4 ms·
>"because the government was found to have illegally bugged his phone and broken into the office of his psychiatrist Can this not be actual legal precedence AG
by samstave 13y ago
>"because the government was found to have illegally bugged his phone and broken into the office of his psychiatrist
Can this not be actual legal precedence AGAINST the entire NSA debacle to begin with?
Seriously, can an IAMAL comment on if this could be used?
- rosser 13y agoIANAL. My understanding of how these things work, however, is that the case against Ellsberg was dismissed by the trial judge, and therefore does not establish any precedent. If he'd been convicted, and the conviction overturned on appeal (and the conviction's having been overturned was upheld in any appeals thereof), then precedent would have been created. The reason it works this way is that trial courts are venues for finding facts, while appellate courts are vehicles for addressing questions of law surrounding those findings of fact. It's how those questions of law are resolved, so-called "case law", that creates precedents. IANAL; corrections welcome.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]