3 ms·
In a free society, you can't guarantee that you will stop terror attacks. They do cause damage and mayhem, however that is strictly localised unless the governm
by grey-area 13y ago
In a free society, you can't guarantee that you will stop terror attacks. They do cause damage and mayhem, however that is strictly localised unless the government overreacts and introduces draconian measures in a mistaken attempt to find terrorists under every rock. The UK survived decades of terrorism (sponsored by some US politicians like Rep. Peter King, now so ferocious against terrorists) without relying on mass surveillance of the kind it is now engaged in, in partnership with the US. It's not necessary to stop the attacks, only to survive them. Your question is like asking: How can we stop the next war?
In fact the aims of terror are principally to provoke a government to introduce repressive measures and lash out, and in the process, damage itself and its credibility with citizens. I think the aims of Bin Laden were probably to induce terror, fear, and paranoia in the US, and unfortunately they have succeeded, probably beyond their wildest dreams. Huge amounts of money and numbers of lives have been squandered, and the only result has been a series of failed states half-way across the world, a casual disregard for the rule of law, and a growing surveillance state at home destroying the very ideas the US claims to represent.
It's time for the US to recognise that expanding the architecture of surveillance and engaging in an eternal war against an ill-defined enemy is not going to make anyone safer, quite the reverse.
- Sven7 13y agoIf you were a Congresswoman, and a terror attack happened in your district, and you give this speech, what do you think the reaction would be?
- chronic25 13y agoI would not be the congressman of a district full of idiots to begin with. The reaction would not be negative.
- grey-area 13y agoLike your previous question, this is a non sequitur. The answer to a local terror attack is not hysteria about stopping all terror and surveillance of all citizens (99.9% of whom will never encounter terrorists in any form). The answer is to give the police and law enforcement time to do their work (which they do very well) and support them in trying to catch the people who committed that crime. The Boston bombers were found by police work after the fact, not by the mass surveillance of the population you are advocating as a solution to 'stop terror'. That's a solution to another problem - it's far more useful for finding dissenters of any stripe and undermining the rule of law than for catching terrorists.
- camus 13y agoThose Who Sacrifice Liberty For Security Deserve Neither.
- enraged_camel 13y agoIf I were really brave, like Norwegian Prime Minister Jens Stoltenberg was after the 2011 massacre there, then I would stick by the ideals my country was founded upon and wouldn't particularly care about the public's reaction. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_Norway_attacks#Domestic https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_Norway_attacks#Domestic "At a press conference the morning after the attacks, Prime Minister Jens Stoltenberg and Justice Minister Knut Storberget addressed the country. Stoltenberg called the attack a "national tragedy" and the worst atrocity in Norway since World War II. Stoltenberg further vowed that the attack would not hurt Norwegian democracy, and said the proper answer to the violence was "more democracy, more openness, but not naivety".
- greenyoda 13y ago"In a free society, you can't guarantee that you will stop terror attacks." Even a repressive government can't guarantee that it will stop terror attacks.
- grey-area 13y agoYes of course, but the key here is that even if you could stop all terror attacks, many things are more important than stopping terrorist attacks, many things which are undermined by dragnet surveillance. Stopping the terrorists is entirely the wrong debate and not the most important issue here - it's a convenient hot button issue which, because it has no solution and is emotive, distracts much time and attention from the real issues in question.
- jlgreco 13y agoEven North Korea cannot prevent assassination attempts. That should be all anybody wanting a "solution" to terrorism has to know.
- fnordfnordfnord 13y agoA repressive government wouldn't stop things which can be used to justify the need for repression.