4 ms·
Presumably the same justification/reasoning could be used to serve a home/business search warrant.
by tantalor 13y ago
Presumably the same justification/reasoning could be used to serve a home/business search warrant.
- daviddoran 13y agoWould a judge approve the warrant though? Just because this person communicated with Assange?
- betterunix 13y agoGee, it sure would be nice to know what happens at a FISC hearing...
- rayiner 13y agoCan the FISC grant Article III warrants?
- betterunix 13y agoCan information gathered under a FISA warrant be used to get another court to grant an Article III warrant, and can such information be critical to getting an Article III warrant? If a rubber stamp like FISC enables the government to get Article III warrants that it would not otherwise get, then FISC might as well just hand out Article III warrants.
- rayiner 13y agoIt's not a rhetorical question, I don't know the answer to it one way or the other. As to your second sentence, I think it's very reductionist. I see a FISC warrant as functioning like a subpoena. Say the SEC subpoena's your company's financial records from your accountant, and finds in there evidence that is sufficient to get a proper warrant to get documents from your company's premises. Does that mean there is no protection or purpose to the SEC not just being able to give itself Article III warrants?
- burntsushi 13y agoThat might be the case. But you'd know about it. And why.
- magicalist 13y agoYou would know about it, but the warrant can still be sealed if it "is necessitated by a compelling government interest", so you can no idea why it was being done. In theory you can get this reversed, but it is common for courts to uphold the government's interest in keeping investigations secret well beyond normal disclosure dates, in a few cases even up to and during the trial against the person who was served the warrant.