3 ms·
What exactly is the connection between Assange and Stallman? Why does Stallman turning out to be "right" have anything to do with Assange's future? In any case
by untog 13y ago
What exactly is the connection between Assange and Stallman? Why does Stallman turning out to be "right" have anything to do with Assange's future?
In any case, I don't think anyone thought Stallman was "wrong", just that he presented his points in a hysterical way that detracted from him being taken seriously. He still does.
We're the only ones with any grounds whatsoever [...] to fight against this
What does this mean? Hacker News isn't unique in any relevant way.
- GuiA 13y agoGood questions; those points deserve clarifications. >What exactly is the connection between Assange and Stallman? Why does Stallman turning out to be "right" have anything to do with Assange's future? Both are activists, who have warned us (and are still warning us) about the consequences of letting those powerful in the world of atoms exert their power in the world of bits. Their causes are distinct, but are two facets of the same object. I highly recommend reading this essay by Assange: http://blog.p2pfoundation.net/the-internet-is-a-threat-to-human-civilization-julian-assanges-a-call-to-cryptographic-arms/2012/12/24 http://blog.p2pfoundation.net/the-internet-is-a-threat-to-hu... >What does this mean? Hacker News isn't unique in any relevant way. I'm saying "we" as in "we who work in technology and program for a living", not as in "we on HN". The latter is a subset of the former, and a somewhat representative one in my experience. Hence my phrasing. Hope that clarifies my original points a bit :)
- adrianbye 13y agowell said. your original point was completely clear btw.
- ownagefool 13y agoI don't think Stallman presents his points in a hysterical way, he's just uncompromising when the vast majority of us are pragmatic by necessity. The problem is most of us are pretty simple; One cannot resonably follow his advice, thus we believe he is wrong. It's a catch 22 though, as if more agreed, at least some of his ideals would be worthwhile. Personally I'm not super bothered about whether your flash in the pan app is open source or not, but it's really frustrating when people don't buy into open data standard and open hardware drivers. Ultimately, that's a bit like chopping your foot off to save your toe.