7 ms·
Any evidence to back up Musk's claim? Being a Senator's employee must be annoying sometimes. "Hi, I'm calling to defend Telsa Motors because its CEO told me to
by untog 13y ago
Any evidence to back up Musk's claim? Being a Senator's employee must be annoying sometimes.
"Hi, I'm calling to defend Telsa Motors because its CEO told me to. No, I do not know anything more about the topic I am calling about"
- agildehaus 13y agoHe referenced the bill shortly thereafter: http://assembly.state.ny.us/leg/?bn=S05725&term=2013 http://assembly.state.ny.us/leg/?bn=S05725&term=2013 http://assembly.state.ny.us/leg/?default_fld=&bn=A07844&term=2013&Summary=Y&Text=Y http://assembly.state.ny.us/leg/?default_fld=&bn=A07844&term...
- cobrausn 13y agoThanks for finding that. At the time I posted this, he hadn't linked the bill.
- just2n 13y agoEnglish, specifically whatever dialect that is, is a horrible medium for encoding laws. Further, the diffing format used there is atrocious. Law is code. Why haven't we fixed this yet?
- epoxyhockey 13y agoLaw is code. Why haven't we fixed this yet? Because lawyers love buggy code.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 13y ago> English, specifically whatever dialect that is, is a horrible medium for encoding laws. Compared to what, exactly? > Further, the diffing format used there is atrocious. That's a really common problem. > Law is code. Why haven't we fixed this yet? Mostly, because there is no first party money in it, and there's considerable expense to do it as a third-party solution, because of exactly the problem that this is directed at solving. There's quite a bit of money in third-party solutions, which are provided by several vendors to the people who have the money and motivation to pay for them (people who professionally deal with the law), as components of wider research suites that cover more than just statute law (including many copyright-protected sources). Third-party solutions that use only the free-of-copyright public information don't have a lot of market, and would have a lot of expense to create and maintain (not the system, so much as keeping the data current.)
- nawitus 13y agoEnglish is not the problem here. You can write sufficiently clear language (which is not formated with caps lock..) in English. The problem is just the custom in United States of writing complex laws instead of writing the main points and letting the courts interpret it. For example, here's[1] a reasonably sane-looking law written in English. 1. http://www.finlex.fi/en/laki/kaannokset/1994/en19940543.pdf http://www.finlex.fi/en/laki/kaannokset/1994/en19940543.pdf
- ttcbj 13y agoI recently read Robert Caro's biography of Robert Moses. RM built most major highways and parks in NY state, and effectively became an absolute ruler in his domain. For 40 years he exercised near total control. It made me understand the political process completely different way. For RM, the 'broken' differencing format was a feature, not a bug. It allowed him to slip though all kinds of law changes without people understanding what he was up to. The book has many, many examples of exactly this differencing format being put to use to gain power. The point about the differencing format is more broadly true - prior to reading the book, I thought politics was about having the right ideas, and explaining them clearly. But the book compellingly argues that politics is really about obtaining and wielding power. The people who thrive in politics are more interested in power than ideas. It is a book that is well worth reading, especially if you are an idealistic programmer (like I was) who cannot understand why we can't just 'clean politics up.' (Also, Caro's LBJ biography is awesome, with similar themes.)
- moens 13y ago"...politics is really about obtaining and wielding power. The people who thrive in politics are more interested in power than ideas." This should be the preface to every history book. BTW, s/politics/business/ and it is still true. Not to say that politics and business are not interested in ideas... they are, but not fundamentally. Ideas are only a means to power. Understand this and you will understand much about an idea you wish to see implemented.
- jarrett 13y ago> Law is code. Why haven't we fixed this yet? Properly drafted English-language laws do read as code. It's like how you can describe formal logic in English: "All Americans wear hats. I am an American. Therefore I wear a hat." I take it you're arguing for something like Lojban, though. I see two problems there. First, it's not the (de facto) national language, which infringes on one's fundamental right to read the laws of the land. Second, and probably more incurably, these types of languages don't remove the most important kinds of ambiguity in laws. Most disputes over ambiguity in legal text do not arise from syntactic ambiguity. It's not usually confusion over what words the "not" modifies, or which "if" is nested within which. Rather, most problems arise from semantic ambiguity, i.e. the meaning of the individual words. What constitutes a "bank," exactly? What does it mean to do something "in a reasonable period of time?" If you're "bearing" arms, where exactly are you bearing them? You might argue that the problem then comes down to defining your terms well. That's certainly a noble goal when drafting legal text. But one of the principle goals of legal drafting is to make the text flexible enough to apply to specific circumstances that the authors could not have foreseen. This, of course, is in constant tension with the need to be precise. The more precise you are, the easier it is to interpret the law, but the more likely it is that someone will find a loophole arising from the excessive narrowness of your language. A language like Lojban won't alleviate these difficulties, unfortunately.
- echohack 13y ago> First, it's not the (de facto) national language, which infringes on one's fundamental right to read the laws of the land... Legaleese requires you to take years of law classes to even understand, and makes the same problem. I think it's more accessible to run something through a compiler...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- lostlogin 13y agoIt might take years to become a lawyer, but I bet their are more than a few people here who have spotted an error (international or accidental) in a contract that has passed under the eyes if a lawyer or two. My wife and have caught several major errors in our time that could have cost us a lot of money. There is no substitute for a careful reading of a contract, legal training optional.
- jforman 13y agoBecause law is not expressible as code. The phrase, "the right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures" is captured in human language for good reason — it contains embedded values and cultural assumptions that cannot be written objectively.
- dpeck 13y agoThe view that law is code is a common fallacy. In the law there is seldom a right answer, merely answers that can be argued to be more right than others in the given context.
- sigil 13y ago> Further, the diffing format used there is atrocious. Law is code. Why haven't we fixed this yet? You might be interested in this experiment: https://github.com/divegeek/uscode https://github.com/divegeek/uscode (Federal code, not state.)
- doughj3 13y agoJust wanted to also share the link on NY's OpenLegislation[1], an open source project[2]. [1] http://open.nysenate.gov/legislation/bill/A7844A-2013 http://open.nysenate.gov/legislation/bill/A7844A-2013 [2] https://github.com/nysenate/OpenLegislation https://github.com/nysenate/OpenLegislation
- CatMtKing 13y agoSo.. what part of it specifically is anti-Tesla? That is one painful read. I need an abstract or some annotations.
- uptown 13y agoAdditional details about the situation: "Tesla Clashes With Car Dealers" http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424127887324049504578541902814606098.html http://online.wsj.com/article/SB1000142412788732404950457854... or http://bit.ly/16UCd7s http://bit.ly/16UCd7s
- SomeCallMeTim 13y agoWSJ is behind a paywall. :(
- danielweber 13y agoI read it just fine, no special tricks on my part.
- sfall 13y agothey let you read a few a month at no cost
- rgraham 13y agoIncognito window + Google search the text for the article title
- SomeCallMeTim 13y agoThanks for the hint. :)
- CatMtKing 13y agoThanks. That helped me figure out what the bill was about. So basically the status quo is that manufacturers are legally forced to go through franchised car dealers to sell their cars. And this is because Ford used independent car dealers to sell their cars initially; but as time went on and manufacturers wanted to sell directly, these laws were passed to protect existing franchised car dealerships.
- leephillips 13y agoI bet it does get annoying trying to find ways to spin your boss's servitude to a cartel of car dealerships as somehow being for the benefit of the public.
- Shivetya 13y agoThe current arrangement came about as a means to benefit the manufacturers. The carrot was that they in turn would not attempt to circumvent the dealer system. Hence manufactures would produce cars in volume and sell them to the dealers. The dealers who made that investment in buying those cars then sold them for a profit. Dealers are protected by these same laws usually geographically. This in some way insulated the manufacturers from market fluctuations and allowed more efficient factories. Plus you cannot pass up the test drive. Really, would you buy a car without a test drive? Dealers took that job which does incur some risk of loss. It was a good idea at the time. Society was not as integrated as it now, you could not just look up your car in any sense of the word we do now. Just like other franchise setups, they are entrenched and not necessarily bad. Would you rather be beholden to a large auto maker or have a small shop to talk to in the event of a problem? A sole dealership will be more likely want to create a long term relationship and would work to solve you problems, a distant manufacturer who is large could afford to blow you off.
- cobrausn 13y agoNone of your arguments tell me why this kind of relationship should be enforced by law, only why you might want to buy from a dealer and not a manufacturer directly.
- frogpelt 13y agoNot now. But his arguments might tell you why the laws were created in the first place. Protection of consumers like you and me. I honestly I can't see a good reason for labor unions to exist anymore either, but they're still around and have plenty of politicians on their side.
- 13y ago
- echohack 13y agoHow does this bill effect Telsa? Does Telsa have it's own company run franchises in New York or something? I've read the bill (http://assembly.state.ny.us/leg/?default_fld=&bn=A07844&term=2013&Summary=Y&Text=Y http://assembly.state.ny.us/leg/?default_fld=&bn=A07844&term...) several times now, and it only seems to prohibit the franchisor from forcing franchisees from doing certain things. I'm not seeing text in here like, "We hereby force all franchisors to sell cars through franchisees." or "Selling directly to consumers is prohibited." or anything of the sort. I am not a lawyer, perhaps someone more familiar with how selling cars works want to explain?
- muzz 13y agoPlanet Money had a good article on this: http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2013/02/19/172402376/why-buying-a-car-never-changes http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2013/02/19/172402376/why-buyi... Basically dealers have codified protections via the franchise laws(even in places like Texas, North Carolina, etc), and this hinders the direct sale of autos. Not just from Tesla, but also CarsDirect, Costco, etc.
- echohack 13y agoTo help answer my own question, I think I get it, maybe... "The commissioner shall not issue any certificate of registration authorized by this section to any franchisor, MANUFACTURER, DISTRIBUTOR BRANCH OR FACTORY BRANCH..." The rest of bill then talks all about franchisors, and mentions manufacturers very little. So perhaps there's something in here that doesn't allow New York to give registration to manufacturers, and only makes rules for franchisors. Still, this stuff is arcane. It's like reading assembly code.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- revelation 13y agoI think it might be this? The format is terrible. The commissioner shall not issue any certificate of registration authorized by this section to any franchisor, MANUFACTURER, DISTRIBUTOR BRANCH OR FACTORY BRANCH, (caps are additions) I think the way Tesla has been doing business in many states is that they have just applied for dealership licenses.
- larrys 13y agoIs this the way "it's" really supposed to work? Someone everyone "knows" says something and people immediately spring into action on the social media machine. Without considering anything about the situation. Just "it's the old way, we are new, this must be bad" please help us. Pretty soon things like this will become so commonplace they will be ignored (by people or the people being contacted) the same way 10 tornados a day would fail to get the attention of anyone but those directly impacted.
- bconway 13y agoIt would be interesting to hear the other side of the story here.