5 ms·
> The cost of postage and the check along with all the processing costs are covered from the money generated from sales of valuable crap. Remember: one man’s cr
by pavel_lishin 13y ago
> The cost of postage and the check along with all the processing costs are covered from the money generated from sales of valuable crap. Remember: one man’s crap is another man’s treasure.
And yet, Goodwill doesn't hand out $10 checks for every donation.
I suspect that the money earned from selling "another man's treasure" will rapidly decline.
At first, you'll have the type of people we imagine other HN readers sending things in - nice books, perhaps art, a few desktop toys and things like that. But after a few months, you'll start receiving things that I'd send in - desk lamps that are 99% functional, but don't quite bend in the angle that you want. Paperbacks that have been dropped into a puddle one too many times. An old thermos.
- roc 13y ago> "I suspect that the money earned from selling "another man's treasure" will rapidly decline." That was my first thought: "people can fill boxes with crap worth less than ten dollars longer than you can cut checks for $10."
- gohrt 13y agoYou can write off Goodwill donations for tax deductions
- pavel_lishin 13y agoSure, but that's not Goodwill giving you straight cash - the point being that any given box typically does not contain $10+ worth of stuff.
- digz 13y agoNo, it's the government (or more specifically, taxpayers [today's or tomorrow's]) giving straight cash. It's also the only reason Goodwill exists.
- anigbrowl 13y agothings that I'd send in - desk lamps that are 99% functional, but don't quite bend in the angle that you want. Paperbacks that have been dropped into a puddle one too many times. An old thermos. I find this strangely endearing.
- pavel_lishin 13y agoKill that feeling. Kill it with fire, bury it under a rock, then pave the whole area with three feet of concrete. I feel that feeling with every fucking object in my apartment, and if it weren't for my friends and my wife, I'd probably be one of those hoarders, sleeping in a 3x3 foot area surrounded by garbage. I wish I could find a photo of my room as a teenager. I wasn't a Collyer, but you couldn't see my floor.
- Dove 13y agoI used to work at a thrift store. The amount of value we could extract from the average box of stuff dropped off to donate . . . was nowhere near $10. In fact, a lot of it couldn't be sold at all -- it just got thrown away. Broken toys, clothes with holes, dirty shoes, smoke-damaged, water-damaged, and just plain damaged stuff. Ugly nick-nacks, beat up plastic cups, dated books no one wants to read. We got so many tins and baskets! Everyone gets them full of cookies or gifts, no one wants to throw them away, and no one actually has a use for them. My co-worker and I did the master sorting -- sending stuff to different departments or to the trash. I saw it all. Her summary? "People send us their garbage!" And that's the stuff that people could be bothered to drive to the store, look a person in the eye, and drop off without too much embarrassment. This was stuff they genuinely thought was valuable. A box you can fill with crap from your garage? Well. Paying $1 for that sight unseen is probably too much. $10 plus postage is . . . endearingly naive.
- akristofcak 13y agoThis is really helpful perspective, thank you! (the author)
- mst 13y agoThis does, however, make me wonder if there's a way to (ab)use the charitable deductions system to make it a zero cost thing. Spun right, I can see a lot of people (myself included) find donating it for free to be a more satisfying idea than paying to throw it away, provided it's a minimally irritating process (remember that in both cases you're competing against "put off throwing it out for another month/year"). As a good example, some friends of mine who work in a networking team will turn up with a land rover and collect whatever pile of old computer equipment you have; they aggregate it and sell it to scrap merchants and the proceeds go towards drinks at their office christmas party. Their management have concluded the fuel costs are less than the recovered beer costs, and I know I can reliably get rid of old tech I don't need and even if it doesn't go to a charity as such it's going to buy beer for people I know and like. The point here is that making it almost entirely free of effort on my part, plus at least the illusion that the money raised is going for something I consider to be of at least marginally more than zero value, makes it a proposition I'm quite happy to work with. Or: Find a way to make people feel at least a little good about making as little effort as possible; the marginal value of a slight good feeling to me is far more than $10 especially if the $10 requires more effort to get.
- squidi 13y agoI give to my local thrift shop (or charity shop as we call them in the UK) and their average bag value is £25 ($39) [1]. That probably includes the 25% extra they can reclaim through tax breaks. [1] http://support.cancerresearchuk.org/support-us/donate/donate-goods http://support.cancerresearchuk.org/support-us/donate/donate...