3 ms·
> Basically the same idea as giving up on detailed long distance billing and going to flat rate. Where in this case the flat rate is about $5 on your property t
by jessriedel 13y ago
> Basically the same idea as giving up on detailed long distance billing and going to flat rate. Where in this case the flat rate is about $5 on your property tax bill.
Nope. The streetsblog.com article linked near the end says the MTA brings in three quarters of a billion dollars through bus fares. That's going to cost $100 per person in nyc. Yes there will be efficiency gains, but this will also be a billion dollar transfer from people who don't use the buses to people who do. (And remember, this is just the buses. Many people like myself use the subways everyday without hardly ever getting on a bus.) Yes this can be justified by arguments featuring externalities, but those arguments (being dwarfed by political feelings) will not play a role in deciding whether this plan is ever implemented.
- amiramir 13y agoIn the US and in NY we non-drivers subsidize automobile usage. The costs of building and maintaing road infrastructure are huge as are the costs of pollution and traffic. It's a form of transfer and a large one at that. As a New Yorker I don't have a car and as a Manhattanite I liked the proposed congestion charge that was nixed by Albany. As an aside, you may recall the revenue from the congestion charge was going to pay for improved transit in NYC. I'm not suggesting a race to the bottom in terms of justifying one transfer with another but the elephant in the room is private automobiles and their subsidies. Nor am I suggesting pay-for-use for everything. However free buses are a rounding error in that light and we need to seriously approach road pricing, congestion charges as part of a unified transportation system.
- jessriedel 13y agoOk. Note that I didn't argue against any of that.