2 ms·
You're assuming I'm making a claim that I'm not. And if anything, you have it completely backwards. IF the claim were a simple "Google is complicit with the N
by mindcrime 13y ago
You're assuming I'm making a claim that I'm not. And if anything, you have it completely backwards. IF the claim were a simple "Google is complicit with the NSA", then one could say that the available evidence weighs in favor of that claim. IF Google want to make a claim "we are not in bed with the NSA" the burden of proof IS on Google to prove that "we are not in bed with the NSA", especially in light of evidence which strongly suggests that they are.
It's a moot point though, as the only claims I'm making are:
A. I don't trust Google (and Yahoo, etc.). That doesn't need any proof, as it's simply a statement of my position.
B. There is probably something more to the NSA/Google/Yahoo/MS/Apple relationship than what Google/Yahoo/Apple/MS are publicly saying. There is evidence (the PRISM slides) to directly support this.
I'm not making any more specific claim (eg "Google have a secret server that the NSA ssh into and do direct queries on Google's database" or something) because, quite simply, I don't know. And without the rest of the PRISM slides, or the other Snowden docs, or some other input, we'll probably never know. But I've seen enough to not trust Google/Yahoo/Apple/MS/etc. completely.
- res0nat0r 13y agoPowerpoint slides of unverified origin I don't think quite meets the burden of proof that Google is complicit or even involved in anything. They are just that: Powerpoint slides.
- mindcrime 13y agoMy understanding is that the origin is verified. I don't have the citation handy, but I believe that reporters from the WaPo contacted the NSA before the story ran, and verified that the slides are - at least - authentic. Granted, there's a lot we don't know about them, but I haven't seen any reason to believe that they aren't exactly what they seem to be.