6 ms·
Push back more on the request? The 4th amendment includes this part: "particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized
by breck 13y ago
Push back more on the request?
The 4th amendment includes this part:
"particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized"
Describing what you want as " all e-mails " is exactly the type of description this part of the amendment is meant to prevent. It's way too broad.
- thrownaway2424 13y agoThere is a 10-bullet list of the particular things to be seized. How would you have made it more specific?
- betterunix 13y agoBy not having such broad categories of things to be seized. It is not "specific" to seize "every email message he sent to anyone ever."
- thrownaway2424 13y agoI'm sure that will be of great interest if this person is ever charged with a crime. Until then, he has neither venue nor standing to challenge the warrant. Imperfect warrants are a problem for the state at trial. Outside of trial, any old warrant will do.
- breck 13y agoExactly. "All emails" negates all bullet points. It's like asking for 9 specific items in a real world warrant, and then point #10 is "and your whole house and everything in it".
- rayiner 13y agoNo, it's like "all documents in the office" which is fair game for a warrant. You think warrants require you to specifically mention every document?
- rayiner 13y ago"betterunix's g-mail account" is plenty specific as a "place to be searched" and "e-mails" is plenty specific as "things to be seized." If you printed out every letter you've ever sent to someone and put it in a filing cabinet, it would be totally fair game for a warrant to get the contents of the filing cabinet. Or if you kept them on a hard drive, it would be totally fair game to get a warrant to get the hard drive. In this case, the problem is not investigators overreaching the law. The problem is the amount of information consolidation modern technology enables and encourages.
- betterunix 13y ago"If you printed out every letter you've ever sent to someone and put it in a filing cabinet, it would be totally fair game for a warrant to get the contents of the filing cabinet" Except that people do not typically do that, and it is reasonable to expect that a filing cabinet will contain only important or current documents. With GMail, you typically see personal messages that date back years, probably long before whatever crime the person is suspected of. "The problem is the amount of information consolidation modern technology enables and encourages." I think for once, we might agree. The relevant laws were written with a very different model of communication in mind.
- Zigurd 13y agoHow is "everything in the computer" different from "everything in the house?" Or are we now writing search warrants for "everything in the house?"
- rayiner 13y agoBecause a computer is a small self-contained thing that you can often fit in a bag? That's my point about information consolidation: the law is rooted in the physical (and necessarily so). You can wax philosophical about "virtual spaces" but at the end of the day a hard drive is a small physical object that is treated the same as any other small physical object.
- Zigurd 13y ago
- jholman 13y agoGoogle has a legal team whose full-time job is pushing back on these requests. At some point, they have to either obey the law, or go to prison themselves. Get off your high horse. It feels like some people won't be satisfied unless Google says "well, our existence has many benefits, but it also makes it slightly easier for the government to spy on people, so we're closing up shop".
- breck 13y agoI think Google is doing a great job. I was offering a suggestion of one angle they could play.
- throwaway10001 13y agoGoogle has a legal team whose full-time job is pushing back on these requests. At some point, they have to either obey the law, or go to prison themselves. Get off your high horse. Google has a business model whose entire premise is to push the envelope on privacy and to collect as much as possible and hold it forever--to make a few extra pennies per user. Get off your high horse. Google (and FB) is /are a menace to us all, even if only because they gather so much private data about us.
- mpyne 13y agoHow can they collect private data on you personally if you don't use their product?
- throwaway10001 13y agoHow can they collect private data on you personally if you don't use their product? How can NSA collect data if you don't use your phone, email or browse the internet? See Google's reach, especially via Analytics, Adsense, G+, Youtube etc. Yeah, we agree that people should think for using so many products from any one company.
- malandrew 13y agoThe warrant should detail the nature of the crime being investigated, the dates under which they believe a crime was committed and the range of dates that are reasonable to investigate based on the aforementioned facts. That's reasonable. A blanket warrant impacting all emails since the beginning of time is not reasonable. If the cant name a crime and give a date or dates then they shouldn't be asking for a warrant.
- rayiner 13y ago> It's way too broad. No way would that be considered an over-broad warrant. If, e.g., you suspected someone of financial fraud, it would be totally okay to get a warrant for the contents of all the filing cabinets in his office.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- breck 13y agoBut I think "filing cabinets in the office" is a lot more specific. I think an equivalent would be "emails that contain the phrase X", or emails from these addresses, et cetera.
- rayiner 13y agoYou think filing cabinets in the office is more specific than e-mails in an account?