5 ms·
I doubt there is anything harder than to extradite Assange from an embassy which has granted Assange asylum. Since that’s the actually reality, if an extraditi
by belorn 13y ago
I doubt there is anything harder than to extradite Assange from an embassy which has granted Assange asylum.
Since that’s the actually reality, if an extradition is made, UK isn't as much in the picture expect that the embassy is technically located inside the UK.
- tptacek 13y agoNo, that argument moves the goalposts. He's in the embassy because he didn't want to go to Sweden. He claims not to have wanted to go to Sweden because of the ease of extraditing him from Sweden. But it was easier to extradite him while he was walking the streets of the UK.
- b6 13y agoBut the reality of ease of extradition may be very different than what the laws would suggest. The US has been secretly breaking its own most basic laws. Maybe Sweden does, too.
- tptacek 13y agoI'm amused by the meme emergent from the Assange debacle that Sweden is some US client state, but the UK is fiercely independent. Like Sweden is Belarus, and nobody really knows anything about them.
- b6 13y agoI wasn't aware of any such meme. I don't think many Assange supporters have a positive view of the UK. I certainly don't. The lying criminals in one government are willing to work with the lying criminals in other governments.
- whodoneit 13y agoWe know a lot about Sweden and they are for all intents and purposes a US client state. Americans seem oblivious to how their government "project power" round the world. This is how it goes: Majority in parliament or equivalent: "we're not going to buy US fighter jets"/"we won't support this war"/"we're going to go on record saying that this group of people deserve some kind of basic human rights support". Anonymous US embassy source: "That would be extremely ill advised". Majority in parliament: "Oops, sorry. Forgot who we were working for there." Democracy is great.
- erikpukinskis 13y agoI'm confused about how you can be so confident in your assessments of the "ease of extradition" property of these two countries. To me that's like claiming you know which country is going to support the US in it's next war. Sure you can look at the laws and the history, but these things seem very fuzzy to me. I don't understand where your confidence comes from.
- tptacek 13y agoDoing a lot of reading. This subject has come up a bunch of times on HN before.
- mpyne 13y agoIf you paid attention to HN (and other tech news sites) earlier than about 2012 or so, you'd see that the U.K. got in the news practically every year for extraditing someone to the U.S. on charges that even I would agree are too minor to warrant it. I think the last famous case was Gary McKinnon or something like that but there have been many others.
- aptwebapps 13y agoIIRC, he happened to be in England when the extradition request came. He fought that and if the US had requested the UK to arrest and extradite him he presumably would have fought that too. I'm not certain that he was allowed to leave the UK on his own after the extradition request was made. Wasn't he actually on bail? It's also possible that he didn't think the US would come after him until the extradition request. That said, I think it definitely sounds better to give the reason that he does than to say he's afraid of being convicted in Sweden even if he wouldn't be explicitly admitting guilt.
- belorn 13y agoHe might have gone to the embassy a yea ago for reasons related to the UK, but that doesn't relate to the arguments why he today won't go. The parent comments which I replied to was talking why he won't go to Sweden. If the parent post had said why he didn't go to Sweden, ie in past sense, then you would be right that my argument would be moving the goalpost.