3 ms·
They make the distinction on their page, too - this is a "next-next-generation" codec, not just a "next-generation" one like VP9 and HEVC. So if this is finali
by mtgx 13y ago
They make the distinction on their page, too - this is a "next-next-generation" codec, not just a "next-generation" one like VP9 and HEVC.
So if this is finalized in 2-3 years, then it will be more of a competitor to VP10. Not sure if MPEG-LA will release another one 2 years from now. They usually release one every 5 years or more, and VP9 managed to catch-up with HEVC after only 2 years of work (work on HEVC started in 2008; work on VP9 in 2011), so we might see VP10 in 2 years that is twice as good as VP9/HEVC, but not an h.266 codec that is twice as good HEVC/h.265.
It will be interesting to see just how good Daala will be. If it's going to be released 2-3 years from now, then it should be at least 3x better than h.264, or at least 4x better to be safe, and to be worth the switch from HEVC/VP9 (and at least as good as VP10, if Google does indeed release VP10 around then, too). That would make 4k video as efficient as 1080p video with h.264 (file size/bandwidth-wise).
- anon1385 13y ago>not just a "next-generation" one like VP9 and HEVC. VP9 is not the same generation as HEVC. It's more comparable with H.264. >VP9 managed to catch-up with HEVC after only 2 years of work Do you mean in terms of how far along with standardisation/development they are? VP9 is ~6 months behind, although that's not really that significant in video standard timescales. If you mean quality then VP9 encoders have not caught up with x264, and that in itself may take years, if they ever do. We were promised that VP8 would get a lot better over time, but it didn't because they basically gave up and concentrated on VP9. If they do the same again and start looking to VP10 then VP9 will flounder. Video codecs can't gain adoption with such short churn times. The reason there was so little time between VP8 and VP9 is that VP8 was technically so far behind it never had any chance of adoption. MPEG-LA are not going to release a new codec in 2 years time. HEVC will probably only just be seeing mature implementations and widespread adoption by then. There is still a hell of a lot of MPEG-2 tech out there and H.264 has been out for a decade.
- ZeroGravitas 13y ago"Next-gen", as it is in consoles, is derived from the traditional business models where things go in 5-10 year cycles based around fixed hardware that falls in cost over time. Your new PC isn't called next-gen, even if it's much more powerful than your old console. And even if you look at the longer timescales of PC, it's hard/subjective to choose a line in the sand for one "generation" to transition to the next. So I don't think VP9 is, wants to be, or needs to be "next-gen" by that kind of definition. Having said that, it's a sufficiently "next-gen" bitstream (basically it assumes you have a certain amount of hardware oomph available) that its visual output can be better than x264 already in most ordinary videos, even with an encoder that could be described as "worse" in many ways. x264 may be a better fighter "pound for pound" but it's clearly in a different weight class.
- 0x09 13y ago> Not sure if MPEG-LA will release another one 2 years from now. MPEG-LA aren't compression engineers or a standards body. They're a law firm in Colorado. The LA stands for "Licensing Authority." Thanks to the blog roll half the internet can't distinguish between it and ISO WG-11, but it's not a trifling distinction.