6 ms·
Continued Funding for Minix (2.5M Euro)
- anigbrowl 18y agoI was going to be snooty about this, but on reflection the existence of Minix is a good thing for mission-critical applications like medical, military or scientific computing (eg satellites). Likely, the performance advantages of Linux's monolithic kernel have been obviated by the advances in hardware performance over the years. The maintainers don't sell themselves very well though. It does give off the flavor of ivory tower academia despite the apparent concrete benefits. Tannenbaum's public comments that he doesn't know who is using Minix (and by implication, doesn't care) isn't a very good advert for it. Do HN readers think there's a demand for apparently-bulletproof *nix, or are other OS offerings already good enough for anything that isn't classified?
- NonEUCitizen 18y agoThere's QNX.
- vorador 18y agoYes, but it's proprietary.
- davidw 18y agoIs Minix actually used for embedded stuff like that? I thought it was mostly used for teaching OS stuff. It does have very clear, easy to read code. I once needed a floppy driver for the eCos operating system, and Minix's was way easier to read than Linux & the BSDs', probably because it doesn't try and do everything for everyone.
- anigbrowl 18y agoI don't know. It just seems like it would be a natural candidate if the claims about the size and fault-tolerance of the kernel are true (as opposed to reinventing the wheel and writing everything from scratch).