3 ms·
If Brazilians can create a 1 million strong protest over a 0.1$ bus fare increase, I'd hope Americans from the "land of the free, home of the brave" would be ab
by mtgx 13y ago
If Brazilians can create a 1 million strong protest over a 0.1$ bus fare increase, I'd hope Americans from the "land of the free, home of the brave" would be able to do the same over the revealing of a massive spying apparatus that's used against Americans and completely infringing on the 4th amendment.
But even more importantly it's infringing on their human rights that should guarantee that they don't have to live in fear in a surveillance state and they have the right to anonymous speech or being able to have confidential conversations with people, without having to think that everything they say is being recorded by the government, and if if they even say the "wrong words" they may end up on certain "lists" that are monitored more heavily.
- notdrunkatall 13y agoI hope for the same thing, but I suspect that I'm going to be disappointed.
- mpyne 13y agoIs the protest over the bus fare increase? I was always told it was merely the latest in a long string of events drawing in protesters. Likewise, didn't the group that incited protests over the bus fare increase later support ending the protests, since the protests are said to have been co-opted by militants and fascists? Likewise likewise, neither anonymous speech or confidential conversations have gone away (that is, where they were possible before). But you may have to choose to enforce that by technical means (a capability we didn't used to have, by the way, just ask people who lived in the age of letters and phone calls). Likewise^3, the prioritization of who would be monitored by warrant is certainly a legitimate function of the security apparatus, unless you're trying to claim that picking random conversations to get a warrant for is somehow more effective in breaking up terror cells or criminal conspiracies. I would argue that taking action against people merely for what they believe in is screwed up, but I not only wouldn't blame people for keeping a closer eye on those who advocate large changes to government, I'd be offended as a taxpayer if they weren't doing exactly that.
- outworlder 13y ago> Is the protest over the bus fare increase? I was always told it was merely the latest in a long string of events drawing in protesters. Brazilian here, and you are right. The big protests started in one capital and not all capitals raised their fares, at least not recently. One week before that, in my city, we had thousands of protesters, who wanted something to be done about the violence (873 people were murdered by gunshot in the first quarter alone, out of a population of 2.5 million, giving over 60 per hundred thousand people). After the demonstrations in São Paulo, it spread like wildfire. Since not all cities have the same problems (at least, not in the same priority), the protesters had different agendas. But they were (and stil are) all over the country.
- Dn_Ab 13y agoThe important bit is that the bus fares are completely irrelevant now. Most of my life I've thought that malaise amongst the oppressed was the stable state. But these protests suggest that is either wrong, or something has shifted the vocabulary of the dynamics from equilibrium to attractors. At least for a certain class of countries [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abelian_sandpile_model#Self-organized_criticality http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abelian_sandpile_model#Self-org...] It remains to be seen if this has done anything to dampen the strong dystopian possibility of cross-national oligarchs whose members are large bureaucracies and whose mission is the status quo. And it is worth paying attention to these countries where broad abuses are not merely potential. Because if it is not possible to regain their rights, then it is all the more important to not ignore the currently well intended overreach of Lawful Good Paladins.
- diminoten 13y agoHeh, that's not fair, our country's population is more spread out, and our largest city is not our capital.
- thwest 13y agoWe have cars that can drive us to the central protest location, and Brasilia is only the fourth largest city in Brasil.
- enraged_camel 13y agoSaying the Brazillian protests are about bus fares is like saying the Turkish protests are about a park. Your general point is good but your ignorance is getting in the way of communicating it effectively.
- mtgx 13y agoBut that's exactly the point. For Brazilians and Turkish people, those were the tipping points. Where is America's tipping point? Haven't Americans had enough of government corruption and abuses of power already? Confidence level in Congress is at the lowest levels ever. So where are the mass protests, in the land of the brave?