3 ms·
This sounds great, but would actually hurt the environment, not help it. Of all the things on this earth to recycle, glass is the very last one. The planet (th
by ars 13y ago
This sounds great, but would actually hurt the environment, not help it.
Of all the things on this earth to recycle, glass is the very last one. The planet (the crust anyway) is basically made of glass. (60.2% of the earth's surface, by mass, is glass.) It's, by far, the most plentiful raw element there is. Next closest is alumina at 15.2%.
Recycle it for some energy savings? Sure. But if you are going to waste water, and heat, for it you are really doing exactly the opposite of saving energy - not only are you wasting energy, you are wasting water, and time.
Pretty much the only things worth recycling are metals.
- kragen 13y agoGlass is not an element. Neither is alumina; alumina is a compound of two elements, aluminum and oxygen. Glass is a kind of solid which can be made of virtually any substance, including water, steel, and alumina. Very little of the earth's surface is actually made of glass (although some is: pumice and obsidian are glasses) but all of it could be made into glass. It's true that every recycling process uses energy and other resources. That's why the first choice is "reduce" — read your neighbor's newspaper instead of just sending it off to be pulped. The question is how much energy you're using, and how much the alternative non-recycling process would use. If you're comparing heating a bottle from 20° to 73° to sterilize it and heating it to 1400° to melt it, you will find that melting it uses, unsurprisingly, about 30 times as much energy as sterilizing it. It's going to take a heck of a lot of water desalination to make up for that much energy.
- ars 13y ago(When I said element I didn't mean it in it's chemical sense, but rather in the composition sense.) Glass is SiO2, and that is what the crust of the earth is made of. It's not amorphous, but that doesn't make any difference. To sterilize a bottle using water you have to heat water, not just glass. Water takes a huge amount of energy to heat. Your calculations are not as straightforward as you think. Plus heating something at home to sterilize it is not anywhere near as efficient as doing it in bulk. To melt glass takes 984.2 J/g. A glass bottle weights about 200g. So about 200kJ. That much energy will raise about 1kg of water 50 degrees. 1kg of water is about 1 liter. 1 liter of water is not enough to sterilize a glass bottle unless you had a perfectly shaped container to hold it. So final result: melting the glass uses less energy than sterilizing it. Plus no water. Plus the glass plant can probably recover most of the waste heat. Plus no need to wash the bottle. Plus no need to sort and transport to the original location. And now you know why almost no one does it: It's a bad idea.
- mmcnickle 13y agoYou're assuming the only energy in reforming a glass bottle comes from melting the glass and that industrial sterilisation submerges a bottle into fresh hot water, neither of which is true. As far as I know, industrial sterilisation uses very high pressure, high temperature steam or UV light for smaller operations.
- ars 13y agoYou still have to wash the bottle, and that's done with hot water. They probably make the homeowner do that, otherwise they would have some very dirty and stinky bottles by the time they got to them. That single action alone tips the energy balance, even before you go any further. (But of course the bottle maker doesn't pay for it....) I bet the steam is not recaptured because it prevents continuous operation of the line (you would need a pressure chamber with some kind of airlock). They probably do a batch, then open it and let the steam escape. So your steam is still very energy intensive, (and if you can recapture the heat energy in waste steam you can also do it for molten glass). And even if you got the energy stuff settled (which isn't going to be easy) this might work (barely) for high volume daily deliveries (milk is the classic example), but it would be hugely labor intensive for any other purpose - and labor also costs energy.
- mmcnickle 13y agoThe machines I've seen are essentially autoclaves, so sealed high pressure chambers. What you've expanded on is correct. The point I was trying to make was that at an industrial scale, the back of the envelope calculation you first presented isn't particularly useful in working out the energy delta between reusing vs recycling.
- kragen 13y agoIf you're washing a sink full of bottles, you're probably doing it in water that's around 45° (which you had to heat up from, say, 20°) and you're probably using more like a cup of water (250ml) per bottle, not a liter. I mean, my sink won't even hold 20 liters of water. Even if that water isn't usefully warming up your house, we're still talking about (45°-20°)×250ml/bottle×1 calorie/ml/° for more like 26 kJ per bottle. As for the steam, you only need enough steam to fill the bottle — perhaps one gram of steam per bottle, or a bit less. That costs you on the order of 600 calories, or about 2.5 kJ. Actually heating the bottle itself at 0.84 J/g/° will cost more than that; say that instead of heating to 73°, the minimum standard for food sterilization, you heat it to 150° with high-pressure steam. That's (150°-20°) × 200 g × 0.84 J/g/° = 22 kJ. So, assuming batch autoclaves like you said, with much higher temperatures than needed, with people washing their bottles at home in the sink, we have an energy cost of 26kJ + 2.5 kJ + 22kJ = 50kJ per bottle, compared to the 200kJ you calculated to recycle it. And that's why glass bottle reuse is widespread, even if perhaps not in your neighborhood: it saves energy. In my neighborhood, it's basically universal. Beer is always bought in returnable bottles here, and soft drink glass bottles are usually returnable. Why might it not be widespread in your neighborhood? Aside from the water-heating externality you suggest, I suspect that it's because you guys are spending extra energy to reduce labor costs, because labor is expensive where you are, especially when doing the labor means you have to deal with dirty, stinky bottles — even if occasionally. On the other hand, basically anything you do with a plastic bottle — whether you return it for reuse or throw it away, both of which are common in my neighborhood — is going to cost a great deal less energy. By the way, I'm really delighted to have a conversation here on HN that involves actual facts and calculation, along with careful consideration of the possibilities. Thank you for that.