4 ms·
I've lived and worked in Australia and Canada for many years. In Australia, everyone gets sufficient basic care from taxes, and if you want, you can buy extend
by grecy 13y ago
I've lived and worked in Australia and Canada for many years.
In Australia, everyone gets sufficient basic care from taxes, and if you want, you can buy extended care. It has nothing to do with your employer.
In Canada, everyone gets very basic care from taxes, and if you want, you can buy extended care, or your employer might do that for you (implied: If you're lucky).
After living and working under both systems, I find giving my employer power over my healthcare to be a nasty draconian measure that I don't like at all, and I see no benefits.
- run4yourlives 13y agoDisclaimer: I work in the health insurance industry in Canada, for a Third Party Provider. Canada and Australia are basically the same, but in Canada there is a default understanding that most employers will help to sponsor an extended health/insurance plan. I see no real issue with this, as it certainly does NOT mean they in any way control your options. As healthcare becomes increasingly expensive, the ability for employers to offer this benefit is degraded. None of that prevents you from doing what you want in terms of extra coverage though. Most full time jobs that are also considered "careers" will offer some form of insurance benefits, and that usually includes health care. Aside from cost, the benefits of Group Insurance is that there are no pre-existing condition exceptions. You have guaranteed acceptance as a nature of your employment. This is a huge upside for people that aren't prefect medical specimens, and as a result employer offered extended coverage is significantly cheaper for the individual. As I said you are starting to see changes mainly due to demographics and cost increases. The switch to Flex benefits, health spending accounts and such will see more "individualization" of health care costs in the future. Personally, I think HSA's are the best possible way to offer extended health benefits to employees, and I expect they will grow in popularity; analogous to what RRSP's have done to pension plans. I find giving my employer power over my healthcare You simply don't do this in Canada, although many people do have that impression. Example: Me. I have my government health care, my employer health care that I pay a portion of, and some extra private care that I elect to pay for.
- grecy 13y agoI think you and I have discussed this before on HN. >I see no real issue with this, as it certainly does NOT mean they in any way control your options. Of course it does. In Canada I'm looking at moving jobs right now, and one of the things I'm weighing up is the health benefits now vs. the new position. I also would love to take 2 years off work to pursue my photography and writing passions, but I worry what I'll do without my company paying my my group plan. My options are without question controlled by my employer. In Australia, that is not so. > Aside from cost, the benefits of Group Insurance is that there are no pre-existing condition exceptions. You have guaranteed acceptance as a nature of your employment. If the care provided by my taxes was sufficient (as it is in Australia) there would be no pre-existing condition exceptions. In Australia, you have guaranteed acceptance as a nature of being born. > and as a result employer offered extended coverage is significantly cheaper for the individual. You've been tricked into thinking group plans are cheaper... if the government was buying a group plan for everyone, it would be drastically cheaper again. > Personally, I think HSA's are the best possible way to offer extended health benefits to employees Why do health benefits need to be offered to employees? Why only offer them to a subset of the population, that is, those with jobs? Surely it's better to offer them to everyone.
- run4yourlives 13y agoMy options are without question controlled by my employer. Eh? Google search "Private Insurance Canada" and tell me how your healthcare is "controlled" by your employer. This is like suggesting your employer "controls" how you can use your car because they offer you free parking. >If the care provided by my taxes was sufficient How is Canada's healthcare not sufficient, exactly? >You've been tricked into thinking group plans are cheaper.. Erm, remember that part where I said I was in the industry? Yeah, I know they are on the average cheaper. Plans vary though, of course, but pooling is a significant part of insurance. In 99% of cases, a pool of white collar office workers performs better than a pool of everyone. >Why do health benefits need to be offered to employees? They don't. That's why they call them benefits. >Why only offer them to a subset of the population We don't. Canada has universal health care and extended insurance is available for everyone that wants to pay for it. >Surely it's better to offer them to everyone. They are. The idea that every possible health problem and treatment that one can conceive of should be offered to everyone for free is about as dumb as saying someone should pay for everything themselves. Extended benefits are for services that we've already determined are "extras" to basic, guaranteed health care. I'm not sure you have a strong understanding of the purpose of our system to be honest.