3 ms·
Basically the same idea as giving up on detailed long distance billing and going to flat rate. Where in this case the flat rate is about $5 on your property ta
by VLM 13y ago
Basically the same idea as giving up on detailed long distance billing and going to flat rate. Where in this case the flat rate is about $5 on your property tax bill.
The good news is locally the bus service is approx 75% subsidized anyway, so they'd only "lose" 25% of revenue but the substantial gain of no more cash handling etc would help.
The other problem is you can tell the author lives in California. Where I live, the weather outdoors is at least somewhat foul about 10 months out of the year, so they would become rolling homeless shelters at least 10 months out of the year, maybe more by habit. That leads to even more expensive systems for what amounts to loitering ticketing, enforcement of no sleeping on the bus, etc.
The problem is this might even lead to politically sensitive ideas, like having enough homeless shelters to hold our homeless, or even having mental health treatment so our nuts are not just tossed out on the street as human debris until they die, instead we might try actually treating them. The criminal justice-industrial system would protest at the lack of revenue. It would be a little disruptive.
- sopooneo 13y agoFree buses would likely attract more riders, so the cost of providing the service would increase at the same time the 25% fare revenue disappeared. This does not counter your point, it just strikes me as a confounding issue.
- VLM 13y agoThe std deviation of utilization is pretty spectacular. You could play games with pricing where its free at 2pm when the bus usually only has 2 people, but it costs money at 5pm rush hour, or if there's an open seat its free but if you have to stand it costs, or something like that. Now that I think about it, I'm not a big drinker so I don't pay much attention, but a local brewer pays the fares on new years eve to keep the drunks off the roads, and despite claims that free fare = 20 times utilization, I'm just not seeing it.
- loceng 13y agoYou could assume that high traffic areas, at least during peak hours, would be considered healthy and productive environments - and whereby those people involved / using those services would be economic producers - which are needed - and therefore you would / should cover their costs overall with the tax base, as their activities are helping everyone in the society.
- wutbrodo 13y agoI'm not sure about those claims, but I don't think your examples is really a counterexample. The free fare --> drastically higher utilization argument seems like something that would apply more in the steady state; nobody is going to sell their car for the one day a year that fares are free, and one of the main advantages of taking a bus is erased if you already have a car.
- danielweber 13y agoits free at 2pm when the bus usually only has 2 people, but it costs money at 5pm rush hour If the goal is to pull people off the roads, you want to charge people a lot to be on the bus at 2pm, and nothing at 5pm. And a bus with 2 people probably shouldn't even be running. Get them two taxis.
- lmm 13y agoThe bus is already paid for and needed at rush hour; the driver needs a full-time job not two three-hour shifts at opposite ends of the day. It's probably better to run the bus. Longer-term what we need is more flexible working to spread out the rush hours, but for some reason that's a hard sell to american businesses.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- notatoad 13y agothat would be the point though, wouldn't it? This whole essay is based on the assumption that transit is cheaper overall than personal cars. the cost of providing transit service would increase, but the city's overall transportation budget should be neutral or improved.
- loceng 13y agoI've thought through some of what might happen if you eliminate the effects of the "class system." I think in some ways it would make more sense to artificially create them (while maintaining free services), though only if at the same time you're helping people improve their lives / take care of them. If you have a lot of homeless - uncared for (potentially having mental illness, smell, or other) - riding buses, etc. then less people will use those services - and that probably even happens now to some degree (higher care ownership when people might be okay with riding shared transportation if they knew there wasn't a certain chance of harassment or discomfort).
- jack-r-abbit 13y agoMost lines have a point that is designated as the "end". It would not be out of line (no pun intended) to say that everybody must exit the bus at the end of the line. For most people taking a bus from point A to Point B, that would not be an issue. But it might be enough hassle to keep some people from just riding it all day. It may not work but something might. Most of us are used to some amount of inconvenience when something is free. If you are taking your price down to zero, it can come with some rules. Edit: ok... maybe not THIS exactly... but some sort of rules. It is not the bus operator's job to find a place for homeless people to hang out.
- astrodust 13y agoYou don't have to be a hobo to want to get on the bus before the technical end of the line, just ride it there and back, to avoid waiting in cold or wet weather for the very same bus to arrive at the top on the other side of the street. Plus, people would just get off, and get right back on again. Some bus lines also have no defined end, they just go in a circle, making this impractical to enforce. Others have such a long run, taking hours, that it doesn't matter if there's an end or not. The better thing is to try and shunt the people on the bus to proper shelters, including those that can handle the more difficult variety of homeless person.
- VLM 13y agoThat would prevent sleeping, but would have issues with people stepping off and right back on. No particular reason to stop my grandma from stepping off the bus, spend 5 minutes pickup up prescription, then stepping back on, while the driver takes a mandated 15 minute break. The driver could look the other way, until statistical analysis shows a racial difference in rule enforcement or whatever, then it all hits the fan.
- sharkweek 13y agoI really like your last point -- Seattle is pretty "homeless friendly" in the big picture (rumors of other cities buying bus passes for their homeless to send them here have circulated for years). But there was a big debate when the county eliminated the "ride free" bus zone in downtown, which was a major transportation benefit for the homeless to catch rides to social services. When the county got rid of the ride free service, they stepped up with a transportation van that would loop once an hour between areas where the homeless congregated and loop around to the shelters, food banks, the Urban Rest Stop (free showers and laundry, no questions asked -- http://www.urbanreststop.org/ http://www.urbanreststop.org/), etc, still offering the homeless ease of access to these services, but also sort of "classifying" them on this bus as being very specifically in need. I'm not going to pretend to be an expert on the psychology of class designation, but I'd much prefer the homeless rode with the rest of the people in our city. I think it raises social awareness when you avoid segregation like this.
- jessriedel 13y ago> Basically the same idea as giving up on detailed long distance billing and going to flat rate. Where in this case the flat rate is about $5 on your property tax bill. Nope. The streetsblog.com article linked near the end says the MTA brings in three quarters of a billion dollars through bus fares. That's going to cost $100 per person in nyc. Yes there will be efficiency gains, but this will also be a billion dollar transfer from people who don't use the buses to people who do. (And remember, this is just the buses. Many people like myself use the subways everyday without hardly ever getting on a bus.) Yes this can be justified by arguments featuring externalities, but those arguments (being dwarfed by political feelings) will not play a role in deciding whether this plan is ever implemented.
- amiramir 13y agoIn the US and in NY we non-drivers subsidize automobile usage. The costs of building and maintaing road infrastructure are huge as are the costs of pollution and traffic. It's a form of transfer and a large one at that. As a New Yorker I don't have a car and as a Manhattanite I liked the proposed congestion charge that was nixed by Albany. As an aside, you may recall the revenue from the congestion charge was going to pay for improved transit in NYC. I'm not suggesting a race to the bottom in terms of justifying one transfer with another but the elephant in the room is private automobiles and their subsidies. Nor am I suggesting pay-for-use for everything. However free buses are a rounding error in that light and we need to seriously approach road pricing, congestion charges as part of a unified transportation system.
- jessriedel 13y agoOk. Note that I didn't argue against any of that.