6 ms·
I'm sorry what? F*ck privacy, this way is more expedient? Is that what you're saying in effect? That's not what I want from my government. --edit-- I also did
by Nursie 13y ago
I'm sorry what? F*ck privacy, this way is more expedient? Is that what you're saying in effect?
That's not what I want from my government.
--edit-- I also didn't make any suggestions, I would have accepted a reasonable explanation of the legal and technological measures that were in place to protect my data from rampant proliferation through US corporate and government systems.
Instead I got (and this is a direct quote) "We don't allow Google to use or share our analytics data.", and a zendesk reference number. Fobbed off, basically.
And with the zendesk link, now my actual communication with a UK government team is being processed in the bay area.
This is unacceptable.
--edit 2-- Somehow other large UK web-based institutions manage without GA as well. The BBC for instance. Perhaps they could talk to each other.
- mbesto 13y agoThis is unacceptable. Before you start the lynch mob, ask yourself this: what on earth can one do with non-person-identifiable data stored on a server? "Next on BBC - Terrorist organisation finds out too many British people forget to update their MOTs" That's not what I want from my government. Be very very fortunate you can even get a somewhat usable site, much less a very user friendly site. There are citizens of the other nations that would kill for easier access to public information.
- Nursie 13y ago>> Before you start the lynch mob, ask yourself this: what on earth can one do with non-person-identifiable data stored on a server? How do we know it's non-person-identifiable? It's certainly clear that the analytics data comes from a set IP address, and when correlated with all the other data that big G collect from all over the web, who knows what can come out of it. >> Be very very fortunate you can even get a somewhat usable site, much less a very user friendly site. 1. It's not just an information site. 2. Why should Google (and by extension the US government) be informed that I'm looking up (for instance) legal advice, business law or anything else? Again, this is my interactions with my government being published to another nation. --edit-- removed accusations of laziness, I'm sure the gov.uk folks aren't that.
- lifeisstillgood 13y agoWhy should one part of the UK government be informed about your interactions with another part? We have no framework for digital privacy, and until we see an emergent consensus there will not be one. Here, on this site, we have informed, reasonable people disagree on fundamental definitions of online privacy. I am unsure where to begin.
- Nursie 13y agoRight, so because we haven't got a full and complete legal framework and associated consensus driven moral framework in this area, we should just relax and give up on the whole idea? We already have data protection frameworks in the UK and at the EU level. I would like to see them adhered to in spirit, and I would also like to know that someone involved in the gov.uk has at least given this a moment's thought.
- lifeisstillgood 13y agoClearly not give up. But we should have at least a clear idea of where we want the debate to go to. You say you want the DPA adhered to in spirit - great. It is adhered to in the letter of the law, and there are many interpretations of the spirit of that law. My view is that the spirit of the law needs to be codified for a new world, and it is healthier to have that clear (and so open for debate) than to say someone is violating my idea of what the law should be., My starter for 10: * Privacy is merely a politeness, and does not actually "exist". The expectations of privacy are the expectation for data to not be exploited without our consent. * All digital communications and associated metadata are made in a public domain, and should have very limited expectations of privacy. * If digital communication is encrypted, or marked as anonymous, then it should be legally viewed as having an expectatin of privacy and similar penalties applied for interfering with that as with post. * Any monitoring of digital activity that can be linked to an individual human must be publically acknowledged by the monitoring organisation and the data released / published unless the individual has given consent for identifying data to be stored and processed to that organisation. Its a thought in progress.
- sp332 13y agoOf course it's personally identifiable. AOL https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AOL_search_data_leak https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AOL_search_data_leak and more recently Netflix http://www.cs.utexas.edu/~shmat/shmat_oak08netflix.pdf http://www.cs.utexas.edu/~shmat/shmat_oak08netflix.pdf tried to anonymize datasets and failed. With a website, you can geo-locate the IP, cross-reference with timestamps, and probably ID more than half the users. Someone tested how hard it is: http://web.mit.edu/newsoffice/2013/de-anonymize-cellphone-data-0327.html http://web.mit.edu/newsoffice/2013/de-anonymize-cellphone-da... With 4 location datapoints + timestamps, you can differentiate 95% of people.
- mbesto 13y agoBut if they identify that "Jim English" has visited the MOT description website 10 times in the last month...so what? Google analytics for a publicly facing government website is akin to someone watching you walk physically into a public municipality.
- Nursie 13y agoSomeone in another country, not subject to the same laws about how that sort of data is collected and used. Actually it's not even equivalent then. It's more like them recording the conversation you have with the public services folk. And you haven't actually gone there, just called on the phone.
- mbesto 13y agorecording the conversation This is where I'm really failing to understand your logic. Your activity is very different from what you converse. If I fill out a web form and that data gets logged, fine, I can see how privacy may be an issue. Unless someone can correct me, Google analytics does not have that capability, it only tracks how you navigate. If I walk around a public library and check out 6 books and someone follows me around watching me look at 6 books, then again I ask "so what?"
- 13y ago
- lifeisstillgood 13y agoWhich part is unacceptable - the fobbing off part, or the some data gets sent to a country that tortures people, spies on all its citizens indiscriminately and has not signed up to common international treaties. I think that before Snowden most people, myself included, would have thought not using google analytics for the above reasons was paranoia. Now, I think that all digital data should be treated as public and until we change the law to have a public / private demarcation, we need to accept it and deal. (I see this as a pollution issue, until we get a clean air act, everyone will walk around with cloths across their mouths) edit: little less troll like: We have no framework for digital privacy, and until we see an emergent consensus there will not be one. Here, on this site, we have informed, reasonable people disagree on fundamental definitions of online privacy. So the first step here is to ask, "privacy in the US is based on two things, actions in ones own home are protected by default, and written communications between yourself and others are protected, and publishing is an explicit act" What do those things now mean in a world of mobile phones, internet and metadata?
- Nursie 13y ago>> Which part is unacceptable Pretending it's a non-issue and not addressing concerns AND then using an overseas helpdesk service, such that now not only are analytics being sent to the US, but actual communication between a UK citizen and the UK government. But particularly the latter half. >> I think that before Snowden most people, myself included, would have thought not using google analytics for the above reasons was paranoia. Most people haven't been paying much attention then. >>Now, I think that all digital data should be treated as public and until we change the law to have a public / private demarcation, we need to accept it and deal. Cool, if that's your attitude to this. Some of us would prefer to prevent our government being complicit wherever possible. They may already be in breech of various regulations and I do intend to be in contact with the ICO soon.
- hnriot 13y agoThis just sounds like a paranoid rant. If you have a problem with it, either don't visit the site or block the analytics. The reason they are using it is pretty obvious, like everyone else that builds digital services, they want to look at how it gets used. It is a non issue, that's not pretending, it's just putting on a rational hat and taking off the silly rhetoric of paranoia. Personally, as someone who left the UK in the 90's for silicon valley, I'm blown away that the UK government has even heard of the internet, let alone built a decent digital service.
- saraid216 13y agoNo, what they're saying is, "How much more in taxes do you want to pay to get them to stop using Google Analytics?"
- Nursie 13y agoAnd the answer is "some". As a proportion of the whole development cost, using either an EU based analytics service or in-house server shouldn't really be significant. But even before that I'd like to have some indication that someone has actually thought about what they're doing, rather than just stuffed in GA because that's what you do in the private sector.