5 ms·
A very old problem turns 20
- chewxy 13y agoFun fact: In Star Trek the Next Generation, Picard mentions that Fermat's Last Theorem had gone unsolved for 800 years. 5 years after that episode came out, Wiles showed his proof.
- diminish 13y agoin Picard's parallel universe Wiles wasn't born.
- ColinWright 13y agoSee my answer elsewhere explaining why this is not true. Here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5932237 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5932237
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- ColinWright 13y agoSeason 2, Episode 12, "The Royale." This was subsequently tangentially referenced in an episode of "Deep Space Nine," which means "explanations" about Wiles never being born in the timelines are wrong. Quoting from Wikipedia: In "The Royale", an episode (first aired 27 March 1989) of Star Trek: The Next Generation, Captain Picard states that the theorem had gone unsolved for 800 years. At the end of the episode Captain Picard says, "Like Fermat's theorem, it is a puzzle we may never solve." Wiles' proof was released five years after the particular episode aired. This was subsequently mentioned in a Star Trek: Deep Space Nine episode called "Facets" during June 1995 in which Jadzia Dax comments that one of her previous hosts, Tobin Dax, had "the most original approach to the proof since Wiles over 300 years ago." This reference was generally understood by fans to be a retroactive continuity for "The Royale".
- eksith 13y agoThere's a lovely documentary from the BBC/Horizon on Andrew Wiles' accomplishment. Also ran on PBS as the "The Proof". http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7FnXgprKgSE http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7FnXgprKgSE It's a very moving piece that puts a lot of depth behind the 2d scribbling on paper that describes whole universes. Also a very humane look into the lives of mathematicians. Reminds me so much of how people obsessed with a solution will give up any semblance of a social life to pursue it.
- ibrow 13y agoHere is the book[1] that goes with that documentary. It is a really good read and not too technical at all. [1] http://www.amazon.co.uk/Fermats-Last-Theorem-confounded-greatest/dp/1841157910/ http://www.amazon.co.uk/Fermats-Last-Theorem-confounded-grea... Edit: Just seen nicholassmith posted exactly the same link. Apologies for duplication
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- nicholassmith 13y agoThe history of the Theorem and the attempts to crack it, and how Wiles finally got there is fantastic, and if you've not come across it in detail then I'd definitely recommend finding out more about it. If anyone is looking for a good book about the history of Fermat's Last Theorem I can thoroughly recommend Simon Singh's book about it [1], which is both accessible for those without a strong maths background (like myself) and paints a wonderful history of mathematics as well. In places it's more entertaining than fiction. [1] http://www.amazon.co.uk/Fermats-Last-Theorem-confounded-greatest/dp/1841157910 http://www.amazon.co.uk/Fermats-Last-Theorem-confounded-grea...
- aidos 13y agoI'd 2nd that. I've read two other of his books, The Code Book and Big Bang, in which he gives cryptography and physics similar treatment.
- dagw 13y agoGreat book, no matter your level of math knowledge or interest. I'm an all round science nerd with a MSc in maths, my wife is an architect with a background in art history and graphic design and a aversion to all things mathematical, yet we both really liked book.
- arh68 13y agoI read the book as a kid (I'm guessing 15), and while I probably understood little of it, I read the whole thing. It was definitely inspiring to learn Wiles' slow persistence/progress, and the never-would've-guessed kind of connections that come up in maths.
- dtparr 13y agoSomewhat off topic, but I was somewhat surprised that architect is a viable career for someone with an aversion to all things mathematical. Does she still need math, she just doesn't enjoy it, or does the modeling software these days take care of all the calculations necessary?
- 13y ago
- hmexx 13y agoI'm not a mathematician, but I find it unsatisfying that the solution to such a simply stated theorem requires 100s of pages of mathematics. Would have been cooler if the proof was extremely simple to write out, but required outside-the-box thought process that evaded thousands of humans for centuries. I hope the same thing does not happen to physics. Discoveries that lead to simple equations like e=mc^2 are so cool!
- dbaupp 13y agoWhat often happens is the first version of a proof is long and arduous, but the new ideas that it spawns slowly circle back so that someone else can come up with a much neater proof, it just takes a while. (Proving theorems is hard work!)
- assafs 13y agoIn other cases, a very complex problem can be stated very simply, especially to a lay person. A good example is the Jordan curve theorem[1], which at first sight seems like a trivial problem but in effect requires a good deal of topology and analysis to even understand why it is so complicated in the first place. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jordan%27s_theorem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jordan%27s_theorem
- ColinWright 13y agoThere is an obvious enhancement of the Jordan Curve Theorem, which is to say that the interior is effectively a disk, and the exterior is effectively a plane with a hole. There is then an obvious 3D version, with a (topological) sphere separating space into a topological ball[0] and a topological R^3 with a hole. This enhanced version, although natural and obvious, is false. I use this as an example of why "obvious" things aren't always true, need proving, and understanding their proofs can lead to useful insights. [0] Edit: corrected "sphere" to "ball"
- tehwalrus 13y agoOoh, OK, you've tickled my interest. Can you provide an explanation (or a link to something similar) with the disproof of the 3D version?
- andrewingram 13y agoI've occasionally caught myself wondering whether there is a completely different proof that could have been discovered using 17th century mathematics. Or is it the case that the maths used by Andrew Wiles would have been understandable to Fermat? Namely, I'm wondering if Fermat was actually lying and he just got lucky that a proof was eventually found.
- tome 13y agoFermat definitely couldn't have understood Wiles' proof in terms of the mathematics of his time, since it relies on a lot of theory that wasn't available then. It's technically possible that there's a proof that only requires the mathematics of that period, but since no one has found it yet it seems unlikely.
- raverbashing 13y agoNot lying, but probably thought quickly of a proof that later was revealed to not be a correct one (not sure Fermat got to this point)
- tehwalrus 13y agoI agree; if he didn't write it down (and test it), it was probably a simple one that was subtly wrong.
- andrewingram 13y agoThat's a good point, for some reason it didn't occur to me that he might simply have been wrong...
- dagw 13y agoI don't have a copy of the book in front of me, but I seem to recall Simon Singh's book talked about simple, but flawed attempted proof that was found in the 19th century, that might have been what Fermat found.
- rst 13y agoMore likely Fermat was just mistaken. There have been numerous flawed proofs over the years --- most likely Fermat stumbled on one of those, realized the error (hence, never published), but never bothered to correct the note he'd left in the margins on of one his books.
- tokenadult 13y agoSome comments ask whether Pierre de Fermat may have had a proof of his conjecture (which I now call the Fermat-Wiles Theorem) using the mathematics of his day. Agreeing with Colin, on historical grounds, I think Fermat did NOT have a proof of his famous conjecture. The historical reasoning works like this. In Fermat's day, mathematical "publishing" was not submission of articles to peer-reviewed journals, but people interested in mathematics sending personal letters to one another. (One of the first mathematical journals, if I remember correctly, began as a collection of mathematicians' letters to one another, something like turning individual emails into an email list.) Fermat was a lawyer by occupation, and did mathematics in his free time. He corresponded with other mathematicians of his era, including Pascal. In all the surviving correspondence Fermat had with other mathematicians, there is no trace of a proof of "Fermat's Last Theorem," even though, as Colin pointed out, he wrote about simpler cases of that theorem. The real historical reasoning comes in by considering dates of the primary sources. Fermat's note to himself in the margin of the printed Latin translation of Diophantus was written EARLY in Fermat's investigation of number theory. He read that book, taking notes in the margins as he read, and then he wrote for years afterward about interesting number theory problems. The book with Fermat's annotations was published after Fermat's death by Fermat's son, and that is when the marginal note became known to the world, but Fermat had plenty of time--and plenty of pieces of paper with wider margins--to write out a complete proof of his conjecture if he actually had one. So as essentially all mathematicians have concluded on mathematical grounds, and as all historians have concluded on historical grounds, most likely Fermat briefly thought he had a complete proof of his conjecture, which he then worked on, discovering a mistake in his reasoning. He proved a simpler case of the theorem, died, and then when his notes were published, other mathematicians worked on the full conjecture for 350 years before Wiles found the complete proof, based on advanced research by other mathematicians still alive today. Google Books links to the historical background from mathematicians who write good popular books about mathematics: http://books.google.com/books?id=I-RSVN6TjXsC&pg=PT95 http://books.google.com/books?id=I-RSVN6TjXsC&pg=PT95 http://books.google.com/books?id=ZhK73qVgOw0C&pg=PA265 http://books.google.com/books?id=ZhK73qVgOw0C&pg=PA265
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]