4 ms·
The preponderance of evidence is that net caloric balance predicts weight. http://examine.com/faq/what-should-i-eat-for-weight-loss.html http://examine.com/faq
by jacques_chester 13y ago
The preponderance of evidence is that net caloric balance predicts weight.
http://examine.com/faq/what-should-i-eat-for-weight-loss.html http://examine.com/faq/what-should-i-eat-for-weight-loss.htm...
Given the choice between "astonishing phenomenon never before detected in history" and "record-keeping errors", I know which horse Occam is telling me to bet on. And it's not that HFCS has more Higgs bosons.
- schoper 13y agoTrue. But what causes the overeating?
- jacques_chester 13y agoCheap, tasty food.
- schoper 13y agoSure, that could be possible. However there are some issues: 1) Obesity isn't a disease of the rich. So the "cheapness" doesn't seem to be an obvious factor. This is in contrast to the 1600s and 1700s when obesity and gout were diseases of the rich in Europe. 2) In poor areas, especially the third world, we are starting to see a pattern obese mothers and malnourished children. This is bizarre. The usual pattern is to see malnourished mothers and malnourished children. 3) We can simulate the syndrome with insulin injections, which seems to suggest at least one hormonal pathway driving overeating (rather than simple psychology). 4) Women get fat after menopause (hence the estrogen supplementation industry, which turned out to be giving them cancer). Everybody starts to put on pounds at middle age. Kids seem to start eating a lot at puberty, but generally grow up rather than around. It seems like the whole system is much more complicated than "cheap, tasty food."
- jacques_chester 13y agoI know what you're saying, but consider the counterfactual (ie, almost all history to this point). In the absence of cheap, tasty food, obesity is rare. When cheap, tasty food is abundant, so too are overweight and obesity. On a population level it looks very much like cheap, tasty food is both necessary and sufficient. Without an increase in per-capita calories, there can't be an increase in population BMI. The reason we call all these other phenomena strange is because we've never had tens of millions of overweight and obese subjects before. Sample sizes of tens of millions throw up new and interesting outliers. It's only going to get weirder.
- mietek 13y agoHave you actually looked at the studies cited, and checked the fat—protein—carbohydrate ratios used? For example, this 2009 study used the following ratios to conclude "low-carb" diets aren't better than regular reduced-calorie diets: 20%—15%—65% 20%—25%—55% 40%—15%—45% 40%—25%—35% http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19246357 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19246357 None of these are actually low-carb. The recommended ketogenic ratio is: 60%—35%—5% Try Peter Attia's Eating Academy for some highly informative reading: http://eatingacademy.com http://eatingacademy.com
- jacques_chester 13y agoYou've missed the point, which is that body mass is directly predicted by total calories and is not statistically distinguished regardless of macronutrient composition. There are multiple studies listed, you just picked one. Review articles come to the same conclusion: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15351198 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15351198
- mietek 13y ago> http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15351198 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15351198 I don't think this citation supports your point of view.
- jacques_chester 13y ago> A systematic review of low-carbohydrate diets found that the weight loss achieved is associated with the duration of the diet and restriction of energy intake, but not with restriction of carbohydrates. Put another way: ketogenesis isn't a magic escape hatch from physics. If you eat foods rich in protein, you are satieted sooner and total calories consumed falls. Total calories consumed falls. That's what causes the weight loss. Not a particular hormonal-metabolic configuration.
- mietek 13y agoSo, you're saying that it's actually easier to lose weight with a low-carb diet? Well, then, glad we agree. As for the "calorie is a calorie" point of view, I recommend reading the following: http://eatingacademy.com/nutrition/do-calories-matter http://eatingacademy.com/nutrition/do-calories-matter
- glenra 13y agoWhat, exactly, are you calling an "astonishing phenomenon never before detected in history"? Are you saying that chickens and monkeys got fatter over time due to "record-keeping errors"? Are you claiming the "fat virus" effect - that if you give chickens or monkeys or rats or mice a certain human cold viruse, they get fatter - is due to "record-keeping errors"? Have you read anything of Gary Taubes? He argues that the phenomenon of some local culture getting unusually fat in spite of the usual suspects not being present, is something that has been seen a great many times in history...but has been ignored or misinterpreted until recently. > The preponderance of evidence is that net caloric balance predicts weight. An equally valid way to put that is "the preponderance of evidence is that weight predicts net caloric balance." You can't derive the direction of causality from that relationship.
- jacques_chester 13y ago> Are you saying that chickens and monkeys got fatter over time due to "record-keeping errors"? Depending on the margin of error, yes. > Are you claiming the "fat virus" effect - that if you give chickens or monkeys or rats or mice a certain human cold viruse, they get fatter - is due to "record-keeping errors"? I'm claiming that getting fatter is completely explained by net caloric balance. Insofar as a virus depresses metabolism, it is still explained by net caloric balance. Insofar as a virus increase appetite, it is still explained by net caloric balance. Insofar as measurement fails to be adjusted for either scenario, it's a record-keeping error. > He argues that the phenomenon of some local culture getting unusually fat in spite of the usual suspects not being present, is something that has been seen a great many times in history...but has been ignored or misinterpreted until recently. Anthropology is not a substitute for metabolic ward studies and controlled-diet studies and medical fasting studies and twin studies. All of these find that caloric balance has predictive power, modulo noise and measurement error. If energy or matter is being destroyed by viruses, there would be detectable evidence. Lethal amounts of radiation, for example. > You can't derive the direction of causality from that relationship. Given that changing caloric balance temporally precedes changes in body mass and body fat, and that the outcomes can be predicted to within a few percent in controlled conditions, and that the mechanisms of lipogenesis and lipolysis are well studied, yes. I believe that I can deduce just such a causal system.