4 ms·
If anyone from gov.uk is reading this, do you fancy answering the question I posed when the site was launched but never received an adequate answer to? Why doe
by Nursie 13y ago
If anyone from gov.uk is reading this, do you fancy answering the question I posed when the site was launched but never received an adequate answer to?
Why does gov.uk, a site all about allowing the British public to interact with the British government, use google analytics?
You are shipping all the data about all my interactions with my government off to a third party in another country. Another country that we know has not got the same legal data protection requirements, and one which has now been exposed as having massive internal spying problems.
And no, telling me "google aren't allowed to use the data" and then opening an outsourced helpdesk ticket with another US based company does not cut it.
- jpswade 13y agoThis extends well beyond boundaries and governments. Google Analytics has become an industry standard.
- Nursie 13y agoYes it has, and the sharing of site-visitor data with google on sites all over the web is something to be concerned about IMHO. However, again IMHO, tracking casual web use is a different class of data to my interactions with my government, and I very much resent those being sent to foreign companies and (by inference) foreign powers, however benign and friendly our relationship is.
- jpswade 13y agoLet's not forget. Google is an international company, not "foreign". Google has servers and offices in the UK. If you read the first point, it says "Start with needs". They need to be relevant and appear in Google. Google Analytics is simply a tool that helps them do that.
- Nursie 13y ago>> Let's not forget. Google is an international company, not "foreign". No, it's an American company, subject to the whims of the US government. >> Google has servers and offices in the UK. Sure does. I have no idea where they process the data though and I doubt the gov.uk folks have. If they did have a guarantee that the data wasn't ever going to leave the UK then maybe they could say so? >> If you read the first point, it says "Start with needs". They need to be relevant and appear in Google. Google Analytics is simply a tool that helps them do that. Err, no, google analytics records and transmits site interaction data.
- _mulder_ 13y agoUnfortunately it's attitudes like this that usually end up making Government projects so eye-wateringly expensive. Assuming they listen to your suggestion and act on it as you suggest, it seems the only option open to them is to design their own in-house (In UK for that matter) version of Google Analytics to do their own analysis. Regardless of the cost and time this would add to the project, it's unlikely that it would be anywhere as good as Google's offering. The other, more likely, option would be to decide it's too expensive to implement a different, more complicated, solution; so they don't bother. They don't get the feedback and analysis on how to improve their services and the customer experience declines until you're back where you started with a poorly designed product offering hard-to-find information and people are posting angry comments on HackerNews about how bad gov.uk is and how they would never run a start-up like that... I'm almost certain someone would say "Why don't they use google analytics to improve things, like everyone else". Instead, we need to be applauding a massive operation like Gov.uk for taking a dose of reality and thinking, "we're not doing anything amazingly special here, we're providing people with a quick way to check their council tax, or bin collection dates, or maybe pay their car tax. let's just get the job done as best we can."
- Samuel_Michon 13y ago> the only option open to them is to design their own in-house (In UK for that matter) version of Google Analytics to do their own analysis. They could just install Mint on their own servers. Problem solved. http://www.haveamint.com/ http://www.haveamint.com/
- Nursie 13y agoI'm sorry what? F*ck privacy, this way is more expedient? Is that what you're saying in effect? That's not what I want from my government. --edit-- I also didn't make any suggestions, I would have accepted a reasonable explanation of the legal and technological measures that were in place to protect my data from rampant proliferation through US corporate and government systems. Instead I got (and this is a direct quote) "We don't allow Google to use or share our analytics data.", and a zendesk reference number. Fobbed off, basically. And with the zendesk link, now my actual communication with a UK government team is being processed in the bay area. This is unacceptable. --edit 2-- Somehow other large UK web-based institutions manage without GA as well. The BBC for instance. Perhaps they could talk to each other.
- tombrossman 13y agoIt is for these same reasons that I contacted Crimestoppers UK and asked them about their use of Google Analytics, especially on a site that is for 'anonymous' crime reporting. They wrote back with a non-answer missing the point that they are voluntarily leaking crime victims' metadata to a US advertising company. A site the size of gov.uk or crimestoppers.org.uk really cannot claim that they don't know how to switch to something like Piwik and keep the visitor data in-house and private.
- matthewcford 13y agogov.uk uses _anonymizeIp[1] so you do get some privacy there. [1] https://developers.google.com/analytics/devguides/collection/gajs/methods/gaJSApi_gat#_gat._anonymizeIp https://developers.google.com/analytics/devguides/collection...
- Nursie 13y agoMy only issue with that is that you have to trust google to do it. The info is still transmitted (even if only in the form of the initial request to download ga.js) so we only have their word on the matter.
- chestnut-tree 13y ago"Why does gov.uk, a site all about allowing the British public to interact with the British government, use google analytics?" I'd like an answer to this too from the .gov.uk team. Ironically enough, their service design manual (which is excelllent and a fantastic resource) has a very good section on analytics tools [1]. Some quotes: "When deciding which analytics tool is most appropriate for your service, you should consider the following...who owns the data (it should be your organisation!) Does the solution meet the EU privacy directive and the European Commission’s Directive on Data Protection? - where is collected data held? - do data centres meet EU/British data security standards? - how long is data held for? - what will happen to the data on termination of the contract- can you export it? - what access your vendors employees have to your data" Did they evaluate Google Analytics based on these guidelines? [1]https://www.gov.uk/service-manual/making-software/analytics-tools.html https://www.gov.uk/service-manual/making-software/analytics-... The full list of topics in the service design manual https://www.gov.uk/service-manual/browse https://www.gov.uk/service-manual/browse
- lifeisstillgood 13y agoTo be quite honest, a month ago any of use would have said yes to all those for google analytics
- Nursie 13y agoHave you performed or read an analysis of this as it applies to GA then? I'd love to read it.