3 ms·
I'm not sure I see the difference between the freelancer->fulltime and contractor/probation->fulltime progressions. Is is just because in the latter case they w
by andrewflnr 13y ago
I'm not sure I see the difference between the freelancer->fulltime and contractor/probation->fulltime progressions. Is is just because in the latter case they weren't already a freelancer/contractor? Is there a big terminological issue I'm missing?
- tptacek 13y agoThe two issues (unfairness and inefficiency) are somewhat orthogonal. So let me just guess that you're referring to the "inefficiency" side of the problem. The problem is that companies looking to fill full-time slots are looking to fill full-time slots, not to engage a succession of contractors. By requiring candidates to perform in a contractor role prior to signing on full-time, companies are effectively disqualifying most candidates that are currently employed. That's because very few people sniffing around for a better job than the one they have now can afford to drop out of the market for months or even weeks delivering work as a contractor. That's not how most people switch jobs; instead, most people search for their new job from the comfort and security of their current job, knowing that if (say) interviews don't work out, they can take their time looking for the next lead, knowing that they can continue to execute on their current job. This is a problem for employers because virtually everybody you'd want to hire in this market is already employed.
- mechanical_fish 13y agoAnd those who aren't full-time employed may not bite on the contract-to-perm offer either. Because in my limited experience "here's our contract-to-perm offer" usually translates to: "Please freelance for us at sub-market rates, under our poorly-thought-out non-negotiable boilerplate contract with unclear deliverables." Typically they offer to take a slightly-low full-time weekly salary+benefits number, divide it by 40, and pay that as an hourly rate. Oh, goody. No company wants to pay a contractor the going rate for contractors, and then face the unenviable task of talking that contractor's rate back down again when making them a full-time offer. Nor do they want the bother of haggling over the details of a contract deal that will almost always prove, one way or the other, to have been a wasted opportunity. (If the worker proves to be competent, the contract will be replaced by a full-time offer as quickly as possible. If the worker is incompetent, the contract will be terminated at the earliest practical date. In no case does anyone care much about the contract. It is a consolation prize for everyone involved.) My personal philosophy is to treat contracting and employment like oil and water. Both can be tasty. But they are different things and one does not merge seamlessly into the other.
- andrewflnr 13y agoSo the difference is whether you started off in a full-time job, and come into the deal hoping for one? If you're a freelancer, the chance of a fulltime position is one you can take or leave at your leisure. But if you start off as a fulltimer somewhere else and come into some contract-to-hire scenario, that's what you don't like. Amirite? Anyway, I learned. Thanks.
- thestoic 13y agoContrary to the other comment, moonlighting is just as easy for someone FT employed to try as someone who is no employed. The FT employed can make 20-30hrs available a week to try out a company on a set amount of work and get a feel for it. The alternative is to go through a set interviews (that if you read the google article, are useless) and then change your job (effectively putting a bullet on your last job) only to find out that you hate your new job and now you are stuck there. Try outs are safer and available for all.
- tptacek 13y agoSo now we're talking about constricting the flow of candidates down to those who are willing to accept a second job for weeks to mitigate the concerns of future employers. The problem here is obvious: the best candidates don't ever have to put up with stuff like this. They're actively courted by prospective employers. Sure, not every candidate can be "one of the best candidates". But why would a rational employer select a screening process that overtly rules those candidates out?