3 ms·
is there anything Google could do or say to convince you that they are not, in fact, in cahoots with the NSA? First of all, I don't see it as a binary thing, w
by mindcrime 13y ago
is there anything Google could do or say to convince you that they are not, in fact, in cahoots with the NSA?
First of all, I don't see it as a binary thing, where I'm 100% convinced they are or 100% convinced they aren't. It's more like, "what's the probability that they are?" That said, they could lower my estimate of the probability that they are (in cahoots with the NSA), although perhaps not lower it to zero. But nothing they are likely to actually do.
For example, agreeing to an extensive audit of all of their internal systems, by a 3rd party organization which gets full access to everything inside Google for some period of time, including looking at source code. If somebody did that, and came back and said they found no signs of any kind of NSA tie-in, I'd be somewhat more convinced.
But, that's obviously not realistic and I won't be holding my breath for it to happen. :-)
- mcbutterbunz 13y agoLet me get this straight... You would trust Google MORE if they let a third party company come in and have full access to EVERYTHING? Source code and data? And whose to say that company isn't associated with the NSA or the Chinese government?
- jka 13y agoThis is what auditors exist for - to bolster trust - they get to ask the difficult questions, look at the systems and processes in place, and assess the behaviour of a company in order to reassure external parties (often investors). They do often genuinely have access to data and code, even if it is perhaps slightly rarer for them to bring the skills to truly interrogate them. The reliability of an auditor is based on their perceived level of trust in the community. As an investor, you want to be assured that your investment is worthwhile, so you want to work with an auditor that is thorough and highly confidential. If an auditor can be proven to have intentionally misled in the past, or to have worked with shady agencies / outside parties, that would be a very black mark against them and future business, so it should, ideally, not be in their best interests. Note that this does not except the behaviour of humans in practice, where short term gains of a person might not be aligned with their parent organization (c.f. banking).
- mindcrime 13y agoAnd whose to say that company isn't associated with the NSA or the Chinese government? That's the rub... you never really know. Especially when we have "secret government" with things like gag orders, secret laws, secret courts, etc. That's what makes all this so insidious.