8 ms·
Meet the 16 People Responsible for Protecting Your Privacy
- ck2 13y ago"Twelve of the 14 judges who have served this year on the most secret court in America are Republicans and half are former prosecutors." More great coverage from The Atlantic shedding light on all this. I'm going to have to subscribe.
- sigzero 13y agoUh why? Those "facts" really have very little at all to do with it. It's not like if you change them to all Dems that suddenly it changes. It doesn't.
- cobrausn 13y agoThe Atlantic is kinda kidding themselves if they think merely bringing on Democratic judges would make it more 'balanced'. Both parties seem hostile to privacy rights right now (or at least, the primary movers of each party do).
- ck2 13y agoWell they are stating the facts. But if a court for example is all white, male, republicans, you are in danger of "dittoheads" cut from the same cloth. Their names suggest 4 women which is almost acceptable. Cannot guess anything else. The minimal number of requests that are modified by the court has led experts to characterize it as a rubber stamp. For example, Russell Tice, a former National Security Agency analyst said "It is a kangaroo court with a rubber stamp." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FISA_Court#Criticism http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FISA_Court#Criticism One Democrat resigned: On December 16, 2005, the New York Times reported that the Bush administration had been conducting surveillance against US citizens without the knowledge of the court since 2002. On December 20, 2005, Judge James Robertson resigned his position with the court, apparently in protest of the secret surveillance. The government's apparent circumvention of the court started prior to the increase in court-ordered modifications to warrant requests.
- joyeuse6701 13y agoso...we're going to hope they have diverse opinions based on their pigment, sex, and political affiliation? Why is profiling in this case acceptable. Besides, didn't the court rule that these actions taken by government were unconstitutional? Would you have preferred a different outcome?
- ck2 13y agoThe court has only rejected or modified a handful of requests out of tens of thousands. Something is clearly wrong.
- lukeschlather 13y agoThe composition of the court based on pigment, sex, and political affiliation makes it pretty clear that profiling was used to select the court members. The point isn't that they would have diverse opinions otherwise, the point is they were obviously selected to have homogeneous opinions. As if that wasn't bad enough it's obvious that they were selected using ethnic profiling, if not sexism.
- zhemao 13y agoHow on earth could you conclude that? It's a group of 14 people. It isn't terribly unlikely that they weren't chosen solely on race and gender. Not to mention that they're all federal judges, and the federal judiciary isn't well known for its diversity.
- pessimizer 13y ago>the federal judiciary isn't well known for its diversity. Are you arguing that there's not profiling, or at what level the profiling begins?
- zhemao 13y agoWhat exactly do you mean by profiling? Do you mean deliberately choosing a group of people so that they all fit a certain set of demographic criteria? If so, then I am arguing that there is not necessarily profiling going on. Just because a group is skewed demographically doesn't mean there is active profiling going on. There could be unconscious biases or other effects at play. I don't disagree that they were probably chosen to have homogeneous opinions. I do disagree that there is clear evidence of ethnic or gender profiling. I think they just said "we need experienced judges who can be trusted to keep things secret and have strongly favorable views towards law enforcement and intelligence services." It happens that most such people are old, White, Republican men.
- malandrew 13y agoI really really wish we would push for a model of oversight like that the Romans adopted when they appointed ordinary everyday citizens like Cincinnatus appointed as temporary dictator in times of distress [0] This court should have oversight of peers, not career politicians with entrenched interests. [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cincinnatus http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cincinnatus
- wnevets 13y agoif they rubber stamp Obama's request, why does it matter?
- influx 13y agoYeah, if Republican Judges fall in line with a Democratic Executive, how will make it "more diverse" really improve anything?
- ck2 13y agoApparently they have Wikipedia pages http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reggie_Walton http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reggie_Walton https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raymond_J._Dearie https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Raymond_J._Dearie http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rosemary_M._Collyer http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rosemary_M._Collyer http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Claire_Eagan http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Claire_Eagan http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martin_Leach-Cross_Feldman http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martin_Leach-Cross_Feldman http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_F._Hogan http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_F._Hogan http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mary_A._McLaughlin http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mary_A._McLaughlin http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_W._Mosman http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_W._Mosman http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/F._Dennis_Saylor_IV http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/F._Dennis_Saylor_IV http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Susan_Webber_Wright http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Susan_Webber_Wright http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Zagel http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Zagel http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FISA_Court#Criticism http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FISA_Court#Criticism <<<--- apparently they were already known
- richardwhiuk 13y agoThe Wikipedia paragraph on criticism has been added since April - probably as a result of the backlash over PRISM etc.
- brown9-2 13y agoThe fact that the court is "secret" has never meant that it's membership was secret, just that it's output is.
- at-fates-hands 13y agoI have no idea what the purpose of this article is. Exhibit A is the Supreme Court. Many of the judges who were appointed by Republican presidents have turned out to be rather liberal. Look no further than Justice Robert's (appointed by Bush in 2005) ruling on the individual mandate when he sided with the other Liberal judges in upholding its constitutionality.
- pvnick 13y agoI don't give a shit if Ghandi and Martin Luther King Jr. sit on the FISC (FISC court is redundant). America doesn't do secret courts.
- rhizome 13y agoWell...except that it does. :/
- tptacek 13y agoIt doesn't do secret Article III courts. That doesn't mean every review or adjudication process in the government is public. Most of the evidence I can find suggests that FISC isn't an Article III court. It happens to be composed of appointed federal court judges, but that's as close to "Article III-iness" as it gets. Real Article III courts have judges appointed by the executive branch who sit with lifetime tenure. Instead, the word "court" in FISC turns out to be a little misleading. FISC operates more in the manner of a review board. The Constitution doesn't set out limits to foreign intelligence operations, and FISA ostensibly concerns itself exclusively with foreign surveillance operations (and with the checks that prevent foreign surveillance from "mission creeping" into domestic surveillance, which is where things start to get fuzzy). The Constitution does not require NSA to obtain warrants to surveil foreign targets (no country really requires their spies to get warrants), and thus doesn't fundamentally require NSA to get court authorization to do what it does. Instead, FISC is a sort of half-measure intended to allow the Congress to have some ongoing check over what NSA does, by passing laws and providing a body to ensure that those laws are enforced.
- LowKarmaAccount 13y agoAlthough the U.S Supreme Court consists of men and women, whites, blacks, and Latinos, Catholics and Jews, it is also very non-diverse. All nine of the U.S Supreme Court justices attended either Harvard or Yale law school (Ruth Bader Ginsburg transferred from Harvard to Columbia). This means that what were probably the most formative years in the justices' legal careers were all spent at the same institutions.
- gohrt 13y agoIt's a bit of stretch to say that highly intelligent 22-25 year olds were brainwashed by their law schools. They had their lives' formative years before they showed up at law school. Sotomayor has commented quite a bit in that regard.
- tptacek 13y agoFISC judges are appointed by the (Republican) Chief Justice of the Supreme Court from among the federal court judges, among whom Republicans outnumber Democrats something like 100 to 60.
- DanielBMarkham 13y agoI've noticed a particularly troubling trend among my friends who are rabidly partisan. Now that some of these privacy issues are out in the open, there's a desperation to pin it on the other party. Just to be clear: as another commenter said, I don't give a rat's ass if the court consists of the greatest figures in western science. We don't do secret courts. It's a serious mistake trying to turn this into the usual one party versus the other thing. The U.S. got here because of systemic problems; the system itself has been set up in a bad way. The qualities of the people involved -- their party affiliation, their tax return status, whether they like cats or not -- that's all bullshit. And we should call bullshit on folks who try to change the subject in this manner. I'll go even farther. I like the NSA. I think they do a great job, I think they have some of the smartest people working in government right now, and I think the country owes a humongous amount of gratitude towards them. If anything, these guys are my heroes. But that doesn't make the NSA spying right. If you tell the NSA to do fucked up stuff, and you set up a system where they are encouraged and promoted for doing fucked up stuff, you're going to have an agency full of awesome people working as hard as they can to do fucked up stuff. They're not supposed to guide national intelligence gathering -- the policy, structure, and ethics are created by congress and the president -- they're the ones executing it. If we want to fix what's wrong, we're going to need to get our head out of our asses in regards to which team is better than the other and start talking about structural changes that can bring intelligence gathering back in line to where it's supposed to be.
- etherael 13y ago> It's a serious mistake trying to turn this into the usual one party versus the other thing. That depends what you mean by "mistake". Historically speaking, obfuscating the real issues by slinging mud at the other guy and pretending you're enormously different and it's not your problem has proven effective in rallying the proles to fall in line, is it any surprise this would be a continuously attempted tactic in this instance also?
- rosser 13y agoIt's also expedient for cattle ranchers in Brazil to slash-and-burn the Amazon rainforest. Doesn't make it one bit less of a "mistake".
- betterunix 13y agoMeet the FISC court - it has no diversity: 14 of 14 judges are major party. Really, after all that has happened, why are we continuing to pretend that Democrat vs. Republican actually matters here?
- _delirium 13y agoThe judges themselves aren't all members of any particular party. The article is attributing judges to which President appointed them to the bench, and since all Presidents in their lifetime have been Republicans or Democrats, therefore all judges have been appointed by either a Republican or a Democrat.
- will_brown 13y agoI could not help but notice the name of the current presiding Judge John D. Bates not included in the list. This link to the FISC Court rules names Judge Bates on the Cover: http://www.uscourts.gov/uscourts/rules/FISC2010.pdf http://www.uscourts.gov/uscourts/rules/FISC2010.pdf Judge Bates was originally nominated to the bench by GW Bush and obviously appointed to FISC by Chief Justice Roberts. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_D._Bates http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_D._Bates)
- acomar 13y agoAccording to the Wikipedia page, his term expired in February of this year.
- will_brown 13y agoWhere abouts? I am not seeing that. I see Chief Justice Robert's appointed Judge Bates, effective July 1, 2013, Director of the Administrative Offices of the United States Court. However, that occurred June 11, 2013 and presumably he will continue to be the presiding Judge of FISC until that time.
- peterwwillis 13y agoI don't have sources at hand, but I recall reading that these judges only work part time on FISC; they have additional case load to deal with. In addition, law students that work for the judges (a standard practice, from what I understand from a law student) probably go over the material and write their opinions for them, and then they sign it. I don't think it matters to them why the fuck the NSA wants to tap these people, because they've got other shit to do and it's just phone numbers they're looking up. Anyway, why would one party affiliation care more about it than the other? Obama's a dem and he's pretty okay with warrantless wiretapping.
- jstalin 13y agoThe problem is the FISC is not adversarial. In a normal court, these judges are used to dealing with the issues presented to them by both parties. Both parties submit briefs, arguing both sides of the issue, and the judge applies the facts and law to the case based on the issues presented to them by the parties. Judges generally do not inject issues that aren't presented to them by the parties. In contrast, FISC is a one-sided event. Only the government presents its case and asks the judge to make a decision without any opportunity for any other party to make the other side of the argument. So it doesn't surprise me that the judges are just approving what the government asks for. It's similar to a legal default in any other court. When the other party doesn't show up, the party that's standing there wins, no matter what their argument is. It's automatic. EDIT: I should say that this is one of the problems with FISC court, not just the problem. A secret court is antithetical to an open and free society in the first place.
- tptacek 13y agoTo repeat a comment downthread: I think the most deceptive thing about FISC is that it's not really a court. It happens to be staffed with federal court judges, and it can issue binding court orders on a limited set of subject areas, but that's it; in every other way, FISC functions as a form of internal review board. FISC exists because there is no Constitutional anchor to policies regarding foreign intelligence. Foreign powers do not have rights under the Fourth Amendment. No state really requires its spies to get warrants for all their foreign targets. But in the wake of the Nixon administration, Congress decided it needed some way to create and enforce policy for NSA. It can pass laws, but without an ongoing process by which NSA's actions are forced to engage those laws, they'd be toothless. So we get FISC, a sort of para-court.
- Balgair 13y agoHmm, I can't seem to find a way to contact these judges. I'd love to mail them a letter expressing my concerns and to voice my opinions to them. At least to give their clerks a call and try to move towards positions I feel are more in line with American culture. Anyone here got a list of numbers or addresses? Edit: Found contact info for: The Honorable Thomas F. Hogan U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia E. Barrett Prettyman U.S. Courthouse 333 Constitution Avenue, NW Washington, DC 20001 (202) 354-3420 Chambers of Judge Reggie B. Walton's contact information: Telephone Number: 202-354-3290 Fax Number: 202-354-3292 Address: United States District Court for the District of Columbia E. Barrett Prettyman United States Courthouse 333 Constitution Avenue, N.W. Washington, D.C. 20001 Give a call folks!