4 ms·
In what sense are the poor poor? (Louis XIV didn't have a single TV. Poor people in the US typically have two.) Income seems to be a fairly bad way to measur
by anamax 18y ago
In what sense are the poor poor? (Louis XIV didn't have a single TV. Poor people in the US typically have two.) Income seems to be a fairly bad way to measure poverty.
Note that income is an especially bad measure if they didn't account for non-taxable sources of stuff, as is typically the case in such studies. Since those sources provide a huge fraction of the "support" for poor people, failing to account for it makes the results highly suspect. Moreover, since it is well known that non-taxable sources are significant, failing to account for them ....
- AlisdairO 18y agoI'd imagine that the poor are poor relative to the rich. Individual's happiness with their economic position tends to be based to a significant extent on what they are earning relative to other people.
- anamax 18y agoSome people feel ugly compared to others. Should we do something about that too?
- AlisdairO 18y agoThe disparity between rich and poor is something that society actively decides upon, and society would be well advised to take into account the ramifications of its decision. Part of that information being that the absolute value of an individual's wealth is far from the only important factor - relative values are important to. Humans judge their wealth relative to other people. To look at it in a nice, emotive context, which society do you suppose is happier: the one where the cure for all cancers exists, but is so labour intensive that only the rich can afford it, or the society where the cure does not exist at all, and all are in the same boat? I'd caution you not to underestimate the pain of knowing that your loved one could be saved, if only you had a bit more money. Whether someone is ugly or not is not really something that society makes an active choice about at the moment - I'm not sure it's relevant. NB: No, I am not a commie, and I am in full favour of some income disparity as a motivator towards useful output. I just find the assertion that it doesn't matter if the rich have an ever-increasing share of the pie as long as the pie keeps growing a touch disingenuous. edit: formatting
- anamax 18y ago> To look at it in a nice, emotive context, which society do you suppose is happier: the one where the cure for all cancers exists, but is so labour intensive that only the rich can afford it, or the society where the cure does not exist at all, and all are in the same boat? I'd caution you not to underestimate the pain of knowing that your loved one could be saved, if only you had a bit more money. Spare me the sanctimony. Now lets look at it in a realistic context. The society where rich people can afford something today is a society where poor people said something tomorrow. You're arguing that folks should die "forever" in order to spare the feelings of people who died "unnecessarily" during a "while". Do you really believe that people saved later are worth so little? > I just find the assertion that it doesn't matter if the rich have an ever-increasing share of the pie as long as the pie keeps growing a touch disingenuous. Oh really? You find what I say to be "lacking in frankness, candor, or sincerity; falsely or hypocritically ingenuous; insincere"? On what basis? It's not that the pie keeps growing. It's that the amount of pie that the poor get keeps growing.
- AlisdairO 18y ago> Now lets look at it in a realistic context. The society where rich people can afford something today is a society where poor people said something tomorrow. And where there will be another thing (of some critical importance) that the poor cannot afford tomorrow that the rich can. > You're arguing that folks should die "forever" in order to spare the feelings of people who died "unnecessarily" during a "while". Do you really believe that people saved later are worth so little? No, I'm arguing that a society where progress is slightly slower (i.e the pie grows more slowly), but has lesser income disparity will probably be happier than one with massive income disparity and faster overall progress. I'm not saying it's 'right' or 'wrong', but I am saying that this is a fact. Happier societies generally have lower income disparities than those displayed in the US, and really, what else do you need to justify it? > Oh really? You find what I say to be "lacking in frankness, candor, or sincerity; falsely or hypocritically ingenuous; insincere"? On what basis? Because I think when people say it that their motivation is not accuracy, it's just an excuse to justify not caring about the poorer segment of society - a way to ignore the fact that although the absolute amount of pie they get has increased, there's still a problem.