3 ms·
Rather, the recent issue is a disagreement over what constitutes a violation of privacy, e.g. whether electronic collection of data (without a human listener) c
by grey-area 13y ago
Rather, the recent issue is a disagreement over what constitutes a violation of privacy, e.g. whether electronic collection of data (without a human listener) constitutes violation.
If you think accessing private communications should not be allowed except in limited circumstances, you should be very worried by the storing of all this information. The implications are that anyone's privacy can be violated simply because of a policy change by those agencies who store and swap this information across national borders at some unspecified point in the future. In addition to future use by your national agency - your data might be collected in one country, and used in 10 others without control. The only way to stop future abuse is not to collect the data.
The intelligence agencies have arrogated to themselves the right to listen to any communication by using lawyerly arguments like yours over the difference between collection and listening, and denying that they are using all this information they are collecting without proper legal authority (of course for the NSA, that legal authority turns out to be a six-monthly rubber stamp on their procedures, not oversight of their actual work, but oversight of what they say they do).
So I think your distinction between storing and accessing is unimportant and not worth arguing about - storage enables later access, so once it has all been stored, you have no control over the way it will be used (and it will be used).