3 ms·
At this point, it seems more plausible to me that Google is telling the truth here and the Prism slides are either inaccurate or refer to DPI reconstruction or
by rdl 13y ago
At this point, it seems more plausible to me that Google is telling the truth here and the Prism slides are either inaccurate or refer to DPI reconstruction or just a live hosting/presentation environment for conventionally-delivered dossiers. I can't see Google intentionally making statements which are both incorrect and falsifiable to this degree, especially since it looks like more leaks are coming, or actual official declassifications.
There is absolutely some horrible shit going down -- backbone sniffing and DPI, mass telephone metadata (and either OTA or carrier-delivered copies of content for "interesting" numbers and maybe areas), etc. And, there are serious future trust issues with cloud computing. But, at this time, I don't think NSA has pervasive access at Google -- I'm sure they (and the Chinese, Israel, and others) have Google staff who they know are likely to be "friendly" if they actually did need to do something (much much more applicable to non-US agencies), but even that doesn't need to be formalized until used.
Because NSA has so many other tools (legal and technical) to use, I don't think they do high-odds-of-being-detected stuff, certainly not on a widespread basis. Active MITM of connections, or really intrusive requests to companies, seems unlikely.
This is not the case for China, Israel, etc., so they are far far more likely to use external or internal attacks (other than legal) to get data from companies. And, guess what -- look at the news or your own networks -- lots of attacks from China, some quite sophisticated and successful.
I'd actually say there are higher odds of a given Google SRE being purely commercially evil and selling access to crime organizations than that NSA is doing this actively against Google.
This all means the threat is every bit as real as if NSA were doing it pervasively if you're likely to be a target. I don't think we ever thought NSA was using its pervasive monitoring for anything other than ultimately going after some specific targets, not for general law enforcement risk, so the situation is no different either way -- you can mostly trust Google if you blend in, but can't if you're "interesting".
Against some kind of pervasive secret program involving many people: The odds of a single Googler on any team being a "whistleblower" are far higher than the odds at NSA, and we've had a lot of espionage leaks over the years, plus actual leakers.
Occam's razor is that Google is telling the truth here.
- throwaway10001 13y agoAgainst some kind of pervasive secret program involving many people: The odds of a single Googler on any team being a "whistleblower" are far higher than the odds at NSA, and we've had a lot of espionage leaks over the years, plus actual leakers. Ya think that random Googlers would spy for NSA or feed them info? They are probably hundreds of Googlers with Top Secret clearance.
- rdl 13y ago"Top Secret" doesn't mean very much (either positively or negatively). It's being read into very specific special access programs which matter. Those can have populations from like 2 to thousands. I actually think the whole the USG handles classified information and clearances is broken -- it keeps too much secret from the public or businesses which could use it, AND fails to effectively keep essential-to-keep-secret stuff secret. It's borderline OK in operational DoD units other than NSA/intel/etc. (like, keeping maps and such secret), but other than that, it's horrible. Unlike the 1980s, they now have laughable internal security, where a contractor in the provinces gets superuser access (unlogged!) to the point where he can exfiltrate mad data, tamper with things, etc. There are commercial organizations who do a vastly better job with their secrets. I'm torn between wanting to fix this all by making technical controls much stronger, background checks more effective, etc., and wanting to let it collapse (because 90% of what is classified is overclassified, and a lot of the mission is either unnecessary or immoral, both in the general Eisenhower "every dollar spent on bombs is theft from humanity" and in the specific sense of violating civil liberties.