show that both are prime factorizations under the modified definition of 'prime' we get when we allow factors of (a + b × sqrt(-5)). You can get there by noticing that any number of the form a + b × sqrt(-5) that factors into smaller such numbers must either be totally real (b=0), be totally imaginary (a=0), or have a larger absolute value than any number that could possibly multiply together with another number > 1 to get you 1 +/- sqrt(-5). This line of reasoning can show that 2, 3, (1 + sqrt(-5)), and (1 - sqrt(-5)) are all primes in this ring.
- ColinWright 13y agoSo you have proven that a ring of that form is not necessarily a UFD by giving a specific case where it isn't, and proving it. The real point is that assuming rings of that form are UFDs gives a relatively easy proof of FLT.