3 ms·
there's one great read that discribes the fundamental flaws of defense procurement pretty well (http://pogoarchives.org/labyrinth/full-labyrinth-text-w-covers.p
by hef19898 13y ago
there's one great read that discribes the fundamental flaws of defense procurement pretty well (http://pogoarchives.org/labyrinth/full-labyrinth-text-w-covers.pdf http://pogoarchives.org/labyrinth/full-labyrinth-text-w-cove...).
Mainly geared towards the US, but the basics works for Germany, too. As far as the procurment of the NH90 and Tiger is concerned, there are more flaws in the specification, design and program that fit in a book. Everybody aims at a silver bullet solution only to end up with a one made of lead for the price of a golden one.
One point that dtruck me most when I was still part of the "system" was the shere amount of spec and design changes that happened AFTER development was finished. the solution is called Retrofit. That and the important difference of a design to be able to perform a certain task and a design being allowed to perform it by the german army.
One example is the NH90 not able to transport troops with combat gear (German army view pint) and the NH90 being suvvessfully used to airlift troop over half of Finland.
Another one would be the Eurofighter being unable to perform ground support operations in the german air force and the very same plane doing just that for the british.
And the A400M would be apretty good plane hadn't politians insisted on a new prop engine built by a paneuropean consortium that did that for the very first time. That other planes would be just as good, agree. Even i would have rather opted for the Antonov An70 :-)
What really sad about the NH90 is the wasted potential. Considering the age of the Blackhawks, the potential market is HUGE. The situation being what it is, this ain't gone happen. But that's a point the NH90 has in common with the F-35, doesn't it?
- ckozlowski 13y agoThanks for the document. I've only started reading it, but it looks rather good. (I'm astonished and thrilled that in the essays, the authors cite their sources.) Good find. =)