5 ms·
The safeguards for actual analysts who use the data "officially" are probably a lot stronger than for sysadmins (like Snowden) who have access through side chan
by rdl 13y ago
The safeguards for actual analysts who use the data "officially" are probably a lot stronger than for sysadmins (like Snowden) who have access through side channels. They probably log access through the front door of the webapp and would question someone doing queries on blatantly non-work related things -- this has caught people in healthcare looking up the medical records of famous people, in the past.
They could probably still get access to a very limited number through some pretext, or with cooperation from other staff (like sysadmins or the reviewers), but it's less of a risk with NSA I think than it is with other agencies.
- samstave 13y agoExactly, except for the logging part: It would appear that either Snowden was able to circumvent the logging policies via his admin privs or they were not in place. When I was head of an IT division within lockheed (non-classified) I could have accessed anything - with admin accounts i was the sole owner of. I was ethically precluded from doing so... At a company where there is "open access" with "logging the shit out of access (e.g. Facebook) -- then this situation could arise where an arbitrary employee could access any data, assuming they had the knowledge of where to find the info they were looking for, didn't get caught and the logging was either faulty, ignored or fictitious -- or the employee used an account other than their own to avoid suspicions. It would be interesting,actually, to understand to what deep level of privs B.A.H - as a company - was afforded to NSA data/systems/programs/etc... One thing I am not clear on is how this employee of a 3rd party def contractor (albeit, supposedly the biggest to the NSA) was able to access information that is considered to be so deeply secret to the USG? Is this an indication that a significantly "important" program (PRISM) was, for the most part, outsourced to be run by contractors such as Snowden within BAH? Did Snowden systematically seek out, deftly, access to information over a long period of time through his privs afforded him as a sys ad? This to me is the most intriguing and unknown part: For how long was Snowden planning this? Was this something he truly accomplished on his own? Or was there a cast of supporting characters that we are unaware of" If there is no supporting characters who helped him put this together - that this guy is one of the most brilliant high-school drop-outs I have heard of. If there is a cast of supporting characters were they operating as whistleblowers in support of the seemingly patriotic reveal that we have thus far seen? Or was there a supporting cast of characters that have helped snowden architect this whole event, masterfully - it seems, for a motive that we, the outsiders, are not yet aware: There seem to be three possible realities if this is true: 1) Snowden plus team is a smokescreen designed to purposefully air this info to further the surveillance agenda by seeing how far the world acquiesces to it. Stir up a reaction that can result in tighter controls of liberty when protesting pops up and the USG can claim that these are all threats to our national security and these efforts are vital. 2) Snowden plus team are truly patriots and heroes and are looking to stop the furtherance of USG/tyranny over individual freedom and are airing this info to allow for an open dialogue. 3) Snowden and team really are double/triple agents and are an attack on the USG directly attempting to make the USG look bad and have the US lose face/credibility... (I am sure there are countless other potential scenarios that the NSA/USG have mapped out... I would be REALLY interested in hearing them for consideration) --- My personal opinion is simple - I am very happy this series of events has taken place as I have known of Echelon for decades - and now feel that there is 100% irrefutable proof that it is in place... what the next steps are is unclear, but I hope that it is an awakening and invigoration of people all over the world to fight to make this place a better world to live in rather than a worse one.
- XorNot 13y agoSnowden didn't circumvent anything, because he hasn't released anything. Snowden has made a lot of grandiose claims which he can't actually back up, because beyond a few slides and some very common knowledge stuff (NSA hacking China) which he could've outright made up he hasn't been able to show he could do any of the stuff he claims. If you were aware of any notable hacking incidents in China, and could claim to have privileged knowledge, then it's easy to say the NSA were behind whatever you want (just in this case, obviously the NSAs mission would imply it attempts hacking of foreign networks). PRISM is disclosed via a powerpoint presentation. Presentation as in, a thing you tend to show to a large audience. Its highly likely he was simply given a copy of it after being shown it, since good internal education and knowledge sharing is a pretty core concept to running a successful enterprise.
- grey-area 13y agoSnowden didn't circumvent anything, because he hasn't released anything. He clearly has released top secret documents; your assertion that he "hasn't released anything" is simply untrue. If you truly feel this isn't a leak, you obviously think the top secret classification is irrelevant and disagree with the US gov. on this. Some examples of his assertions verified by documents: NSA keeping daily phone records for every American NSA receiving data from US internet companies GCHQ (and thus NSA) keeping 3 days complete internet traffic passing through UK GCHQ (and thus NSA) keeping the content of all UK text messages Re access controls at the NSA, I find it telling that an analyst was able to look at Bill Clinton's emails and only be reprimanded afterward - if proper legal controls on each target of surveillance were in place, or even perfunctory control by supervisors, that could never have happened.
- XorNot 13y agoHe's released - again - a powerpoint presentation. The NSA phone record stuff? That was public knowledge in 2007. The GCHQ stuff seems like it was a powerpoint presentation too - no one's claimed anything more. It's a leak, yes. He should be prosecuted for it, yes. But it's also widely disseminated internal data by nature of being a presentation. Everything else is him claiming to have knowledge of things, without providing specific details beyond "his word". There's no reason to think he had the powers he claims to have and he's been leaking the NSAs foreign survieillance programs in broad-strokes like a sieve, but American specific stuff? Mysteriously quiet. With equally quiet walkbacks of the claims by the Washington Post and Guardian.